Nobody could "know" that I was scum.
Starting with 4 vigilantes and 3 scum made for an interesting setup but not conducive to typical play where a player is lynched and suspicion goes towards those that voted to lynch a townie.
Random vigilante shots without a plan and a guaranteed scum kill every night would have made it difficult for the town to win.
Nenos should have made his shot and the game should never reached the point where Rafay had to make a judgement between 2 players.
The flaw in the town's play was that my "random" assignment was not challenged. I got to pick the time when when the stock prices were quoted. If the arrangement at that time did not favor the scum, I would simply have picked another time.