Eva999

For future reference, I'm a guy.

Darn brackets Vote: ABigDeer

I have some work to do before a class and then the class its self, so hopefully I have time to fully respond to that before the day ends. To be brief though, you're totally misreading my posts. For the first one, I don't think anyone suspected Rafay at that point, a position that has changed for probably everyone, including myself now that we've narrowed down the list of people. Ccabal was suspicious there. A townie role claim that early was totally suspicious, though I see now why he did it, to try and set a trap for the scum. A shame it didn't work as it was a good plan. How did I say RoT was suspicious for not voting but ABigDeer wasn't? I clearly said I don't think the lack of a vote was suspicious at all. I criticized RoT over ABigDeer because I felt like when RoT did post, he never actually said anything at all, the same reason I'm still suspicious of KevinH. RoT never spoke up, not even to role claim before he got lynched. In the next post, I criticize KevinH, as I have been. I say I don't think Emmanuel (now you) was scum. I comment on why I felt RoT was scummier than ABigDeer at the time, Note that I never say in those posts that I think ABigDeer is townie, only that others were being scummier to me. I say I'm pretty sure Beebs is town. Finally, I comment that Rafay has been throwing votes around less, but getting overly defensive, something that has gotten worse as people started to say, well maybe his is scum. Anyways, we're in agreement at least about ABigDeer and Rafay being the obvious candidates. Vote: ABigDeer]/b]

Team Rocket confirmed for scum. Well, that settles it guys

I'll try to post more later today, I've had the most absolutely bizarre schedule the past couple days to study for exams. For now though, Rafay and ABigDeer seem like the best choices. Rafay is already gunning for a lynch with hardly any discussion and being even more defensive than ever before when called on it. I feel like he's in panic mode right now. Karl is 99% confirmed town for me, though I suppose there's the off chance that the town doesn't have a cop-ish role and its a scum role instead to let them find the townie power roles, but that seems very very unlikely.

What makes you feel Kevin isn't scummy? I still feel like he is. He's posted a lot and stands out because of the poems, but I feel like people are just glancing over him because of that. He's posted a lot but said nothing of value. Even when I asked directly for his opinions, he replied in such a vague way he didn't actually say anything. His only saving grace right now for me is his vote against Rafay back when EM was lynched, thought Rafay was not in super danger of being lynched after EM unvoted and with Rafay's vote on ccabal that could have been switched earlier. Kevin is a very skilled player, just look at the wins and losses thread. Don't let him escape your gaze so easily.

He didn't vote for you, just eyed you for suspicion. Quite the hasty vote on our most important day. If you aren't scum and neither are they, you've cost us the game. Though given that that would make the scum ABigDeer, Kevin, and Karl, and I don't believe Karl is scum. Rafay seems very scummy here, if he can garner up one townie vote to go with him, the other scum can jump on and end it, assuming there's 3 scum at least. I could be wrong about Imran and Ccabal being townie, but I don't think I am. FOS: Rafay

It's not actually written down in Kazio's rules as far as I can see, but as a general rule of thumb, don't edit your posts in a mafia game. If you have a correction to make, just make a new post. Aside from making it more coherent though, I dont think anything changed much with the post.

In class now so I'll post more later, but for now, WHY OH WHY DID ROT NOT SPEAK UP???

Making me look like scum with the lynch vote are ya? I'm not totally convinced either, but if I unvote, no one dies tonight which really just leaves us tomorrow with another townie dead and no new info for voting tomorrow.

Personally, I feel lynching Imran is the wrong choice, but my vote cant stop it now unless someone jumps in on RoT. Vote: Reign of Terror With no one else stepping up, I feel we have to trust ccabal and Imran right now. I don't really think RoT is scum, but going into tomorrow losing Imran and likely ccabal, both townies imo, leaves us incredibly helpless and game ending if ccabal speaks truely

So, he's a doc, but can only protect you?

ABigDeer and who?

Ccabal is voting for Reign of Terror currently, not Imran Ehsan

I'm really not sure how to vote here. RoT has been suspiciously quiet, but I'm hesitant to follow ccabal and Imran into another lynch after being wrong about EM. Kevin's quick vote on Imran without much explanation is a bit suspicious. I still kinda feel like Kevin's using the posting in poems to hide really having to say anything . Emmanuel hasn't posted in a while which is kinda odd given how important today is, but as I've already said, I don't think he's scum. ABigDeer has been staying a bit quiet as well, but when he does post he at least says something unlike RoT. I don't really find him and RoT suspicious for not voting for the lynch. By that logic Imran should find himself suspicious for voting No lynch when Nerau got lynched as I don't see much of a difference in voting No Lynch against someone who was nearly for sure going to be lynched and not voting at all, the outcome was effectively the same, but I suppose that's just me Beebs I'm not sure about, but my gut says townie. Rafay has calmed down a bit it seems, but he's still being a bit defensive whenever anyone says anything to him.

Rafay sorta voted for both I think he meant? Technically his vote against EM didn't count though.

I'm pretty sure ccabal said he has no special power, just being able to talk to Imran apparently.

So what are your thoughts on whos scum and whos townie Kevin? You've posted quite a bit but I don't feel like you've really actually said much. Probably a side effect of trying to post in poem, but it would be nice to hear your thoughts

Anyways, to continue my thoughts. If EM had been a scum, I would've been gunning for Emmanuel for agreeing so hard with EM about a werewolf theory and throwing a last minute vote against Rafay, but if he were scum I don't see why he would vote for Rafay over just not voting or jumping on with EM.

Sorry I've been a bit inactive, mixture of being busy, a bit sick, and playing Tribes: Ascend with all my spare time >_> Anyways, RoT does seem to be lying low, though he may have just thought that neither EM nor Rafay were scum. Abigdeer didn't vote either, but his posts have a bit more substance to them. I have to run for a bit because I need to go to a class, but I'll post again a bit later when I get the chance.

Between Rafay and EM right now, EM just strikes me as the more likely scum right now. Rafay is throwing around votes like they're candy, but he isn't really trying to get people to side with him or band wagoning. It almost makes me feel like he's just throwing votes hoping someone will respond stupidly to it. Who knows. For now though, I feel like EM has been trying to confuse the town by throwing around what I feel is an unlikely "werewolf" scenario. Trying to trap ccabal with the mason thing just sounds silly given how generically we talk about roles. He could have easily said mason without a second thought and it wouldn't have meant anything. Vote: Electric Mango I'm not entirely sure ccabal isn't the scum here, as role claiming a townie role so early seems a bit off. It's given us a lot to talk about for now, but I feel like it's dangerous, as it nearly forces the doc (if we have one) to keep you protected. Assuming we have a doc that believes you of course.

It seems like a terrible trap. What if he had answered mason just generically talking about the role instead of answering with the flavor of the role?

This is the post I was thinking of, sorry. Kevin seems to be suggesting here that there is a cop, though it could just be an off hand comment, having a cop of some sort is fairly common. I agree with you that a mafia turning instead of killing scenario seems unlikely. Just reading the intro again, it doesn't seem to fit that there would only be 1 scum.

Let me dig through the posts again later. I thought it was you that said it, but it might have been someone else. That or I'm just stupid and imagining things.

Nerau wouldn't have even had a night action since he got lynched right? There could still be a second vig I suppose, especially since the description of d3mon being charred is so different from the mangled body described in the intro. Given how detailed Kazio has been in the descriptions of everything, that doesn't seem likely to be an oversight.