SirCrocodile

The chance of finding a mafia with the cop gets progressively bigger and bigger if the cop isn't killed. I'm guessing that the doc will protect the cop every night and the cop will investigate and possibly role-claim as to not get lynched. It's a fair argument, but the problem is that a majority has to vote no-lynch for this to work.

Your logic is sound and I can see where you're coming from, but there's an obvious flaw. None of us know for sure the order that the PMs were sent in. For all we know, the mod could have had something come up and he needed to leave the computer for a bit.

Where is the vote-count?

The last time I post-edited was when EM told me to stop.

You voted for me without a good reason in the beginning . You will be suspicious to me until you can explain why you did that.

I wanted a no-lynch earlier in the game, so I voted a no-lynch. That's all there is to the first time. The other two have explanations. fos:KF2001

BeeBs made a solid argument, so I went with it. Problem?

^this. vote: Imran Ehsan

Following that train of thought, I have to ask; we have little knowledge, only when people confirmed and who voted for who based on that. There is no real reason to vote for anybody, so a no lynch would be in place. The problem with that is that as Electric Mango said, a no lynch would leave us where we are today minus a few people who were night killed and possibly a cop investigation. A truly random lynch is best at the moment, with no real reason to accuse or defend and we all have to take a stand behind a single chosen victim or we will not get enough votes behind a single person to lynch. Who should be lynched? unvote

I edited out a double post. Is that suspicious?

Double posted. Oops.

What is that based on? I could have forgone checking the role PM for perhaps 3 hours and my role would not have changed any. How do you know I got my PM early? Maybe you just got one late. Maybe you chose not to respond as quickly as I did. That argument is invalid. You want to random lynch. That seems to be a bit suspicious mindset you have because if you're Mafia, you know who your allies are (Assuming they are a single faction) so you don't care who dies, just that a town dies.

unvote vote:kaziocore Solid arguments, but why did you vote for me?

That's how it was last game.

vote: No Lynch