Montosh

Perhaps a prod on kaz as well?

My opinion on the no-lynch debate has been take it as it comes with the day. If we have a lot of info by the end of the day provided by how people act, lynching probably won't provide much more and will just be an unnecessary loss. That being said, we're unlikely to get much info on Day 1. If we have very little info at the end of the day, lynching won't provide much either, as whoever it was that was lynched won't provide much info either, has we have nothing to go on. However, we have a lot of people, so that probably won't happen. If we have a fairly normal amount of info, then lynching is usually a good option. We have enough info to go on, but not so much that it will have been unnecessary to get more, compared to the loss of a townie. That being said, it's page two so i'm getting 1 random vote in at least. Lyner is here, and no one has voted for him Vote: Lyner

Huzzah!

A simple Bah! will suffice

Actual content(albeit suspicious content at times) > fluff Vote: Rafay

Rafay: Mostly posting fluff, not really posting much content but does seem to be reading the posts at least somewhat and he has voted for Kaz(although it's a really short explanation, it isn't a bad one necessarily. He's simply needs to explain that Kaz is trying to hard to lynch Imran based on little to no real info). This could be a case of apathy, scumminess or both. Kaz: Posting content, and whatever fluff he posts is outweighed by the analyses he posts. That said, his analyses contain a lot of him just grasping at straws, pointing out small, sometimes irrelevant details to try and convince others of his suspect's scumminess. That said(again), he does make some good points.

They sometimes are, at other times i'm just confused though

I pretty much completely agree with Imran's rebuttal you Kaz. Kaz, you seem to be going out of your way to make Imran seem suspicious. It is scummy and it's not getting you anywhere. I don't disagree with d3mon either, just because Rafay was the hammer doesn't make him town. It's the "too scummy to be scum" idea, which is ridiculous, because scum can easily play off that(ie being the hammer). That being said, it is unlikely for scum to hammer unless they feel like they have the town behind them, and even then it's not too likely. People were mostly on board with lynching Lyner, so I don't think it changes much either way in terms of Rafay. He posts mostly fluff(though I post little myself ), and lynched a townie. So, some scummy things there, but he isn't actively trying to paint someone as scum by basically grasping at straws. Also, Kevin's posts are really odd at times, and I don't know what to make of them. Well, if he is the chosen townie there's obviously that benefit. Additionally, if he suspects anyone that votes for him, why should others take heed of that specific suspicion. Unless the suspicion is backed by some evidence in behavior in posts, most townies won't really listen to it. That said, we can play the, "if I was scum I wouldn't do this, so doing this means i'm not scum" game all we want, it doesn't really add anything to the dynamic.

I'm cool like that. Also, i'm just somewhat less active here

That damn name filter. I'll post thoughts later today, but don't consider too closely who voted for Robert and all... scum knows we'll look at that and will use it against us to confuse.

II

I

EM + Kevin vs. Lyner + Kaz Imran + (maybe Robert) vs. Rafay. Just making notes on the "teams" as I see them sorta forming up. I agree with others though, Rafay hasn't been posting much content. This could just be apathy, it could be scummy, though it's probably not inactivity(he came out the moment he was called out, though that could be a coincidence). But, a little pressure never hurt anyone. Vote: Rafay Care to share any thoughts on the game Rafay?

I

Why so?

We can't no-lynch. Another Kevin/Lyner scum team would suck, but it's Kevin that continues to be pushing heavily for a lynch a little too early. Then again, we do have to lynch, and someone has to be the lynchee. Still, we can use up the day.

I agree with Rafay here, Kevin seems way to eager especially considering how we have two chosen townies to look after.

Very odd indeed.

Unvote: KevinH Not cool with having anyone on L-1 right now. You might say, "we'd lynch whoever did it". Ok, sure, or maybe they'd be really convincing, or even really a townie. You never know. I don't want to waste Day 1 in any case.

erm... Kevin, that's L-1 at page three after like a day(in RL). I say that's bad, and you should feel bad(and unvote).

We're all chosen inside(though not in the game). We have time, let's be careful.

Vote: KevinH We can't no-lynch. Whatcha gonna do?

I think this'll be a good one.