1125 replies to this topic

[Commander Shepard]

I can not say I am fine with killing Kevinh.

The best reason I see to do so is that he might be killing us, he is no more of a killer than the rest of us and especially since we're in Day 1.

Day 1 is too earlier vote vocal people because "they might be a bad guy but we don't really have a clue".

That is just as bad as no one voting on Day 1 because everyone wants a no lynch, I fail to see how lynching a vocal person almost solely based on their views on lynching on Day 1 helps the us get the real killers.

 

The real killers are laughing at us as we lynch or perhaps they're having a snooze and pretending as though they're asleep and then stab us in the back.

I suggest we lynch someone while they sleep and ask questions later.

[killgor]

I might be wrong but I understood killgor's comment as "implying that I (Lyner) seem like a scum", albeit for no other reason than the fact that we were 2 votes away from a lynchwhen you voted (or L-1 after your vote).

 

 

it was actually the statement he made after the vote. it was like he was saying that he will vote for him but does not want to be blamed if Kevin comes up townie.

[Yates]

The real killers are laughing at us as we lynch or perhaps they're having a snooze and pretending as though they're asleep and then stab us in the back.

What makes you think KevinH isn't a "real killer?"

I suggest we lynch someone while they sleep and ask questions later.

Welcome to the scum pile. This is possibly the worst "Town" suggestion in the history of mafia. What you said basically translates into, "let's lynch someone while they are asleep so that if they are a Town PR they don't have an opportunity to role claim and stop the lynch. Isn't this a terrific idea!"

[Yates]

Further, Kevin's lack of claim means he's either a scum that can't come up with a good fake claim or Town that isn't smart enough to figure out a good gambit. With the bonus feature that if he is Town he espouses anti-Town nonsense that will ultimately lose us the game. And, frankly, wagon analysis will do more to solidify a Town win than anything he has contributed [or is likely to contribute] thus far. So while I'd prefer to see a scum flip, I wouldn't be heart broken over a VT flip either.

I obviously make this statement with no knowledge of his meta.

[Commander Shepard]

 

Welcome to the scum pile. This is possibly the worst "Town" suggestion in the history of mafia. What you said basically translates into, "let's lynch someone while they are asleep so that if they are a Town PR they don't have an opportunity to role claim and stop the lynch. Isn't this a terrific idea!"

 

 

That will teach me for trying to roleplay and not look at the game from the outside.

Inactive people = people sleeping in an ingame context.

[iSocialism]

Vote: Yates

Seems to me that you are trying to sell lynching Kevin a little to much.

[Yates]

Vote: Yates
Seems to me that you are trying to sell lynching Kevin a little to much.

I see.

And what happens if/when he flips scum?

[Commander Shepard]

What do you mean what happens? Are you saying we should lynch him because he might flip scum.

We could lynch anyone on Day 1 for that reason.

[Yates]

What do you mean what happens?

What do you think I mean? That's a silly question. I am clearly challenging the logic behind his "read" considering he is supposed to be part of the uninformed minority. You know who knows who the scum team are? Scum. That's it. So making a read on someone based on a flip that has yet to occur is silly and pedantic.

[KevinH]

Oh no, please don't lynch me.

 

I think to myself:

 

"This L-1 pressure is just too much. What can I do?"

 

"I know, I'll tell them that I'm a townie.  Then surely that will make somebody change their mind."

 

I'm a townie.  There.  Did anybody change their mind?

 

 

[Commander Shepard]

I'm more inclined to vote you as you did not move me with your plea.

[Electric Mango]

Lol @ Kevin's post.

He's right. There's really nothing he could say to prove he's town but there's no reason to believe he's scum as well. Kevin needs to live on and here's why. Well I will have to tell you later because my wife is toe tapping me to go vanity shopping

[Electric Mango]

Ok, lynch debate: Kevin v Inactive

#1 Kevin is interesting, inactives are not.
#2 Loose lips sink ships. The more they talk, the more we know.
#3 We know Kevin's lynch mob, lets see the inactives lynch mob.
#4 We know Kevin's meta.

[Lyner]

Now we're talking

 

I support ze above motion, especially #2

[KevinH]

My name is Simon Templar. I am a Super Saint.

 

If I am lynched, the player who makes the hammer vote will also be killed.

 

[killgor]

i am actually willing to throw the hammer now on you.

 

unvote: Kevin

[Electric Mango]

Ooooh the plot thickens. See, who says Day 1 lynches are not useful. I already have lots of good info based on today's events and we don't even know Kevin's alignment yet.

This is so much better than a bunch of useless no lynch votes. Here we see people taking sides and making meaningful votes which can be used later by experienced sleuths to crack this case.

I'm just sorry that it had to be Kevin and not an inactive.

[Kaziocore]

Votecount 1.07

Chaplain of death (0) -
Commander Shepard (0) -
Electric Mango (1) - Imran Ehsan
Imran Ehsan (1) - Electric Mango
Iron Helix (1) - KevinH
iSocialism (0) -
KevinH (4) - Chaplain of death, Theophilos, Yates, Lyner
killgor (0) -
Lyner (0) -
MutedFaith (0) -
Robert2424 (2) - Commander Shepard, MutedFaith
Theophilos (1) - Iron Helix
Yates (1) - iSocialism

No Lynch (0) -

Not Voting (2) - killgor, Robert2424

With 13 alive, it takes 7 to lynch.
KevinH is the current wagon leader at L-3
Deadline is Friday, November 29th, 2013 @ 03:15 EDT

135 hours left before deadline

[KevinH]

You do know my alignment.

 

I said I was a townie.

[Robert2424]

Ok. Esentully a Bomb/vengful townie he is claiming. Im too tired to remember witch atm. Assuming if I were to place a vote on Kevin, Killgor wants to hammer him to test if whoever hammers him would die. Im more for lynching a inactive then Kevin though.  Idk.

 

Also Kevins post at 1:34 made me laugh.

 

Im inclinded to believe who ever hammers him dies. His name throws me honestly though. So I feel he's telling half the truth. Idk. I'll have to think more on it as I thought he was more town before that post he claimed. If that makes sense. I'll have to check those links when Im not on my xbox 1.