Surely if we all follow them both, we could lynch them both??

Theo,

 

I was attacked day 1. There were only 2 people who could have done it. If it wasn't Chaos then it was SpecOps. We know this for sure so it's not too early at all for the town to take action. Why wait for the mafia to keep picking us off. Like I said, the worst we can do is kill one mafia and one townie, those seem like great odds to me. It's also funny that you are the only one against the lynch as you are also one of the other two people who are under suspicion from the other room.

 

Coincidence? Time will tell my friend.

 

Three things

 

I already submitted that it was in all likelihood Chaos that stabbed you. As you say the evidence seems to point to that. My question was simply would it be possible that he made a "stab in the dark" (pardon my pun here) and hopped for the best result. Granted he had little reason to act in such a way, especially if a townie, but that's why I'm asking if you guys think it possible.

 

I'm not against the lynch, just asking some follow up questions. If he is found to be scum, I'll be just as happy as any other townie; that however doesn't preclude me questioning this decision to get some additional answers.

 

I disagree, an opinion of one person doesn't make for me being suspicious. He could have just as well pointed to AKC, given how he made a simple guess on who attacked him. But as you say time will tell

Well first of all Welcome Back EM

 

now to the matter of hand

 

based on earlier suspicisions CH seems to have been found out

 

i don't think it nessecary for everyone to follow CH simply b/c there are probably still things to be found , wasting time isn't good no matter if a single mafia was determined.

 

so

 

Move to Kitchen

 

also sorry guys RL has been mean last couple of days

Just for consideration ...

 

Night actions spent attacking mean night actions not searching or watching.

There could be more med-kits or light switches to be found (or anything else).

I don't object to finally attacking those that are most suspicious, but we can always do it later rather than sooner.

 

I plan to search.

Just for consideration ...

 

Night actions spent attacking mean night actions not searching or watching.

There could be more med-kits or light switches to be found (or anything else).

I don't object to finally attacking those that are most suspicious, but we can always do it later rather than sooner.

 

I plan to search.

 

the longer we wait to kill scum the more chance they have to do something to seriously damage the town/put us behind. especially considering that there is probably more scum then just CH or Spec. if it's going to take 2 nights to kill someone that means it'll take like 4 or 5 or 6 nights to kill all the scum off, and that assuming we dont wrongly go after a townie(which is quite likely at some point int eh game).

 

the sooner we get rid of scum the better imo.

the sooner we get rid of scum the better imo.

 

I second this. Remember, this game is HP based, as long as a scum lives he can just keep doing damage to the townies.

hey EM...you mentioned you were attacked both nights. yet SpecOps claimed to have watched CH both nights and only saw him attack you night 1. which would make me think there is probably another mafia in that room that night(or Spec is lying and attacked you both nights).

 

thoughts on who it may be?

The 1st night the lights were off decreasing chances of discovery. Also watching does not guarantee 100 percent chance of success.

 

If it's not chaos it has to be spec ops because they were the only ones with me on night one.

The 1st night the lights were off decreasing chances of discovery. Also watching does not guarantee 100 percent chance of success.

 

If it's not chaos it has to be spec ops because they were the only ones with me on night one.

 

yet Spec Ops claims to have seen him attack you night 1 anyway. and night 2 the lights were on(or at least i'm assuming they turned on during the night) and he watched again. it stands to reason that the odds of seeing him would increase and he would have seen him attack you again if it was him.

EBWOP:

 

sorry my thoughts are a bit muddled.

 

basically, i find it odd that SpecOps would see CH attack you N1 with the lights off but doesnt see him attack you N2 with the lights on.

 

which makes me think that CH didnt attack you N2. meaning there's another mafia in the room.

 

either that or SpecOps attacked you both nights and is lying about what he saw.

If we find med-kits, we can keep healing and never lose a townie.

 

If there are more townies than scum, we have better chances overall of finding things.

If we find med-kits, we can keep healing and never lose a townie.

 

If there are more townies than scum, we have better chances overall of finding things.

 

that's assuming there are an infinite number of medkits, but i doubt that.

 

and proportionally we'd have more townies then scum if we did a 1-for-1 trade.

Ok well what I saw the other night, the first night when it was us three people, I saw chaos go rushing up to per (you now) and stab you and then run back to wherever he was, then the next night he was hit by a mage and that is all i know for now. Been watching him and I posted to everyone the first night that I was watching everyone so I couldnt have possibly stabbed per. (you) But I def saw choas the first night go rushing to you and stabbing ya.

 

 

This is what he saw n1 and n2 for the record.

Yes I assure you this is for the record that Ive seen on N1 and N2, what EM posted. I dont know why I didnt see him attack EM the second night but I saw him get attacked by a mage which im gonna assume its a vigilante helping us. I can pretty much assure that I would have to believe that Chaos is scum because he attacked EM without any reason. A townie does not attack another townie for s*#s and giggles knowing that this could help the scum win. Yes the lights were off the first night, I honestly believed that I wasnt gonna get anything at all considering my only action was watching everyone in the dark room, but by sheer happenstance I was lucky and saw chaos stab EM and run back to his area. However on the second night for some odd reason I did not see him attack EM and saw him get attacked by a mage.

 

Btw I recommend no one jump into this room as to avoid further confusion and I say everyone in the room originally if not one watching or one searching, jump chaos. I am sticking to my gut on this one. I can assure you I am a friendly!

Yes I assure you this is for the record that Ive seen on N1 and N2, what EM posted. I dont know why I didnt see him attack EM the second night but I saw him get attacked by a mage which im gonna assume its a vigilante helping us. I can pretty much assure that I would have to believe that Chaos is scum because he attacked EM without any reason. A townie does not attack another townie for s*#s and giggles knowing that this could help the scum win. Yes the lights were off the first night, I honestly believed that I wasnt gonna get anything at all considering my only action was watching everyone in the dark room, but by sheer happenstance I was lucky and saw chaos stab EM and run back to his area. However on the second night for some odd reason I did not see him attack EM and saw him get attacked by a mage.

 

Btw I recommend no one jump into this room as to avoid further confusion and I say everyone in the room originally if not one watching or one searching, jump chaos. I am sticking to my gut on this one. I can assure you I am a friendly!

 

so you saw him attack when it was dark but not when it was light. it just seems to me that if he had attacked the second night you would have seen it. which makes me think a second person attacked Perse/EM.

so you saw him attack when it was dark but not when it was light. it just seems to me that if he had attacked the second night you would have seen it. which makes me think a second person attacked Perse/EM.

Unless the mod left it out by accident? could that be it? considering this is a new game.. Could it be the lights were switched on after it happened?

 

If not these issues then who else was in the room besides me and em and chaos? because i wasn't paying atten. to any other extra person here. Cept chaos.

Unless the mod left it out by accident? could that be it? considering this is a new game.. Could it be the lights were switched on after it happened?

 

If not these issues then who else was in the room besides me and em and chaos? because i wasn't paying atten. to any other extra person here. Cept chaos.

Nvm the lights were off.. they never went on according to what happened, so it appears that I only saw a mage attack him but not him attacking em. because the room was so dark I couldnt see anything else. Unlike by sheer happenstance that i was lucky to see him stab em the first night in the darkness.

Nvm the lights were off.. they never went on according to what happened, so it appears that I only saw a mage attack him but not him attacking em. because the room was so dark I couldnt see anything else. Unlike by sheer happenstance that i was lucky to see him stab em the first night in the darkness.

 

i thought Kazio said he switched the lights back on in the main lobby?

i thought Kazio said he switched the lights back on in the main lobby?

He did but I guess they didnt come on fast enough. Because it was still dark when I saw a mage attack chaos.

We won't really know the whole truth.

It could be that the lights were on when you watched (increases chance but not necessarily 100%)

or it could be that the lights turning on would only benefit us the next day.

Even with reduced probabilities, it is worth it to search or watch and gather information.

Even with reduced probabilities, it is worth it to search or watch and gather information.

 

but how can you know that?

 

unless you know something we dont...

Even with reduced probabilities, it is worth it to search or watch and gather information.

 

So you're saying it's better to search or watch than to kill a suspect mafia right now?

The people who are not following CH could do that...

I don't have special information.

I found a med kit and then used it successfully.

I think the town will have a better chance of winning if we take that approach (most of us, anyway).