Hapa

I'm calling bullshit on these votes. You voted me to "hear my analysis", yet you didn't follow up on the issue at all, even after I asked you to clarify what you wanted. Asking a question without being interested in the response is a mafia-mindset, and made worse by promptly jumping on a popular bandwagon. All your behavior so far looks like you're trying to blend-in with other posters as opposed to being interested in figuring out the game. And that makes you mafia. ##Vote Blaskowicz

Are you suggesting we no-lynch on Day 1? Now I haven't played any games on these boards, but virtually every mafia site I've ever played on considers it to be a terrible idea. Lynching a townie on Day 1 is no big deal, and there really isn't any other way to get good information in the thread. There's always going to be a first lynch, and you just have to man up and do it when you're supposed to. No I'm never said no Lynch I said we should watch people's reactions to being voted to be lynched and base are votes off them. At least then we won't be pointing fingers wildly like the pattern has been so far. Well yeah of course - updating one's votes to one's latest suspicions is pretty standard. But you have to start somewhere. What arguments?

Are you suggesting we no-lynch on Day 1? Now I haven't played any games on these boards, but virtually every mafia site I've ever played on considers it to be a terrible idea. Lynching a townie on Day 1 is no big deal, and there really isn't any other way to get good information in the thread. There's always going to be a first lynch, and you just have to man up and do it when you're supposed to.

So lets find the baddies. Of the posters so far, who is the baddest one of them all?

No, that is a terrible idea. We have exactly one shot. If the mafia decides to not kill us in the first few three days, and we all use that, then more than 80% of us will have wasted our power. How about this, we talk, then we decide what do? That's what this discussion is aimed to do. What do you propose we should do instead? Also @ Montosh, have you played mafia before? If so, where?

So what do you think is the best way to deal with the 1-shot PGO abilities?

That's still absolutely fantastic. I don't think you understand how much of an information advantage extra lynches are for town. Though why are you assuming that there's some "super-team" of mafia running around?

Wouldn't that put you more at risk for the 50/50 chance of being killed? Shouldn't it be if you feel like your head is in the cross hairs to arm and pray it wasn't in vain? I mean either way it's a "hope for the best" situation with only one night for us to arm are self's. I highly doubt mafia would make a night action that would put them at a 50/50 chance of getting killed. Those are terrible odds for mafia, and I'd take the town side of that any day. Remember, mafia only have 3 members in this setup, so taking a risk to lose one at coinflip odds is very scary. ...and here-in lies the point of my plan. If you generate your night actions by RNG, mafia will never have enough information to make a safe shot. That would be fantastic for town no? Mafia not shooting people = extra lynches for us.

Also, while we wait for people to vote for that hethen, blasphemous mafia, I wanted to make a proposal on how to use our town power roles. I propose that anyone who thinks they are in danger of being shot should flip a coin every night (or some other method of RNG). If heads, use your ability. If tails, do not. This will dissuade mafia from shooting useful targets without actually revealing who did or did not use their ability.

How dare you question our lord mod and savior. ##Vote: GeniusInc

A quick setup question... can mafia "save" KP if they no-kill for a given night? (i.e. save KP for Night 1, make two kills Night 2)

Mind if I join up? /in

Ruler Name: Hapapants Nation Name: Ka Lae Link to Nation: http://www.cybernations.net/nation_drill_display.asp?Nation_ID=494536 Does your Alliance need an Embassy?: No Alliance you Represent: Doom Squad Alliance's IRC Channel & Server: #DoomSquad @ irc.coldfront.net