Okay, so now THIS thread is open And we've got the normal day 1 start flurrying about already, complete with Kevin being... well, Kevin.

 

Only thing anyone knows on Day 1 is mafia knowing who mafia is... so let's start poking things and seeing what happens!

 

Vote: iSocialism

 

Because you did such a good job last game of making me suspect you that I still need to get it out of my system

Rhizoctonia? I see you looking, but not posting

The 25% figure is just a rough estimate of scum based on past games.

 

I imagine that there could be as few as 2 scum and 16 townies and still have it balanced.

If I were doing that I would make both scum Godfather-Ninja-Framers <evil grin>.

And you are one of them?

Long day at work, but happy to have a new mafia game up and started (sucked getting killed N2 last game, I feel you CoD).  Good to see people at least talking so far.  It's fluff day 1, but sometimes there are mistakes made we can pick up on hopefully.

Welcome, Rhizo!

Town points from me for Rhizo; just sounds townie to me...

Ok so on day one fluffiness is allowed but not after, see told you i learnt something lol

 

 

Oh btw

 

Unvote Finster

 

Vote no lynch

Lets bandwagon; Kevin has a valid point that my figures are only guess work.

 

Vote no-lynch

 

I don't want this day to end too fast. Let's see who makes mistakes.

 

 

Sister Midnight, Canik, all the rest?

Ah yes, the time-honored no-lynch debate. I was never fully in favor of that - if we were going to simply no-lynch from the outset why have day 1 at all, and not just start off with scum getting a first swipe at us? Odds of failure may be high, but we'll still gain voting information to begin with.

 

That said, we're still clearly in the 'fluff' phase of the day, and need to make sure everyone at least says SOMETHING so the game is really underway.

 

-Preston

I say we keep posting, so when someone comes homes and check the forums. They see mafia has 8 pages that needs to be read. 

I do suspect Death a bit. Lego voted me to see my reaction, and Death jumped in for some reason, prompting my response which both unvoted, with Lego saying I sounded like a Townie. Death could be starting a bandwagon on me. I personally think that there could be 5, possibly 6 scum.

VOTE:  LEGO

 

due to inappropiate use of humor before start of game.

I do suspect Death a bit. Lego voted me to see my reaction, and Death jumped in for some reason, prompting my response which both unvoted, with Lego saying I sounded like a Townie. Death could be starting a bandwagon on me. I personally think that there could be 5, possibly 6 scum.

*shakes head* i was doing it out of a joke, he said to welcome you to your first time in mafia with a vote. To which I added my vote as a joke saying to welcome you with a vote instead of me, because it's my first time too, I thought D1 was about joking around and prodding 

Also, to Town: Lynching is better than not lynching. If we NL, we let mafia get a free kill on us. Even if we lynch one of our own, we still have a chance to hit a scum. NL = 0% hitting scum, scum get a free kill on us in the night. Lynch anyone and we can at least kill a scum. And Death, now that I look at it, I rescind my previous post. 

Unvote Samus

 

Vote: Wolfpacks

 

Come on bro, I can manage a baby and play mafia.

VOTE: LEGO

 

due to inappropiate use of humor before start of game.

😂

Wrong emoticon, cannot edit now.

 

FWIW Motorola Samsung keyboard emoticons may be used.

Also, to Town: Lynching is better than not lynching. If we NL, we let mafia get a free kill on us. Even if we lynch one of our own, we still have a chance to hit a scum. NL = 0% hitting scum, scum get a free kill on us in the night. Lynch anyone and we can at least kill a scum. And Death, now that I look at it, I rescind my previous post.

Why the NL vote then? Did you not vote no lynch before?

Besides that joke in the beginning I'm personally voting NL until I feel I have significant proof

I'm NL until everyone comes up and says something. Want to see if anyone looks scummy.

Good idea.

Also, to Town: Lynching is better than not lynching. If we NL, we let mafia get a free kill on us. Even if we lynch one of our own, we still have a chance to hit a scum. NL = 0% hitting scum, scum get a free kill on us in the night. Lynch anyone and we can at least kill a scum. And Death, now that I look at it, I rescind my previous post. 

You know how low that chance is? If we played mafia in real life, would you really hang a human because there was a small chance he could be scum? I wouldn't, I would only make that decision if there was enough evidence to convince me it was the right decision, but i'm sure mafia wouldn't mind that.

 

1ceCream, first suspect for me.

Based on his second post just above mine, Samus, I think he is doing the right thing. If someone acts scummy, we should lynch them, rather than no-lynch 'because we could lynch a townie'.

 

You could lynch me, for example. I know my VT role claim must look suspicious for being so early. For the sake of Hogwarts, I hope you will not

Based on his second post just above mine, Samus, I think he is doing the right thing. If someone acts scummy, we should lynch them, rather than no-lynch 'because we could lynch a townie'.

 

You could lynch me, for example. I know my VT role claim must look suspicious for being so early. For the sake of Hogwarts, I hope you will not

Not gonna lie you really sound like your trying too hard to sound like a townie

Maybe because I am town?

 

Anyway, overall, you and 1ceCream seem normal. I was suspicious of your icecream vote though.

 

SM... joke vote. Needs to post more.

 

Preston comes as being towny.

 

Kevin... not sure. I will have to see.

 

Samus... nothing to go on yet, suspects 1ceCream. Trying to start a wagon on noobs?

 

Mandarijn... comes across as town.

 

iSoc - too early to say

 

Rhizo -- townie or a very good scum

 

Wolfpacks - no lynch, towny points for that. Needs to post more

 

Finster - see SM

 

COD - see SM

 

 

ABT, Canik, Lyner, Maz, Rafay -- NO POST

 

 

Overall, way too early to form suspicion, just my feelings.

 

 

I was suspicious of your icecream vote though.

 thus the reason I clarified it above and 1ceCream gets it was all in good fun

Samus, I know that lynching right now would be pretty hard to accurately hunt scum. I know the morals aren't exactly great. Honestly, right now I'm waiting for something scummy. Still NL.