622 replies to this topic

[Wolfpacks]

 

Why are you trying to kill me?

 

 

Sounds like he is directly talking about himself and not Robert to me

 

i see your point

[Sister Midnight]

You're information is heavily flawed here. I wasn't on velocity's wagon as there never even was one. Kevin used a random stock to shoot him

As for Robert I never started that one either, I voted at the very end

As for you, yes I was the first person to vote on you, and yes I tried to get TW to place a vote, as I have been trying to get every other person in the game to place votes this entire time.

If I was scum partners with TW, the last thing I would want is him to follow my vote on you.

So basically your first few reasons/argumebts are based on incorrect assumptions from the previous days.

On the plus side, we do have two missed shots we can play with so if Robert does shoot me it's not the end of the world, as yes he would die but I do have a pretty good feeling about who is scum, so I'm very certain at least my first shot would connect.

But I do agree with you on the first part where TW was fingering you, that's one of the main reasons I switched to SBG. With only needing one more missed shot (before TW died), I don't think he would have been bussing from scum as he would most likely have been trying to get a townie killed, so him having a little bit of a hard on for SM does make me think she might be town at this point. Still not 100% cleared (as lach is the only non suspect to me) but less likely scum than sbg, rafay, or wp

Why are you trying to kill me?

 
 
Sounds like he is directly talking about himself and not Robert to me

Still playing catch up, but that seems like something anyone would say if they were used to conventional mafia and forgot this is popcorn. You have said it is fine if Robert shoots you because you know who is scum and you will make all the right choices. Given thspat I am town and you tried to start a bandwagon on me that does not seem promising. I am not defending SBG, I find his inactivity to be scummy, but you look quite scummy as well.

[brewersalliance]

 

You're information is heavily flawed here. I wasn't on velocity's wagon as there never even was one. Kevin used a random stock to shoot him

As for Robert I never started that one either, I voted at the very end

As for you, yes I was the first person to vote on you, and yes I tried to get TW to place a vote, as I have been trying to get every other person in the game to place votes this entire time.

If I was scum partners with TW, the last thing I would want is him to follow my vote on you.

So basically your first few reasons/argumebts are based on incorrect assumptions from the previous days.

On the plus side, we do have two missed shots we can play with so if Robert does shoot me it's not the end of the world, as yes he would die but I do have a pretty good feeling about who is scum, so I'm very certain at least my first shot would connect.

But I do agree with you on the first part where TW was fingering you, that's one of the main reasons I switched to SBG. With only needing one more missed shot (before TW died), I don't think he would have been bussing from scum as he would most likely have been trying to get a townie killed, so him having a little bit of a hard on for SM does make me think she might be town at this point. Still not 100% cleared (as lach is the only non suspect to me) but less likely scum than sbg, rafay, or wp

 

Why are you trying to kill me?

 
 
Sounds like he is directly talking about himself and not Robert to me

Still playing catch up, but that seems like something anyone would say if they were used to conventional mafia and forgot this is popcorn. You have said it is fine if Robert shoots you because you know who is scum and you will make all the right choices. Given thspat I am town and you tried to start a bandwagon on me that does not seem promising. I am not defending SBG, I find his inactivity to be scummy, but you look quite scummy as well.

 

by using your own logic that means that you are saying you would be scum as well. you are saying I am scum because I suggested you should be shot yesterday, and now you are doing the same to me.  So how does that make me scum but you town? . so your argument here is basically a logical fallacy lol   I didnt say its fine if robert shoots me, i said its not the end of the world because I am going to shoot SBG, and i am confident beyond all reasonable doubt that he is indeed scum.  Stop trying to twist my words.  Your entire initial accusation of me was based on pretty much inaccuracies since the previous day, which by the way, I noticed you have decided to completely ignore here.    TW being scum and suggesting that you might be scum has lead me to think you are probably town, but suggesting I be shot and using straight up falsehoods as your reasoning behind it does not feel like something town would do.  It may just be you dont want to read back through the previous posts (if you did you would see outside of me saying I think you are scum, the other stuff just isnt true)

 

 

With that being said, SBG is still the right call in my mind.

 

When is the deadline?  Can we at least get people voting today? So far just SM and I have voted I think. Sure we can just roll die again, but that legit just takes away the point of playing the game.  Otherwise medved should have just flipped a coin and said oh heads, town wins tails scum wins.  

[Sister Midnight]

[quote name="brewersalliance" post="957276" timestamp="1540410315"][quote name="Sister Midnight" post="957273" timestamp="1540409114"]
 
When is the deadline?  Can we at least get people voting today? So far just SM and I have voted I think. Sure we can just roll die again, but that legit just takes away the point of playing the game.  Otherwise medved should have just flipped a coin and said oh heads, town wins tails scum wins.  [/quote]

I fully agree with this. Why am I bothering to try to figure things out if it is all random and only one other person is posting?
Addendum- I mean 2 other people are posting.

[Robert2424]

Keep in mind if you are not voting your on my list to shoot

[brewersalliance]

when are you making the shit

shot lol  i dont need to know when you are taking a shit

also, in case anyone cares

 

brewersalliance 97 Robert2424 56 Sister Midnight 37 The Warrior 31 Wolfpacks 27 Colonel Medved 26 Velocity 23 Lachiton 19 KevinH 19 Rafay 18 SeaBeeGipson 17 Lord MK 16

[Sister Midnight]

Kev has posted more than Rafay AND SBG? Wow!

UNVOTE

[brewersalliance]

and MK, who died D1, is only 1 post behind them... granted he is pretty talkative for a dead guy lol

[Sister Midnight]

New post:

@CM, could you please define inactive? My voting was based partially upon how active people have been. I am starting to think you may have a different definition of inactivity from me.

and MK, who died D1, is only 1 post behind them... granted he is pretty talkative for a dead guy lol

Lol

[Lord MK]

and MK, who died D1, is only 1 post behind them... granted he is pretty talkative for a dead guy lol

Have you seen that old movie called Return of the Jedi?
I am a force ghost.

[Wolfpacks]

As I've said inactivity doesn't always equate to scumminess, i think we will have a active scum and a inactive scum, brewers and Lachiton fit the bill, but so does SM and Rafay, you never know with Rafay as he plays like that all the time, same as Brewers is always active. Also SBG is playing not like his usual self and my gut is saying town.

Fos Brewers and Lachiton

[Lachiton]

Inactivity doesn't equal to scum but given the circumstances, scum will likely try to post the bare minimum stuff and then jump on a town's assumption if that can steer the suspicion to another townie's direction. We saw the same with TW who found out a convenient excuse to jump on Robert and followed my vote on him. Also TW was leading the scum charge by poking at others, pretending to help town.
 
If you're town, use your common sense and tell me will a scum post the following as his very first post, in a game with no investigative roles and no lynches?

I guess we can vote but the person wont be lynched. My role PM says my weapon is my vote, not sure what's going on with that.

You do realize how stupid that play would have been if I was scum. If Medved had sent a different role PM to town members which doesn't mention vote as your weapon (and that shouldn't have been mentioned, Medved confirmed it he forgot to change the text), I would have just given Kevin a clear target to shoot at. I cant quote my role PM as is, as thats against game rules, so I took the one thing which didnt match exactly with the setup but still was included in the PM and subtly put it out so that gunbearer knows not to shoot a fellow town and the odds of hitting actual scum increases.

 

Casting aspersions on me is going to be the perfect scum strategy because with me there along with the gunbearer, there will be 2 confirmed town as opposed to if I become the gunbearer. IIRC TW too tried to doubt my town credentials as well saying the wording is present in mafiascum wiki but when both me and brewers pointed out that something being there in the wiki doesn't mean Medved wont change it, he backtracked immediately. So it was already tried once by a known scum, so it makes sense if it is being tried again by his alive scum partners.

[Lachiton]

As for this SBG debate, it's difficult to pinpoint since he has not posted much on anything except voting twice for WP, now suddenly in agreement with WP and finds me as suspected scum. I think he was the first one to comment on my post where I subtly put out words from my role PM and said he believed I am town as scum wont receive that message, so on what basis or new information is he making a U-turn on his own assumptions? Also his defense against brewers' very strong push against him has been very weak. 

[Colonel Medved]

@CM, could you please define inactive? My voting was based partially upon how active people have been. I am starting to think you may have a different definition of inactivity from me.

 

 

My current activity stance is post related. If you go more than 72 hours without making a post then you may be force-replaced.

 

This is the current activity of the game

 

brewersalliance - October 25th

SeaBeeGipson - October 23rd

Robert2424 - October 24th

Lachiton - October 25th

Wolfpacks - October 25th

Rafay - October 22nd (11:17AM, EST)

Sister Midnight - October 25th

 

As of right now, Rafay is at 72 hours since his last post. I will send him his last warning (since this is his second reminder), if he doesn't return within the next 24 hours i will replace him. If he does come back and goes inactive again, i will replace him. 

 

That also means that if SBG doesn't reply tomorrow then he will be in the same boat.

 

If you feel that a player is just fluff posting to not get replaced then please bring it to my attention. I sleep during the day, and only check the thread to check on votes or shooting actions. I don't have much time as of right now to read through all of the posts sadly. If it warrants a replacement then i will look into it

Edited by Colonel Medved, 25 October 2018 - 03:45 PM.
Added fluff posting

[Sister Midnight]

@CM, could you please define inactive? My voting was based partially upon how active people have been. I am starting to think you may have a different definition of inactivity from me.

 
 
My current activity stance is post related. If you go more than 72 hours without making a post then you may be force-replaced.
 
This is the current activity of the game
 
brewersalliance - October 25th
SeaBeeGipson - October 23rd
Robert2424 - October 24th
Lachiton - October 25th
Wolfpacks - October 25th
Rafay - October 22nd (11:17AM, EST)
Sister Midnight - October 25th
 
As of right now, Rafay is at 72 hours since his last post. I will send him his last warning (since this is his second reminder), if he doesn't return within the next 24 hours i will replace him. If he does come back and goes inactive again, i will replace him.
 
That also means that if SBG doesn't reply tomorrow then he will be in the same boat.

That seems fair. Thanks for clarifying.

[Colonel Medved]

No problem, i also added onto what i posted since you commented

[Colonel Medved]

Suspicion Count

 

 

"I'm a mog - half man, half dog. I'm my own best friend."

- Barf

 

brewersalliance (0):

SeaBeeGipson (1): brewersalliance

Robert2424 (0): 

Lachiton (0):

Wolfpacks (0): 

Rafay (0): 

Sister Midnight (0): 

 

 

Not Voting: SeaBeeGipson, Robert2424, Lachiton, Wolfpacks, Rafay, Sister Midnight

 

Deadline is October 29th, 9:00AM CN for Robert2424 to Shoot

[brewersalliance]

Alright we have four days. Everyone has plenty of time to vote. If you don't vote well then why even play?

[Rafay]

Vote: brewsersalliance

 

He's been active with The Warrior and they agreed on most parts so that's why I've been suspicious of him. And even if I'm wrong, which I'm pretty much not, then the gun will be in the hands of an active player.

[Robert2424]

Speak of the......