232 replies to this topic

[Colonel Medved]

 

FOS:  Kaz

 

Kaziocore (3): KevinH, brewersalliance, Finster Baby

 

Finster did a FoS not a vote 

 

 

Fixed, Thanks

[SealTeamPi]

 

I mean the victory condition for the townies is to survive. Saying that a mafia dude went down increases my chances at winning.

 

No I meant the reason for voting Kevin. Explain why you voted. Any particular reason? 

 

 

KevinH was who I voted for last round prior to changing to Eogrim due to activity. This was based around the questioning his intentions to clarify the rules. Many thought this was him trying to distance himself.

[Finster Baby]

My random vote was Lord MK until I moved to Eogrim only because of inactivity.  I gave MK the benefit of the doubt after he posted a couple of times right before deadline; he's gone silent again, which has my suspicion up.

 

Kaz just seems to be sending me a negative vibe.  Its why I only FOS'ed him as opposed to voting.  I can't explain the vibe, just that I have one.

[Kaziocore]

Town:
Eogrim
iSocialism
Kaziocore - of course

Mafia A:
XXX
XXX

Mafia B:
Canik
XXX

Remaining:
SealTeamPi
Finster Baby
KevinH
The Warrior
Robert2424
Rafay
Wolfpacks
brewersalliance
Lord MK

---

 

Kaziocore (2): Canik, brewersalliance

Canik (1): iSocialism

 
 
iSocialism was a threat to Canik (Mafia Goon B ) so they killed him.
Why was Canik killed? He was a threat to Kaziocore (Mafia Goon A ).

Vote: Kaziocore

 

I fail to see your logic. If I'm scum, why would I kill Canik?

There are much more better alternatives to killing Canik—for example, you because you're active or brewersalliance who actually started the vote wagon against me.

 

You're discounting the possibility that Canik (Mafia could have targetted the paranoid gun owner.

 

---

So far here's my guess

 

Vote: Robert2424

 

Possible distancing

https://ironcentral.org/community/topic/63736-cm-04-iron-ice-cream-mafia-day-2/?p=987417

 

Canik FOSes Robert2424, Rafay, iSocialism

https://ironcentral.org/community/topic/63736-cm-04-iron-ice-cream-mafia-day-2/?p=987450

 

Suprisingly, no one bothered to notice that this could be scum pretending that they didn't know that there are 4 mafia members.

https://ironcentral.org/community/topic/63736-cm-04-iron-ice-cream-mafia-day-2/?p=987530

 

Just a vote for one an inactive player. My gut tells me that this means that Lord MK is town but he's just active

This is different from my situation because I voted Lord MK because I am in danger of getting lynched on D1

https://ironcentral.org/community/topic/63736-cm-04-iron-ice-cream-mafia-day-2/?p=987651

 

Vote for inactive player

https://ironcentral.org/community/topic/63736-cm-04-iron-ice-cream-mafia-day-2/?p=987743

 

In conclusion, I believe Robert is from Mafia B which leaves us with Mafia A.

 

---

 

I have a few suspicions but currently my FOSes are:

1. SealTeamPi - mostly fluff posts to appear active

2. Finster - I actually found it suspicious that he only FOSed me as opposed to voting and he's being vague for his exact reasons. If he's scum, he's scared that he would be part of a wagon against a townie when I'm lynched OR he's scum and thinks I'm scum from another mafia group and he wants townie points when I get lynched and it will reveal that I'm scum.

 

 

 

[brewersalliance]

There are much more better alternatives to killing Canik—for example, you because you're active or brewersalliance who actually started the vote wagon against me.

 

if you are scum thank you for not killing me lol 

[Rafay]

if you are scum thank you for not killing me lol 

 

What if you're scum?? 

[SealTeamPi]

I have a few suspicions but currently my FOSes are:

1. SealTeamPi - mostly fluff posts to appear active

2. Finster - I actually found it suspicious that he only FOSed me as opposed to voting and he's being vague for his exact reasons. If he's scum, he's scared that he would be part of a wagon against a townie when I'm lynched OR he's scum and thinks I'm scum from another mafia group and he wants townie points when I get lynched and it will reveal that I'm scum.

 

Just to clear up my mostly fluff posts, This is my first mafia game, so I don't really know strategies and what types of discussions occur. So, I'm just trying to learn. 

[KevinH]

Mafia A:
XXX
XXX

Mafia B:
Canik
XXX

...

I fail to see your logic. If I'm scum, why would I kill Canik?
There are much more better alternatives to killing Canik—for example, you because you're active or brewersalliance who actually started the vote wagon against me.
 
You're discounting the possibility that Canik (Mafia B ) could have targetted the paranoid gun owner.

 
 

iSocialism, Pistachio Ice Cream (Vanilla Town) was melted on Night 1
 
Canik, Maraschino Cherries (Mafia Goon B ) was thrown away on Night 1

 
 

 

Kaziocore (2): Canik, brewersalliance

Canik (1): iSocialism

 
 
iSocialism was a threat to Canik (Mafia Goon B ) so they killed him.
Why was Canik killed? He was a threat to Kaziocore (Mafia Goon A ).

 

 
To further explain my logic, just suppose ...

Mafia A:

• Kaziocore
• Goon A2

Mafia B:

• Canik
• Goon B2

The conversation last night:

• In the lair of Mafia B, Canik said, "Hey, iSocialism voted for me, let's target him for night-kill."
• In the lair of Mafia A, Kaziocore said, "Hey, Canik voted for me, let's target him for night-kill."

Also, if Canik targeted the Paranoid Gun Owner, they would both be dead with roles revealed. iSocialism was revealed to be Vanilla Townie.

[brewersalliance]

 

if you are scum thank you for not killing me lol 

 

What if you're scum?? 

 

shit.  mind = blown

 

vote: brewersalliance

 

scum confirmed, he didnt die n1

[Finster Baby]

I only FOSed you because I didn’t have enough information to definitely vote for you. While you’ve provided an explanation, I’m not sure I’m ready to lift the FOS or not. Again, there is something about your posts that is giving me pause to continue pressuring you to further explain.

FOS remains on Kaz.

[Colonel Medved]

Vote Count

 

 

SealTeamPi (0): 

Finster Baby (0):

Kaziocore (2): KevinH, brewersalliance

KevinH (1): SealTeamPi

The Warrior (0):

Robert2424 (1): Kaziocore

Rafay (0):

Wolfpacks (0):

brewersalliance (0): brewersalliance

Lord MK (0):

 

 

 

Not Voting: The Warrior, Robert2424, Rafay, Wolfpacks, Lord MK, Finster Baby

 

 

With 10 alive it takes 6 to lynch or 3 at deadline.

Deadline is November 7th at 7:00pm CN

 

[Lord MK]

So we will lynch one person today, and then have another go, without scum having another go? 😅

This is getting a bit confusing.

[Rafay]

So we will lynch one person today, and then have another go, without scum having another go? This is getting a bit confusing.

 

Yes thats correct.

 

Whats confusing you? 

[brewersalliance]

Where is TW? He's gonna get mod killed

[Lord MK]

So we will lynch one person today, and then have another go, without scum having another go? This is getting a bit confusing.

Yes thats correct.

Whats confusing you?

About what happens in between

[Rafay]

About what happens in between

 

Day 2 ends and without a gap Day 3 starts.  

[The Warrior]

Where is TW? He's gonna get mod killed

 

I am having some health issues that I'm trying to figure out right now.. so this is the first time I've been on the forums since last week unfortunately.

 

Glad to see that one scum was knocked out last night. That puts us in pretty good shape, especially since there isn't a night phase at the end of day 2.

 

 

So we will lynch one person today, and then have another go, without scum having another go?

This is getting a bit confusing.

 

I don't quite understand what's causing your confusion either. It seems pretty clear that we just skip night 2 after the day ends:

 

Due to a Mafia member being killed during the night, Night 2 will be skipped!

[Wolfpacks]

I have limited internet access through the day so can only post at night, will try and keep up the best I can

[SealTeamPi]

Its been intersting to see Kaz not appear to defend himself. But this is probably due to activity more than anything.

[Wolfpacks]

Town:
Eogrim
iSocialism
Kaziocore - of course

Mafia A:
XXX
XXX

Mafia B:
Canik
XXX

Remaining:
SealTeamPi
Finster Baby
KevinH
The Warrior
Robert2424
Rafay
Wolfpacks
brewersalliance
Lord MK

---

Kaziocore (2): Canik, brewersalliance

Canik (1): iSocialism

iSocialism was a threat to Canik (Mafia Goon B ) so they killed him.
Why was Canik killed? He was a threat to Kaziocore (Mafia Goon A ).

Vote: Kaziocore

I fail to see your logic. If I'm scum, why would I kill Canik?
There are much more better alternatives to killing Canik—for example, you because you're active or brewersalliance who actually started the vote wagon against me.

You're discounting the possibility that Canik (Mafia could have targetted the paranoid gun owner.

---
So far here's my guess

Vote: Robert2424

Possible distancing
https://ironcentral.org/community/topic/63736-cm-04-iron-ice-cream-mafia-day-2/?p=987417

Canik FOSes Robert2424, Rafay, iSocialism
https://ironcentral.org/community/topic/63736-cm-04-iron-ice-cream-mafia-day-2/?p=987450

Suprisingly, no one bothered to notice that this could be scum pretending that they didn't know that there are 4 mafia members.
https://ironcentral.org/community/topic/63736-cm-04-iron-ice-cream-mafia-day-2/?p=987530

Just a vote for one an inactive player. My gut tells me that this means that Lord MK is town but he's just active
This is different from my situation because I voted Lord MK because I am in danger of getting lynched on D1
https://ironcentral.org/community/topic/63736-cm-04-iron-ice-cream-mafia-day-2/?p=987651

Vote for inactive player
https://ironcentral.org/community/topic/63736-cm-04-iron-ice-cream-mafia-day-2/?p=987743

In conclusion, I believe Robert is from Mafia B which leaves us with Mafia A.

---

I have a few suspicions but currently my FOSes are:
1. SealTeamPi - mostly fluff posts to appear active
2. Finster - I actually found it suspicious that he only FOSed me as opposed to voting and he's being vague for his exact reasons. If he's scum, he's scared that he would be part of a wagon against a townie when I'm lynched OR he's scum and thinks I'm scum from another mafia group and he wants townie points when I get lynched and it will reveal that I'm scum.

He kinda did lol