bleh sorry. nvm i see it.

 

the first was me explaining what i believed before today. the latter is what i believe is a good possibility now.

 

 

You said you suspected KevinH and myself being mafia because we used medkits on injured players "too soon". Then in the next quote you're saying the mafie wouldn't start with medkits, because that would not be fitting "flavorwise"

 

 

read above again.

 

although i admit that second one was poorly worded.

I will let Theo deal with the matter of medkits then.

 

your partner better at lying/coming up with a fakeclaim of sorts?

 

I will add that the fact that Narsis has persisted this far to defend himself this emphatically says a lot too about him.

 

how so? why should i not defend myself? if i dont then the mafia are likely to win. if i do then at least there is a chance for the town to see the light.

Well, I have to conclude from what I've seen, that Narsis is scum.

 

Theo and AKC, I believe you are the vigs, but you could have made our situation a lot easier, if you hadn't attacked Curu >.<

Theo has more experience than I do.

 

I'm implying that your persistence as been quite entertaining.

 

Well, let's do a show of hands. Who believes Theo and I, and who believes Narsis?

Next time, I'll know better, CC.

Almost forgot >_<

 

At this point Narsis probably can't out his partner for a simple reason. His scum partner is dead, ie Chaos was killed by townies. Would Narsis now to confirm his partner, he'd hang him self with it, thus the reluctance, thus the guilt.

 

Agreed 100%

 

The simplest answer is always the best answer.

BTW, sorry about the laggy replies, I'm on a really poor WIFI connection ATM...

Agreed 100%

 

The simplest answer is always the best answer.

 

is it? then why do scum bus? why attempt a gambit? scum are unpredictable beasts as AKC/Theo's gambit is showing.

Right on, cc.

 

I LOVE the surprise effect. Theo is brilliant

Agreed 100%

 

The simplest answer is always the best answer.

 

also applying that line of thinking: then what is the simplest answer to AKC/Theo attacking curu?

Simple! It was a mistake and an extremely terrible decision.

Right on, cc.

 

I LOVE the surprise effect. Theo is brilliant

 

i dont see how this has any bearing on the discussion and is nothing more then a worthless/contentless post.

Simple! It was a mistake and an extremely terrible decision.

 

simple: my attack on Kevin was a mistake and a terrible decision.

 

guess what: we are both right regardless of who is the vig or mafia.

@ #438: indeed.

 

@ #437: indeed.

also applying that line of thinking: then what is the simplest answer to AKC/Theo attacking curu?

 

A bad decision. Almost as bad as attacking people who openly and admittedly healed other people who they believed to be townies (and nothing contradicted this belief so far)

A bad decision. Almost as bad as attacking people who openly and admittedly healed other people who they believed to be townies (and nothing contradicted this belief so far)

 

so we both made a bad decision then eh? so how does that make it any more likely that i'm mafia and he is a vig?

Your bad decision did more damage than our bad decision.

Your bad decision did more damage than our bad decision.

 

did it? you muddying up night results, and did an equivalent amount of damage to a player that my attack on Kevin did.

Kevin is at 1 HP and about to die.

 

Curu accidentally got the knife but if all he got was the bat, he would have lost maybe 3 HP and that would have been that.

Kevin is at 1 HP and about to die.

 

Curu accidentally got the knife but if all he got was the bat, he would have lost maybe 3 HP and that would have been that.

 

as stated the chandelier was an unforseen event. and not something that i or any of my partners caused.

I thought that CH pulled it.

I thought that CH pulled it.

 

precisely my point. CH most definitely wasnt one of my vig partners.

taht is a very scummy thing to do. you see by limiting actions to within the rooms, the mod has given the town an invulnerable unblockable cop that is guaranteed to show that at least one of these 2 players is scum. but it only works if only scum attack at night. you attacking then is an obvious scum move. why would you attack with no leads? you'd get a definite lead within 2 days if you had waited. now instead you attacked a player(most likely a town player). that is a very scum move to do on night 1 as unless scum attack they can't possibly win.

 

No it was a calculated risk that well could have brought results but alas it didn't.

 

I have to agree with Narsis on this one, attacking Curu just like that definately didn't benefit the town, and just confused us regulars.

 

Quite possibly, but the intention was well meant ... it's also the fact why only I attacked and not AKC as well, he had the task of searching.

 

@Narsis And yes the argument to act on what limited info was mine. In that sense AKC is right in "blaming" me, but naturally he isn't blaming me he is only conveying how the decision was made.

 

Well, I have to conclude from what I've seen, that Narsis is scum.

 

Theo and AKC, I believe you are the vigs, but you could have made our situation a lot easier, if you hadn't attacked Curu >.<

 

On hindsight we could have possibly made a better choice.

 

precisely my point. CH most definitely wasnt one of my vig partners.

 

I agree he wasn't your vig partner, he was your scum partner, since you are scum

No it was a calculated risk that well could have brought results but alas it didn't.

 

 

 

Quite possibly, but the intention was well meant ... it's also the fact why only I attacked and not AKC as well, he had the task of searching.

 

@Narsis And yes the argument to act on what limited info was mine. In that sense AKC is right in "blaming" me, but naturally he isn't blaming me he is only conveying how the decision was made.

 

 

 

On hindsight we could have possibly made a better choice.

 

 

 

I agree he wasn't your vig partner, he was your scum partner, since you are scum

 

oh right how sorry of me. you are right i'm scum. and you are vigs. well now why dont we just all kill me now.

 

[/sarcasm]

 

or you know you could be lying...

There is no evidence that Theo is lying. Wow, your only defense is to accuse him of lying, too?