322 replies to this topic

[iSocialism]

Too early for a vig strike IMO, probably a SK.

[Velocity]

Oh my, this is not good, if we can't work together the mafia and whoever else is killing will have us beat by day 3, by my predictions. This is not a good situation for us.

[Colonel Medved]

Looks like a SK is on the loose! On the bright side, at least it was only Vanilla deaths. It would have sucked even more to lose a PR on the first night.

[Robert2424]

somebody didn't care for how well I did last game it seems. I wanted to enjoy playing this one, and was doing research on the game. I'll remember this.

[Rafay]

So um took a pic of myself today

 

 

Survived trial by combat.

 

Not sure if there is a serial killer/vigilante as there were no faceless men in book 1. Maybe 2 factions. 

[Wolfpacks]

Two town lost and Rafay wins the trial, but does that make him town or is he scum, as it's random I'm guessing he could still be either.

[The Warrior]

It’s doubful that there are two scum factions in a 13 player game. It’s more likely a vig or SK. And again, unless we have a vig who was given instructions or some weird modifier that forced them to shoot on night 1, i think it’s more likely that a SK is present.

[Rafay]

Two town lost and Rafay wins the trial, but does that make him town or is he scum, as it's random I'm guessing he could still be either.

 

By the laws of gods and men and by the laws of trial by combat in Westeros, I'm innocent. 

[brewersalliance]

Two town lost and Rafay wins the trial, but does that make him town or is he scum, as it's random I'm guessing he could still be either.

By the laws of gods and men and by the laws of trial by combat in Westeros, I'm innocent.

Since this is something that's a new mechanic I basically made up on my own I will tell you this: the trial does not confirm any innocence or role alignment for rafay. Just because someone survives a trial by combat does not mean they are town, and likewise if they die, it does not mean they are scum

After all, the Hound survived his trial by combat, and he was guilty of murdering the butcher's boy Micha...

[The Warrior]

Confirmation that Rafay is indeed scum.

[KevinH]

17 Sister Midnight
15 Rafay
12 Wolfpacks
9  iSocialism
8  KevinH
7  The Warrior
7  Rhizoctonia
 6 Colonel Medved
6  Lord MK
5  Velocity
5  SeaBeeGipson

Vote: SeaBeeGipson

 

(because I know iSocialism loves it when I do that)

[Wolfpacks]

if in doubt vote Rafay out 

[Rafay]

Velocity and SBG seem to be the prime candidates right now. They are probably 0 on D2 posts as well.

[iSocialism]

What if people are so use to your meta Kevin, that instead, scum hide at the very top of the post count list!

[Wolfpacks]

What if people are so use to your meta Kevin, that instead, scum hide at the very top of the post count list!

Or they could be in the middle, not really drawing attention to themselves

[The Warrior]

Velocity and SBG seem to be the prime candidates right now. They are probably 0 on D2 posts as well.

Velocity actually did post today. ~10-11 posts before lthat although it was only a comment about us being two people down.

Basically nothing has happened on day 2 at this point. We need to get everyone talking.

@SBG - where you at bro?

[KevinH]

What if people are so use to your meta Kevin, that instead, scum hide at the very top of the post count list!

 

Scum shouldn't be able to hide at the top because townies should already be there.

The more people say, the easier it is to make a guess whether they are town or scum.

I'd rather eliminate the silent ones early, 

 

Based on experience, I believe that activity is independent of alignment.  

When someone gets busy in Real Life, they drop in Mafia activity; no judgement -- it happens.

But the probability of being scum is the same whether a person is active or not so much.

[SeaBeeGipson]

how is the trial of combat even done or do we have to endure it to find out?

[The Warrior]

We don’t know yet. I think I recall Brewers saying that he would tell us at some point, but maybe not until after the game?

[brewersalliance]

Vote Count 2.01

Colonel Medved (0)

iSocalism (0)

KevinH (0)

Lord MK (0)

Rafay (0)

Rhizoctonia (0)

SeaBeeGipson (1) KevinH

Sister Midnight (0)

The Warrior (0)

Velocity (0)

Wolfpacks (0)

 

Not Voting:  Colonel Medved, iSocialism, Lord MK, Rafay, Rhizoctonia, SeaBeeGipson, Sister Midnight, The Warrior, Velocity, Wolfpacks

 

Currently in Danger of Mod Kill:  Rhizoctonia, 0 Posts

 

With 11 alive it takes 6 to lynch or 3 at deadline.

Deadline is Sun, November 18th and 8:00pm CST