ccabal86 said he saw Narsis hit KevinH over the head with a bat. I'm confident that KevinH will confirm he was hit over the head with a bat last night as well. This will give further merit to ccabal86's claim. ccabal86 would have no reason to make up the story which is why I believe him 100% and agree that we should attack Narsis tonight in the lobby.

The chance he is lying is high call it a hunch

 

first was how he got damaged the first night

 

Then last night he magically was unharmed by the falling challender

 

so I agree he probably is mafia

Narsis whacked me with a bat and I was hit by the falling chandellier.

I'm as good as dead ...

I also saw the zebra if that info is worth anything.

Here is what I saw. Curufinwe used a weapon on chaos while 19th and I attacked chaos. So, we killed chaos, but then, the chandelier fell on me.

 

(Just to clarify - is the reason I saw the names of the other attackers because the light was turned on? I'm still getting used to this format of mafia.)

 

It has been asserted that Narsis attacked Kevin, and that chaos (or someone else) triggered the chandelier.

 

So, I, for one, am (still) suspicious of Narsis and Curufinwe. If I had to choose which one I am more suspicious of, it's Narsis ... because he has taken less damage. Why would the mafia attack one of their own, right? But then, if I had to choose which person I would rather attack, I'm leaning towards finishing Curufinwe off at the moment and hoping that someone would be willing to search his body therefore confirming if he's scum or not. (Are you allowed to kill then search on the same night? Or does it have to be separate nights?)

 

(BTW, how bad is the bleeding; how much HP will I lose at what points in time?)

 

Anyhow - my day time action for the moment is Follow: Curufinwe.

 

(When's the deadline, again?)

 

BTW, guys, I want to publicly salute Martino for doing a fabulous job with my questions. He's been a real help.

Edits ...

 

I do want to add that I would be willing to help kill Narsis if we, as the town, genuinely thought that eliminating him was a better plan than finishing Curufinwe. So, let's get some discussion going. What am I, as an inexperienced player in this format, missing by going one way as opposed to the other? What makes most sense? What do I need to take into consideration?

Are you allowed to kill then search on the same night? Or does it have to be separate nights?

No, everyone got one action per night. Searching a body counts as an action

 

(BTW, how bad is the bleeding; how much HP will I lose at what points in time?)

You'll just have to find out.

 

(When's the deadline, again?)

I forgot to mention. The deadline is Thursday morning.

Actions ... but can someone search a dead body on the same night I (at least try to) kill someone?

 

Bleeding ... will I die from the bleeding with 6 HP in one day/night cycle?

 

Thursday morning it is. Thank you

Edits again ...

 

I also want to add that Curufinwe used a knife.

Actions ... but can someone search a dead body on the same night I (at least try to) kill someone?

Player X can search the body while player Y attack someone yes. It is just not possible for one player to search and attack.

Bleeding ... will I die from the bleeding with 6 HP in one day/night cycle?

I stand by my previous answer .

Perfect.

 

Hmm...activity wise, do any of the veterans think that someone is suspicious because of a lack of activity?

I don't find inactivity automatically suspicious. However, I'd rather have an active townie than an inactive townie ...

 

Follow Narsis

So it should be a no brainer by now that Narsis is mafia. Our 1st action should be to kill him off as soon as possible.

 

The town has this game wrapped up as far as I'm concerned. We kill Narsis, then we kill Theo and game over. I'd be surprised if it turned out any other way.

 

Curufinwe has to be innocent. Not sure why he was FOS'd, especially when he was seen attacking a known scum.

Woah, wait a minute AKCPLUTO, why do you think Curufinwe is mafia? Just because he has a weapon?

 

On day 1, I'm pretty sure he searched the kitchen, and probably found a knife. I mean, a kitchen has to have knives, right? Also, he triggered the booby trap, wich he probably wouldn't have done if he was mafia. I'm pretty sure Curu is innocent, we have to go after Narsis.

 

Follow Narsis

EM, hmm...I suppose the fact that Curu used a knife does not mean he ought to be FOS'd. He might be a townie who just found the knife.

 

OK...in which case...Follow: Narsis.

 

What if Theo is a vig, though?

@ ccbal86

 

Sorry, I didn't see your post as I was making mine.

 

Yeah, exactly. See previous post. Poor reasoning on my part earlier today.

sigh...i kinda hoped i wouldn't need to do this:

 

I'm a vig.

Really, Narsis? Is that the best you could come up with? I don't believe you at all...because...

 

I'm a vig too. And you are NOT my vig partner.

You remember at the start, the box? I got damaged by it? Guess what damaged me, the knife. Just so you know where that came from. Held it close to my chest till someone was dead, so I would not be a prime target for the mafia.

 

Lets go forward from here. How do we know Narsis is telling the truth??

So a knife from the box damaged you on n1?

sigh...i kinda hoped i wouldn't need to do this:

 

I'm a vig.

 

Ok, so let's assume you are a vigilante. Why would you whack KevinH, which you most certainly did.

 

It's good to know you can dish out some good damage then Curu

I have a really weird theory. I know it sounds dumb, but OK. Is it coincidence that Narsis and Kazio were both in the entrance up until day 3 and that Kazio has been in the entrance during every night period. Now, either Nerau or Kazio attacked Narsis on night 1. What were your night actions then, gentlemen? Then, on night 2, either Kevin or Narsis attacked Kazio. Kevin, what was your night action then? Kazio allegedly got electrocuted by toggling the main lobby light ... but could it be imaginable that Narsis and Kazio have attacked each other to muddy up the waters? I'm not sure about the electrocution story.

 

Also, in putting all the data of my guesses concerning who has attacked who into a little spreadsheet, I can assure everyone that Theo is not scum. Because I did not attack Curu, Theo did attack Curu on N1. But then Curu got healed and Theo's actions since then have been either searching, watching the bedroom, or healing Curu.

 

Thus, I think that Kazio MIGHT be scum. Narsis for sure. I'm committed to lynching Narsis at this point. However, after Narsis, Kazio is my next likely candidate.

 

(After this game, would someone be kind enough to look at the spreadsheet in question and coach me a bit as to how accurate my playstyle is?)

I say we focus on the task at hand, which for now is lynching Narsis. We can evaluate the night's actions, and decide on our next action then.

Ok, so let's assume you are a vigilante. Why would you whack KevinH, which you most certainly did.

 

It's good to know you can dish out some good damage then Curu

 

 

1) why is it good to know Curu can dish out damage? he could be mafia lying about where he got the knife.

 

2) why whack Kevin? well it has to do with the combination of items that us vigs started with and found during the night that makes KevinH finding a medkit night 1 highly suspect.

 

@AKC: if Theo attacked Curu night 1...well why would he do that if he wasn't mafia? and what makes you think that a mafia couldn't have attacked night 1 and then just searched the rest of the game?

rereading AKC's posts these last few pages just makes me think that he is reaching for any reason to draw suspicion away from him. i for one honestly think we caught scum in him.