687 replies to this topic

[Narsis]

A bad decision. Almost as bad as attacking people who openly and admittedly healed other people who they believed to be townies (and nothing contradicted this belief so far)

so we both made a bad decision then eh? so how does that make it any more likely that i'm mafia and he is a vig?

[AKCPLUTO]

Your bad decision did more damage than our bad decision.

[Narsis]

Your bad decision did more damage than our bad decision.

did it? you muddying up night results, and did an equivalent amount of damage to a player that my attack on Kevin did.

[AKCPLUTO]

Kevin is at 1 HP and about to die.

Curu accidentally got the knife but if all he got was the bat, he would have lost maybe 3 HP and that would have been that.

[Narsis]

Kevin is at 1 HP and about to die.

Curu accidentally got the knife but if all he got was the bat, he would have lost maybe 3 HP and that would have been that.

as stated the chandelier was an unforseen event. and not something that i or any of my partners caused.

[AKCPLUTO]

I thought that CH pulled it.

[Narsis]

I thought that CH pulled it.

precisely my point. CH most definitely wasnt one of my vig partners.

[Theophilos]

taht is a very scummy thing to do. you see by limiting actions to within the rooms, the mod has given the town an invulnerable unblockable cop that is guaranteed to show that at least one of these 2 players is scum. but it only works if only scum attack at night. you attacking then is an obvious scum move. why would you attack with no leads? you'd get a definite lead within 2 days if you had waited. now instead you attacked a player(most likely a town player). that is a very scum move to do on night 1 as unless scum attack they can't possibly win.

No it was a calculated risk that well could have brought results but alas it didn't.

I have to agree with Narsis on this one, attacking Curu just like that definately didn't benefit the town, and just confused us regulars.

Quite possibly, but the intention was well meant ... it's also the fact why only I attacked and not AKC as well, he had the task of searching.

@Narsis And yes the argument to act on what limited info was mine. In that sense AKC is right in "blaming" me, but naturally he isn't blaming me he is only conveying how the decision was made.

Well, I have to conclude from what I've seen, that Narsis is scum.

Theo and AKC, I believe you are the vigs, but you could have made our situation a lot easier, if you hadn't attacked Curu >.<

On hindsight we could have possibly made a better choice.

precisely my point. CH most definitely wasnt one of my vig partners.

I agree he wasn't your vig partner, he was your scum partner, since you are scum

[Narsis]

No it was a calculated risk that well could have brought results but alas it didn't.



Quite possibly, but the intention was well meant ... it's also the fact why only I attacked and not AKC as well, he had the task of searching.

@Narsis And yes the argument to act on what limited info was mine. In that sense AKC is right in "blaming" me, but naturally he isn't blaming me he is only conveying how the decision was made.



On hindsight we could have possibly made a better choice.



I agree he wasn't your vig partner, he was your scum partner, since you are scum

oh right how sorry of me. you are right i'm scum. and you are vigs. well now why dont we just all kill me now.

[/sarcasm]

or you know you could be lying...

[AKCPLUTO]

There is no evidence that Theo is lying. Wow, your only defense is to accuse him of lying, too?

[Narsis]

There is no evidence that Theo is lying. Wow, your only defense is to accuse him of lying, too?

no.

and there is no more evidence against me then there is against Theo/you.

[Electric Mango]

There are no vig partnerS, only a vig partner. There are only 2 vig's. If you were the vig, you would A partner. Since you are scum, you have partners, plural.

Not only did you slip up once, you slipped up twice. Tsk tsk.

as stated the chandelier was an unforseen event. and not something that i or any of my partners caused.

precisely my point. CH most definitely wasnt one of my vig partners.

What say ye to that?

[Narsis]

There are no vig partnerS, only a vig partner. There are only 2 vig's. If you were the vig, you would A partner. Since you are scum, you have partners, plural.

Not only did you slip up once, you slipped up twice. Tsk tsk.







What say ye to that?

now how could you know that my good friend hmm? what makes you think that there aren't 3 vigs? also isn't it convenient that AKC/Theo only claimed there's the two of them? with CH dead it makes a lot of sense that there'd only be two scum left alive...

[AKCPLUTO]

Narsis is right. There are two scum alive. Him and possibly Kazio.

[AKCPLUTO]

Out of curiosity, who isn't going to be following Narsis tonight?

[KevinH]

Who asked for this? on what page?

A summary of the game by selected quotes ...

I say we beat Narsis to death just for the lulz .

In literary terms, this is foreshadowing.

Rather than let the scum know what we are doing, I think each player should choose to either search or watch but not let anybody know the choice beforehand.

I hope it was not vigilantes that did damage last night.
We didn't know who was scum and who was not.
If we move and something similar happens again, we can create a list of good suspects.

The vigilantes should know not to randomly attack.

I found a med kit and then used it successfully.
I think the town will have a better chance of winning if we take that approach (most of us, anyway).

If somebody has another med kit, I could use a little help here ...

Then, on night 2, either Kevin or Narsis attacked Kazio. Kevin, what was your night action then?

I healed Curu.

2) why whack Kevin? well it has to do with the combination of items that us vigs started with and found during the night that makes KevinH finding a medkit night 1 highly suspect.

A desperate attempt by Narsis. The real answer is that if I had lost one more HP and nobody had watched, he would have successfully attacked me and gotten away with it.

So if KevinH is mafia, then why did he heal Curu, who is obviously not?

A wise statement.

There is absolutely no reasonable explanation why a vig would attack me. Narsis is scum and I will attack him while I have my one remaining HP.

[AKCPLUTO]

Who's in favor of ending the day early?

I am.

[Electric Mango]

NARSIS IS GUILTY BECAUSE......

He attacked KevinH, a beloved and veteran class mate who proved his "townieness" by coming to the aid of his fellow man.

He was miraculously the only one uninjured by the falling chandelier.

He claims he's a vig but for some strange reason no one else is backing up his story, in fact, everyone else wants him dead. Who needs enemies when you've got friends like these 'eh Narsis?

Claims he was saving his med pack for his partners or a trust worthy townie. Funny, I don't remember him coming to help after two of us were attacked on N1.

[Electric Mango]

I also would not mind if we ended the day early.

This looks like a pretty open and shut case to me. The sooner we end the day the less of a chance we have of Narsis moving to another room to ambush us.

[AKCPLUTO]

EM, you're following Narsis, eh?