Imran Ehsan

You indicated you had a night action and hammered on a scum -> townie actions and with ability that scum would want to take out. Its odd that the role blocker blocked you 2 nights in a row even after your actions on Day 2. So if you are indeed townie, that indicates the roleblocker is in the scum faction and they decided to block a known player with night action and go for a kill on a second target. So thinking about it, probably a logical move on their part to role block you again instead of killing you.

I meant it is odd that the scum didnt target you. It is clear why the vigilante targetted CS. The same reason zenonia is high on the suspects list (voting for a lynch on a townie and refraining from voting on a lynch on a scum).

Mafia = voting on opinions and suspicions. You are very unlikely to ever get "facts" to base your vote upon until it is too late. Someone may "claim" to be a "cop" and know the alignment of certain other players, but still then you cannot be sure whether what they are claiming is true or he is false-claiming. You even voted this day based on a voting trend on not on any "fact". And normally scum know who the other scum are. I havent played any game where the scum are unaware of who their other scum buddies are. This is simply because the scum faction gets one nightkill and you cant have 2-3 different scums sending different nightkills unless they can discuss amongst themselves who they are going to kill in the night. Who did you protect in Night 1 and Night 2? Who are most suspicious to you in this game? and why?

So there is a vigilante in the game. That actually fits in with the theme of this game. Also interesting that they killed Lyner instead of robert. These players lynched a scum: I really thought Commander Shepard was a scum since he put the hammer vote on a townie and then didn't vote to lynch the scum. Draw on Zenonia. He's on the lynch a townie list and not on the lynch a scum list. Who was saying that lynching on Day 1 is fruitless? Now we have a voting trend on Day 3. Agreed with the reasoning as well. zeonia is the online alive player who voted to lynch a townie and failed to vote for a lynch on a scum. Draws on zenonia Not voting is playing it safe. Scum dont want a voting trend to be used against them (see above). If someone is staying away from taking sides while a townie/scum is being lynched, it makes it harder to identify the scum. Not voting is not a help to the town. Only scum will employ such a tactic. However, plus points to you for drawing on zenonia today.

Really at this point the only thing you can do is role claim because there isnt any other better options for a lynch.

sweeeeet ronny d seems to turn up only when theres a lynch wagon on him. seems like a scum trying to stay under the radar <_< Draws on Sweeeeet Ronny D

We are on Day 2 where we dont have much information as in Day 1. You are the only one who claimed some information from the night, so of course it stands to reason that we get some info based on which we may decide on who to lynch. I didnt ask you to role claim, you volunteered what info you had -> which is you performed some night action on Lyner and got a "No result". No result is normally associated with an investigative or tracking/watching type of role. So either you were roleblocked or Lyner has some ability that prevents investigative actions on him. So either lyner is lying or you did actually get roleblocked. If we are going to lynch Lyner based off your night action then more information will be needed (whether you think its a possibility that you got roleblocked or not)

Not exactly. It is unlikely that all the scum got on the bandwagon together. I would say at least one scum did not vote for lord zetano.

I doubt EM was killed because of his votes on Day 1 (although I wont count out SRD as a scum). He was killed because of his experience in mafia games and the scum wanted to take out a potentially dangerous townie player against them. So what does that imply? That implies that there is at least one scum who has played against him before. Since we have a lot of new players in this game, that actually gives us some info. It narrows down the pool of suspects to: CS Kazio KevinH robert2424 Lyner I am going to leave out kevinh from the scum group because he has been playing as he normally does. i will squeeze out Lyner as well..odds of him being scum in so many game is bound to catch up some time . So I would say we have a scum amongst CS Kazio robert2424 robert seems to be indicating he had some investigative result on Lyner. So I am interested to hear what it was before drawing my gun on someone.

lord Zetano seems to be hiding. Draw on Lord Zetano

I am down with a lynch. Draws on sweeeeet ronny d

I didnt play the last game so they dont count :|

Lyner is almost always scum I am almost always townie Kazio will get nightkilled in 1 or 2 days CS always looks scummy but is probably townie if kevin is scum he will not post much if EM is scum we are screwed

the game seems to be based on Reservoir dogs, so I would guess there's two or three undercover cops. i doubt theres a SK but there probably is a vigilante. probably someone with the jailer ability as well. should be interesting. Since everyone has turned up now, I would Holster my gun for now.

When in doubt, kill the inactives Draws on Sweeeeet Ronny D

Either he's alive or he's dead, or the cops got him... or they don't.

In.

I enjoyed the game. Good game.

Yeah seems like scum again attempted a no-kill. Lyner seems like the most likely suspect. Vote: Lyner

Already covering bases lyner?

Well DV is lynched. However, we should also consider the scenario that scum didnt attempt any kill last night. So if DV turns up townie, that would mean scum gambled that RB wont target him, so whoever got targetted would look scummy. Anyway, lets see what results we get from the lynch.

killgor blocked DV. So it seems certain DV is scum. If the game continues even after lynching DV (and him turning up scum) then we know theres another scum and that probably is Lyner. So we should lynch DV first. Vote: Daniel Vigrid

Vote: ABigDeer

Before we hammer the lynch on scum ABD we need to discuss what to do tonight. We have 3 claimed active ability townies. I am not sure if EM has any actions left. So we have killgor - RB, Lyner - scum killer and Yates - tracker. I propose we discuss on what on who they should target this night. killgor should not role block lyner and yates. so we get information from their actions at night on the next day.

Yes. I cant see their roles. Only what they reveal themselves.