494 replies to this topic

[Wolfpacks]

I have no night actions to give, my last vote was as I said listening to TWs reasoning his was flawed as was mine, i still not sure where you can count out Medved yet but I think it's between him, Gian, isoc and Canik, none have been overly active.

[GianMirell]

I am Town, my power is in my vote it said when I joined.

Voting for one of Wolfpacks, Isoc or Canik feels good to me. 

[Robert2424]

I can't really tell with your action brewers. I have to know what your role is and what was the result to make a call what exactly happened. A hider role is considered common, but not common at the same time. (common on mafia scum, everywhere else, rare to see). 

 

The problem is the following, we don't know exactly why there is no kill last night. Scum dose know. Why? because they know who they targeted. They either targeted TW, or Gian, and my money is on TW. 

 

but I am curious on something. 

 

@TW, do you have any restrictions on your role? like amount of times you can use it? 

[Robert2424]

btw, heres the mafia page for hider if anybody wants to see it. https://wiki.mafiascum.net/index.php?title=Hider

[The Warrior]

@Robert - The only role modifier I have is “Weak”. No restrictions on use.

[iSocialism]

TW so if you hide behind scum, you die, correct?

Glad is not cleared as town.

I'm also confused on Medved role, but why would he false role claim a strange role without just saying he was a doctor?

TW night actions do seem to be coincidental.

Who claim watcher, Robert correct?

[Robert2424]

Yes, I'm the watcher Isoc. 

[Lord MK]

@MK - I think we need further clarification on this and to be honest I'm not sure how you can actually clarify this for us without screwing one team or the other. The town needs to know if you would take a role from mafiawiki and give it a different name, even if that name is the name of an actual role from a mafia site other than mafiawiki. If so, then Medved could be telling the truth. If your roles are strictly from mafiawiki (name and description/use), then is means that Medved is either lying or extremely confused about his role.

I am not making an innocent child at any point.

For those of you who have a role, check your role PMs once more.
Except for the newbies, i gave everyone else a flavorised PM, and giving you a chance to figure out the role got yourself. For those who replied, i gave the actual role name.

[Lord MK]

"Heroes are made by the paths they choose, not the powers they are graced with."


Vote Count

iSocialism (1): Robert2424
The Warrior (0):
GianMirell (0):
Colonel Medved (0):
Canik (0):
Wolfpacks (0):
Robert2424 (0):
Brewersalliance (0):

No Lynch (0):

Not Voting: Colonel Medved, brewersalliance, The Warrior, GianMirell, Wolfpacks, Robert2424, Canik

with 8 alive, it takes 5 to lynch or 3 at deadline.

Deadline is on Sunday, September 30th, 2018 at 12 am CN time.

[brewersalliance]

 

@MK - I think we need further clarification on this and to be honest I'm not sure how you can actually clarify this for us without screwing one team or the other. The town needs to know if you would take a role from mafiawiki and give it a different name, even if that name is the name of an actual role from a mafia site other than mafiawiki. If so, then Medved could be telling the truth. If your roles are strictly from mafiawiki (name and description/use), then is means that Medved is either lying or extremely confused about his role.

I am not making an innocent child at any point.

For those of you who have a role, check your role PMs once more.
Except for the newbies, i gave everyone else a flavorised PM, and giving you a chance to figure out the role got yourself. For those who replied, i gave the actual role name.

 

 

So based on this, Medved could actually be a doctor and not a protector.  I can say from my own role PM, MK made it ambiguous without stating the name of my role directly, so I am thinking Medved's actual role might be doctor

also can someone get isoc and canik?  it feels like we havent heard from them in a very long time 

[brewersalliance]

I am Town, my power is in my vote it said when I joined.
Voting for one of Wolfpacks, Isoc or Canik feels good to me.

This to me makes me think Gian is town, as a VT that's what his role PM would say, and he is a brand new player so I would be very shocked if he came up with that all on his own.

Sure you're right he isn't cleared with MedVed protecting him, but this in my eyes makes me think he is most likely a VT

[Robert2424]

If TW wasn't a hider, we have to strongly consider Col Medved to be the role he says he is as its the only explanation on why there was no kill. However, the mafia trying to off TW is very likely. 

[brewersalliance]

I think MedVed is telling the truth.  Especially with MK's explanation that he gave flavor roles and not the actual role names.  So he could be doctor or possibly bodyguard.   BG makes more sense since what do they do?  They protect people, aka protector

[Colonel Medved]

I'm glad that everything is cleared up now. That being said, i'd like to give my two cents on the current situation.

 

It could be possible that i blocked the kill on GianMirell, since he could have been an easy target as a new mafia player and also the last kill of the game before scum win. I'm not sure if i would get a return message or not if i would prevent a kill, but i did not receive one in this case nor have i in the game so far. Or it could be possible that scum is plagued with inactive members and didn't post a kill before the deadline. That leads me also believe what brewers posted lately on his suspected players.

 

Canik has not posted in-game since the 13th, but i also know that Caniks playstyle is lurking, and only posting when he needs to. He has been called out quite a bit recently, and has not replied to anything so far. That leads me to believe that he is trying to lay low until the storm passes over. I think he is a safe bet for voting, this last vote is crucial to who will win. 

 

Vote: Canik

[Robert2424]

I guess, MK was super ambiguous about my last night action, saying only I met you brewers. What the crap is that supposed to even mean. I'm a watcher, the basic analogy is I sit in a tree somewhere and watched your door. He makes it sounded like you walked out of your house and we had a conversation in the middle of the night. Unless you visited me also last night. In witch case you would of been pleasantly surprised to see me I imagine. 

 

also Col Medved, thats MY INACTIVE MAFIA THEORY, NOT BREWERS. 

[Colonel Medved]

also Col Medved, thats MY INACTIVE MAFIA THEORY, NOT BREWERS. 

 

 

I wasn't saying the inactive theory was his, i was saying that i also believe his suspected players are scum (minus TW)

[The Warrior]

We need more out of Canik, iSoc, and Gian. This is not how Town play in a desperate situation with the game on the line. I am leaning towards voting for iSoc unless we see a real contribution soon.
@MK - will you please ping Canik?

[brewersalliance]

We need more out of Canik, iSoc, and Gian. This is not how Town play in a desperate situation with the game on the line. I am leaning towards voting for iSoc unless we see a real contribution soon.
@MK - will you please ping Canik?

This

 

though two of the three you mentioned are two of our top suspects and the third just joined the game and its his/her first ever.

 

so if anything we need to do isoc or canik today.  Im very sure both will turn scum (with wolfpacks probably the 3rd)

[iSocialism]

There's just something off to me about TW role claim.
It just seems perfectly a coincidence that he selected all town players. Though, sometimes that how it works when your a cop after 5 days.

TW why didn't you hide behind someone twice? We're you using your role more as an investigation role. If so, did you leave clues behind to show you found someone to be safe.

Also side thought, would any mafia roles not be detected/or whatever if TW hid behind them.

[Robert2424]

as far as I can tell and my understanding, he would die if he hid behind mafia. Reguardless of any modifier that the mafia hade.