612 replies to this topic

[Chaplain of death]

Well since the Robert wagon was based on inactivity and hes been replaced, and I'm not sold on if ABT is scum or not, I'm going with my other suspicion from D1.

 

Vote: Ferastical

[Tony Maurice]

It’s a good point chaplain and I see your point lww.

 

can we get a vote count MK? I’m considering voting ferastical as well.

[Lord MK]

Vote Count

Ali Bin Turban (4): Kevin, Ferastical, Tony, baby
KevinH (2): brewers, limey
Ferastical (1): CoD
Velocity (0):
Tony Maurice (0):
Chaplain of Death (0):
Brewersalliance (0):
Lyner (0):
lilweirdward (0):
Dontavian (0):
Finster Baby (0):

No Lynch (1): Lilywad

Not voting: Velocity, Abt, Dontavian ❤️

With 11 alive, it takes 6 to lynch or 4 at deadline.
Deadline is Sunday, November 15 at 0000 UTC.

Post Count

brewersalliance 36 (12)
lilweirdward 33 (16)
Ali bin Turban 32 (19)
Finster Baby 31 (14)
KevinH 29 (15)
Tony Maurice 28 (16)
Dontavian 27 (12)
Ferastical 22 (13)
Chaplain of death 20 (20)
Lyner 18 (10)
Velocity 9 (9)

Nice, everyone had high activity levels.
The day average is 14, double the requirement and brewers didn't skew it this time.

[Lord MK]

Ali Bin Turban (4): Kevin, Ferastical, Tony, Baby

Ali Bin Turban, Vanilla Townie, was lynched on Day 2.

It is now Night 2.
Please submit all night actions before Wednesday, 19 November 2020, 0000 UTC.

[Lord MK]

KevinH, Vanilla Townie, was killed on Night 2.

Chaplain of Death, Vanilla Townie, was shot on Night 2.

Night 2 ends.

It is now Day 3.

Vote Count

Ferastical (0):
Velocity (0):
Tony Maurice (0):
Brewersalliance (0):
Lyner (0):
lilweirdward (0):
Dontavian (0):
Finster Baby (0):

No Lynch (0):

Not voting: Velocity, Dontavian ❤️, Lilywad, brewers, limey, Ferastical, Tony, baby

With 8 alive, it takes 5 to lynch or 3 at deadline.
Deadline is Wednesday, November 25 at 0000 UTC.

[Dontavian]

Things are going well so far...except for Town 

 

5 Townies to 1 Scum is not a sustainable trend

[Ferastical]

Chaplain of Death, Vanilla Townie, was shot on Night 2.

 

Goddamn, I knew it, those bastards are going to frame me... again! The last posts on D2 are literally about CoD sussing me. I swear, I had nothing to do with this.

[lilweirdward]

Based on the fact that it shows Kevin as being killed vs CoD being shot, it looks like the first kill was mafia, who I'm gonna say are terrible at this. Kevin would've been a top suspect for pushing so hard to get AbT lynched, and getting rid of him for us is stupid on their part. Good for us though, I'll take it.

Also I told you jerks that scum would kill twice, and now we only have 8 players and 3 scum left and are one mislynch away from LYLO. So, good work everyone. Let's at least try to get today right.

I need to read through some stuff, but FoS Finster for hammering AbT.

Chaplain of Death, Vanilla Townie, was shot on Night 2.

Goddamn, I knew it, those bastards are going to frame me... again! The last posts on D2 are literally about CoD sussing me. I swear, I had nothing to do with this.

Also FoS Ferastical for immediately panicking about being seen as suspicious for this kill

[Lyner]

With 8 alive, if we mislynch one more time we could potentially end up with 5 players (2 town, 2 mafia, 1 SK) which is pretty much a lost game for town.

 

Let's treat today as LYLO

 

I'm gonna reread the thread before sharing my thoughts

[lilweirdward]

Only concern with treating today as LYLO is it would mean the power roles should come forward with whatever they have, even if it's nothing since it would still confirm two townies. While we can't really afford a mislynch, we still have two more we need to get right after today (assuming we get today right), and you can almost guarantee the cop and doctor will get killed once they out themselves.

Maybe today is still worth it, but we should think that through before just throwing them to the wolves to get only our 2nd scum kill out of 4. I agree though that all the remaining vanilla townies need to play today like it's LYLO. No stupid votes.

[KevinH]

Bah

[brewersalliance]

alright i am back from my trip and ready to dive back into this.  crazy weekend haha 

 

kevins death is interesting to me.  kind of feels like an inexperienced scum kill.  i think kevin put a big target on his back with the whole abt push, and scum could have easily pushed a lynch on him.  this feels like he was killed based on his reputation alone, which makes me think rookie scum. 

 

lyner is also right.  three kills puts it at 2v2v1, and if that happens, we are basically screwed unless the mafia and the sk both target each other for the kill (which is possible but not the most likely outcome) so we should treat today as lylo.

 

dont rush your votes, or vote recklessly for lulz.

 

as for the PRs, i dont think they should come forward unless they absolutely have to.   and i dont really see a situation where the dr should come forward at all, as it gives scum a free kill, as they know that person cannot be protected (tho the sk is probably turning the dr off every night anyways)

 

one thing that always intrigues me is when people feel the need to state the beyond obvious stuff like this:

Things are going well so far...except for Town    5 Townies to 1 Scum is not a sustainable trend

i always feel like its someone trying way to hard to appear like they are town.  if youre town, obviously having three town die per cycle is a bad thing lol you dont need to scream it to the entire world that you think its a bad thing.  so i always take these posts with a grain of salt, as don could be a scum trying to appear like he is concerned for the town.  and it would fit along with the scum being relatively newer with the kill of Kevin.  

[lilweirdward]

Yeah I agree with pretty much all of that. The only reason a doc should come forward is if they're close to being lynched, since if we get the SK then they'll be able to help a ton more. If the cop somehow has been getting any useful info then it might be worth coming forward, especially if they learned who the SK is since they will be able to be protected from then on I think.

Somewhat on that note, between WP and CoD, it looks like the SK is probably more experienced, or at least someone who understands the progression of kills. Wouldn't surprise me if it's Velocity, brewers, or maybe even Finster or Lyner. Just something to keep in mind, especially given what brewers said yesterday about it being in the SK's best interests to help us scum hunt which may make them seem more townish.

[brewersalliance]

Wouldn't surprise me if it's Velocity, brewers, or maybe even Finster or Lyner

 

 

or you lol

[Dontavian]

 

lyner is also right.  three kills puts it at 2v2v1, and if that happens, we are basically screwed unless the mafia and the sk both target each other for the kill (which is possible but not the most likely outcome) so we should treat today as lylo.

 

dont rush your votes, or vote recklessly for lulz.

 

as for the PRs, i dont think they should come forward unless they absolutely have to.   and i dont really see a situation where the dr should come forward at all, as it gives scum a free kill, as they know that person cannot be protected (tho the sk is probably turning the dr off every night anyways)

 

one thing that always intrigues me is when people feel the need to state the beyond obvious stuff like this:

 

 

Dontavian, on 17 Nov 2020 - 07:11, said:

Things are going well so far...except for Town    5 Townies to 1 Scum is not a sustainable trend 

i always feel like its someone trying way to hard to appear like they are town.  if youre town, obviously having three town die per cycle is a bad thing lol you dont need to scream it to the entire world that you think its a bad thing.  so i always take these posts with a grain of salt, as don could be a scum trying to appear like he is concerned for the town.  and it would fit along with the scum being relatively newer with the kill of Kevin

Or, this is brewers trying to deflect a spotlight away from himself by posting the obvious but saying I’m scummy because I posted the obvious 

dont rush your votes, or vote recklessly for lulz.

I’ll RC now to save speculation and make the math easier, I’m VT

[lilweirdward]

Wouldn't surprise me if it's Velocity, brewers, or maybe even Finster or Lyner

or you lol

You flatter me

I’ll RC now to save speculation and make the math easier, I’m VT

Lol k

[brewersalliance]

lyner is also right. three kills puts it at 2v2v1, and if that happens, we are basically screwed unless the mafia and the sk both target each other for the kill (which is possible but not the most likely outcome) so we should treat today as lylo.

dont rush your votes, or vote recklessly for lulz.

as for the PRs, i dont think they should come forward unless they absolutely have to. and i dont really see a situation where the dr should come forward at all, as it gives scum a free kill, as they know that person cannot be protected (tho the sk is probably turning the dr off every night anyways)

one thing that always intrigues me is when people feel the need to state the beyond obvious stuff like this:


Dontavian, on 17 Nov 2020 - 07:11, said:

Things are going well so far...except for Town 5 Townies to 1 Scum is not a sustainable trend

i always feel like its someone trying way to hard to appear like they are town. if youre town, obviously having three town die per cycle is a bad thing lol you dont need to scream it to the entire world that you think its a bad thing. so i always take these posts with a grain of salt, as don could be a scum trying to appear like he is concerned for the town. and it would fit along with the scum being relatively newer with the kill of Kevin

Or, this is brewers trying to deflect a spotlight away from himself by posting the obvious but saying I’m scummy because I posted the obvious

dont rush your votes, or vote recklessly for lulz.

I’ll RC now to save speculation and make the math easier, I’m VT

And which spotlight was on me that I'm deflecting? Lol

This RC feels premature. RCing like this with almost no reason other than me pointing out a very minor thing like that feels a bit scummy to me.

Could just be because you're a newer player, but it also could also be you as a newer scum player panicking a little bit

[Dontavian]

 

Could just be because you're a newer player, but it also could also be you as a newer scum player panicking a little bit

 

Nothing to panic over and it has nothing to do with length of time I’ve been playing. I RCd to be honest and make the math easier. Since you’ve singled me out when all I’m trying to do is help Town, is by definition a scummy thing to do. So, let’s kick it up a notch... feel free to vote for me and we’ll leave it up to the others sitting on the side atm.

 

Vote: brewers

[lilweirdward]

 

Could just be because you're a newer player, but it also could also be you as a newer scum player panicking a little bit

 

Nothing to panic over and it has nothing to do with length of time I’ve been playing. I RCd to be honest and make the math easier. Since you’ve singled me out when all I’m trying to do is help Town, is by definition a scummy thing to do. So, let’s kick it up a notch... feel free to vote for me and we’ll leave it up to the others sitting on the side atm.

 

Vote: brewers

 

 

If you come for the king you best not miss, and my brother you are REALLY off right now lol. Brewers may be mafia but this is 100% a desperation play and makes me way more suspicious of you.

 

Just as a note in case you are town: RCing as a VT means nothing. If we all mass role claimed (can't remember if it's allowed but I don't think it is), all 3 remaining scum would RC as VT and we would know nothing except that 3 of the people with that RC are lying, which we already know. That's why this looks like such a panicky move: claiming this offers literally zero to the town, but has the appearance of trying to pull yourself out of the spotlight so town can focus on other players, which is really only something that scum would want to do.

[Dontavian]

If I were “panicking” I wouldn’t do anything... I’d lurk on the side and hope for the best. I disagree that there’s no need to RC...as Town, I have no other method to communicate with other Town than to discuss in the open. Scum get to know who they are and coord in private, while being privy to the Town’s discussion.  Town is against the ropes...I’m not a PR, I’m just fodder, so I’m IDing in the hopes the other Townies then know and can act accordingly.  brewers decided to highlight me based solely on the fact that I posted. I pushed back...now you’re piling on, agreeing that I’m the one looking scummy...just because I’m trying to close ranks with the Town. Hmmm. 
 

WTF ever, I’ve RCd, the other Townies now know. The scum already knew, they just don’t know the SK.