687 replies to this topic

[Theophilos]

Ok, then Theo and AKC, but what was the logic behind going after Curu on night 1? If I was in your stead, I would have surely waited a night before hurting someone, after all you were only guessing at that time too.

Yep we had no particular lead as mentioned above I answered this questions in one of the posts already

No matter I'll go about it again; we had no particular lead, and after a discussion we decided it would be best to do an attack and a search since we (AKC and I) were in the same room with Curu. Thus I attacked and AKC searched. Now to the why ... simply because we speculated it would get a response from the rest and possibly start a discussion. Simple as that, between taking no action at all, and doing something we opted for doing something.

[ccabal86]

Curu is Curu, I pushed the button because we were all to busy umming and ahhing about it.
I am a man of action...

lol

combination of the items the vigs started with plus wanting to generate some discussion/reactions.

That's really vague. I'd say since the suspicion is heavily stacked on you, now would be a good time as any to reveal how EXACTLY you came to the conclusion that KevinH needs to go.

[AKCPLUTO]

19th, it's on pages 1-3. I remember that myself.

Attacking Curu was a mistake but it was Theo's decision.

[Narsis]

Yep we had no particular lead as mentioned above I answered this questions in one of the posts already

No matter I'll go about it again; we had no particular lead, and after a discussion we decided it would be best to do an attack and a search since we (AKC and I) were in the same room with Curu. Thus I attacked and AKC searched. Now to the why ... simply because we speculated it would get a response from the rest and possibly start a discussion. Simple as that, between taking no action at all, and doing something we opted for doing something.

taht is a very scummy thing to do. you see by limiting actions to within the rooms, the mod has given the town an invulnerable unblockable cop that is guaranteed to show that at least one of these 2 players is scum. but it only works if only scum attack at night. you attacking then is an obvious scum move. why would you attack with no leads? you'd get a definite lead within 2 days if you had waited. now instead you attacked a player(most likely a town player). that is a very scum move to do on night 1 as unless scum attack they can't possibly win.

[AKCPLUTO]

Theo, you mentioned the bad PR...for crying out loud.

[Narsis]

lol




That's really vague. I'd say since the suspicion is heavily stacked on you, now would be a good time as any to reveal how EXACTLY you came to the conclusion that KevinH needs to go.

as i said it wasn't a belief that Kevin needed to go, only a belief that he was the best target for the night. we didn't expect the chandelier to drop and hurt him.

[Narsis]

19th, it's on pages 1-3. I remember that myself.

Attacking Curu was a mistake but it was Theo's decision.

oh so now you are blaming your partner for an action that you as a group decided on. so you are the good guy and Theo is the bad guy now?

[ccabal86]

I have to agree with Narsis on this one, attacking Curu just like that definately didn't benefit the town, and just confused us regulars.

[Narsis]

lol




That's really vague. I'd say since the suspicion is heavily stacked on you, now would be a good time as any to reveal how EXACTLY you came to the conclusion that KevinH needs to go.

bleh sorry didnt really explain did i.

the vigs started with a medkit as an item. plus the fact that two were used by people that weren't a vig on night 2 of all nights...well we figured it was extremely unlikely that there were two medkits to be found and that two townies would find them on night 1.

[AKCPLUTO]

What did Kevin do to arouse suspicion?

[AKCPLUTO]

I must emphatically deny that we as the vigs have had ownership of the medkits.

[ccabal86]

as i said it wasn't a belief that Kevin needed to go, only a belief that he was the best target for the night. we didn't expect the chandelier to drop and hurt him.

Ok, fine. But what exactly led you to believe he needed to be hit then. What are these items, and why do they put the blame on KevinH

[ccabal86]

as i said it wasn't a belief that Kevin needed to go, only a belief that he was the best target for the night. we didn't expect the chandelier to drop and hurt him.

Ok, fine. But what exactly led you to believe he needed to be hit then. What are these items, and why do they put the blame on KevinH

[Narsis]

bleh sorry didnt really explain did i.

the vigs started with a medkit as an item. plus the fact that two were used by people that weren't a vig on night 2 of all nights...well we figured it was extremely unlikely that there were two medkits to be found and that two townies would find them on night 1.

Ok, fine. But what exactly led you to believe he needed to be hit then. What are these items, and why do they put the blame on KevinH

read quote above.

@AKC: well of course the mafia wouldn't start with a medkit. i dont see why they would flavourwise.

[ccabal86]

Ah, ok I just saw. Slow internet ATM....

[19thSpecOps]

lol




That's really vague. I'd say since the suspicion is heavily stacked on you, now would be a good time as any to reveal how EXACTLY you came to the conclusion that KevinH needs to go.

I beleive the mage was either nerau or narsis if he was in the room with us.

[AKCPLUTO]

Double post, cc.

Let's pretend that we as the vigs have a medkit. Demonstrate that we have used it or why we would save it for a late point in the game. We don't have a medkit. Period.

[ccabal86]

bleh sorry didnt really explain did i.

the vigs started with a medkit as an item. plus the fact that two were used by people that weren't a vig on night 2 of all nights...well we figured it was extremely unlikely that there were two medkits to be found and that two townies would find them on night 1.

@AKC: well of course the mafia wouldn't start with a medkit. i dont see why they would flavourwise.

Contradiction right there...

[19thSpecOps]

Btw can someone prod kasabian... we havent seen him at all. or he disappeared to go under the radar....though i believe unlikely that hes scum...

[Narsis]

Double post, cc.

Let's pretend that we as the vigs have a medkit. Demonstrate that we have used it or why we would save it for a late point in the game. We don't have a medkit. Period.

well of course you the scum havent used it yet...you dont have one.

why save it? we were/are planning on using it when either one of our own gets hurt enough, or someone we deem strongly enough to be town is in need of it. up until this point neither situation has come about.