Every week I will post one of the cards (selected at random), and each participant writes a response to what they would do in that situation or how they might handle it. I will let the thread run for one week, and then post a new question. Post as much as you like after giving your response. Debating and analyzing is part of the game! I won't be playing as I am the one running the game.
There are no right or wrong answers as the game is about hearing how people could navigate a stressful or perilous situation.
Deck 2 - Survival Scenarios: Three of Spades
Your group has managed to survive a catastrophic event, and in fact, you are thriving. The group has many individuals with essential talents that have helped the group be successful. However, one day, your only gunsmith/blacksmith lets slip he was once convicted of child molestation. He has never given the group any hint of his past until now and has in fact been a core and valued member of the group. Do you forget his past and hope that his tendencies don't emerge again, or do you expel him from the group and lose his skill set?