1469 replies to this topic

[Electric Mango]

Why would Narsis have told us he was roleblocked if he has a power role?

The question should be, how could Narsis get role blocked if he doesn't have a power role. You can't role block someone unless they actually have a role that can be blocked in the first place.

VOTE COUNT


Not Voting (10): Narsis, Electric Mango, Samus, Sir Jesus, SinKon, Falzis, Kaziocore, Aquinas, CanucksDynasty, Martino

With 10 Alive, 6 is needed to lynch.

Edited by molestargazer, 21 December 2009 - 10:16 AM.

[Narsis]

The question should be, how could Narsis get role blocked if he doesn't have a power role. You can't role block someone unless they actually have a role that can be blocked in the first place.

depends on the wording. when i say roleblocked, i mean that a roleblocker used their night action on someone, regardless of whether it was successful or not or did anything.

[Kaziocore]

will be gone starting tomorrow until on Sunday

[CanucksDynasty]

The question should be, how could Narsis get role blocked if he doesn't have a power role. You can't role block someone unless they actually have a role that can be blocked in the first place.

The only one to clarify this would be Narsis.
He has chosen to remain silent for now.

In any case...can we go back to scumhunting?
Any ideas/suspicions?

[Electric Mango]

TBH I don't have any solid leads on anyone. I had KevinH as my front runner but we all know how that turned out.

My thoughts right now is that one scum voted for junkahoolic and the other two did not. I have the most suspicions on those that have not been as active or have remained ambigious. However, it is difficult because Firkked has been replaced and Sir Jesus has been largely inactive due to RL. Plus Sinkon has replaced AoD and it's hard getting reads on these people.

I was thinking that due to the size of the thread we should split the work load up. Each of us could review the posts of one other player and then give an analysis of what we think.

This will benefit us because we could have a file on each person, plus the reviews given by the players could also be useful in the future as well.

We could use the sign up sheet to assign who investigates whom.

Thoughts?

[Narsis]

sounds interesting. however, would there not be the possibility for mafia to abuse that kind of set up?

[Electric Mango]

That's where the other benefit would come in. If mafia abused this, it would be documented and could be used against them. If I painted a townie as scum that and was proven wrong, my case against him would be analyzed and I would be under a strong finger of suspicion. The same would be true if if they tried to cover up for a fellow scum buddy.

[Narsis]

That's where the other benefit would come in. If mafia abused this, it would be documented and could be used against them. If I painted a townie as scum that and was proven wrong, my case against him would be analyzed and I would be under a strong finger of suspicion. The same would be true if if they tried to cover up for a fellow scum buddy.

but how is that any different from the normal method? what specifically are we gaining by doing this?

[Martino]

TBH I don't have any solid leads on anyone. I had KevinH as my front runner but we all know how that turned out.

My thoughts right now is that one scum voted for junkahoolic and the other two did not. I have the most suspicions on those that have not been as active or have remained ambigious. However, it is difficult because Firkked has been replaced and Sir Jesus has been largely inactive due to RL. Plus Sinkon has replaced AoD and it's hard getting reads on these people.

I was thinking that due to the size of the thread we should split the work load up. Each of us could review the posts of one other player and then give an analysis of what we think.

This will benefit us because we could have a file on each person, plus the reviews given by the players could also be useful in the future as well.

We could use the sign up sheet to assign who investigates whom.

Thoughts?

This would still pretty much require all of us to read through all 50 pages. Sure, we wouldn't need to read each post, but we still have to read the majority of the posts to see the context in which our target player made his posts. If we want to split the work, I would be more in favor of each of us rereading 10 pages. In this way we will also have 2 players rereading the same posts, which would make it considerably harder for the mafia to abuse the system.

[SinKon]

Well...almost 1,000 posts but mol did say that we could as for an extention until next year. Maybe we could do this after X-mas but before the new year?
Well, how do we decide who gets who?

I believe everyone is watching this forum now so he/she could get the 1,000th post. XD
Samus is probably overwhelmed so we should give her sometime to fit in too. lol

[Electric Mango]

I'll do whatever the town decides would be best, if any.

I still favor picking one person because we would be better able to follow their trends. Also if mafia tried to manipulate anything they would be caught...

My $.02

[Narsis]

Well...almost 1,000 posts but mol did say that we could as for an extention until next year. Maybe we could do this after X-mas but before the new year?
Well, how do we decide who gets who?

I believe everyone is watching this forum now so he/she could get the 1,000th post. XD
Samus is probably overwhelmed so we should give her sometime to fit in too. lol

jsut thought i'd mention that Samus is a he.

[Samus]

i'm a she. -.-

Still reading though, I have a lil suspicion on someone but haven't finalized it yet.

[Electric Mango]

/peeps in

[SinKon]

/peeps in

2nd that.

Looks like I have a competitor for the 1000th post. "

[Kaziocore]

Wow... I was away for three days but there's hardly anything new here...

[molestargazer]

Seems everyone's caught up in one thing or another.
A mass prod will go round tonight when I get time. I'll put some vote counts up now.

[CanucksDynasty]

Both Narsis and KevinH were in the same room and both were targetted.
I think that mafia thought one of them was a cop.
I don't think that they thought one of them was a doc.

The only reason to target both of them was to make sure that they don't do an investigation.
Which I would assume would be a member in their own room (one that wasn't previously investigated...ie. Falzis).

Either Mafia is pretty clever in setting it up that way...or Falzis is mafia and didn't want to be found out.
I think it's the latter.

Vote: Falzis

[Falzis]

There wasn't suspicion on me the day before anyway either by Narsis or KevinH. If anything, the mafia must have wanted to implicate either Narsis or me.

Anyway, I don't have any leads or alternative suspect to offer since this game has lost momentum for me but if I were to choose who I think are mafia, it could be anyone except for Narsis and EM, who I believe are more or less town.

[Samus]

1000th post.

Should we vote now?