381 replies to this topic

[Iron Helix]

MMk, backup time.

 

Vote: d3mon

[d3mon]

FOS: d3mon

 

 

Why is everyone voting for ISoc? I didn't see anything that might point to him being scum?

 

Duh.  More important question is: why would you be protecting him?  He should be just as suspicious(likely to be scum) to you as anyone else at this point.

 

For now though: Vote: iSocialism

 

Imho, a townie should always be concerned by bandwagons. We were quickly heading towards lynching a guy just because we need to lynch someone.. and I am not comfortable letting that happen.

[im317]

votes:

iSocialism: 6 (Alternate_Tree, Commander Shepard, iSocialism, Kilgor, Lyner, Mango, MF, Lyner, Iron Helix)

 

Electric Mango: 0 (Killgor)

Commander Shepard: 1 (iSocialism, Ogaden)

 

No Lynch: 2 (KevinH, KevinH, D3mon)

 

Imran: 0 (Iron Helix, Lyner)

 

KevinH: 2 (Kaziocore, Zacch, Mango)

 

Lyner: 0 (iSocialism)

 

Kilgor: 1 (iSocialism)

 

Ogaden: 1 (Lyner, Iron Helix)

 

Kaziocore: 1 (Imran)

 

D3mon: 1 (Iron Helix)

[Iron Helix]

 

FOS: d3mon

 

 

Why is everyone voting for ISoc? I didn't see anything that might point to him being scum?

 

Duh.  More important question is: why would you be protecting him?  He should be just as suspicious(likely to be scum) to you as anyone else at this point.

 

For now though: Vote: iSocialism

 

Imho, a townie should always be concerned by bandwagons. We were quickly heading towards lynching a guy just because we need to lynch someone.. and I am not comfortable letting that happen.

 

 

If there was going to be a lynch, there was going to be a bandwagon.  You can't have 9 votes for someone (to get a lynch) and have it not be a bandwagon or at least called it by someone.  Now that it's likely that iSocialsm is town, is it possible that some of the people who voted for him are scum? Sure.  Is it possible that scum knows iSocialism is town and see the "bandwagon" happening but remain on the sidelines? Sure.  How about both? Also possible.

 

Obviously the people voting for iSocialism didn't have any real good reason to suspect he was scum.  So when you are asking for a reason as to why he is scum, when you should know there isn't one, is suspicious because it puts you in the position of looking like someone who would profit by advocating for an innocent man (if it was found out he was innocent).  If iSocialism was scum and you were as well, then you may have been motivated to defend your ally (that seems like it's not the case at this point).  If iSocialism turned out to be scum upon a lynch, but you were innocent, then you trying to protect him (seemingly specifically) would put you in an awkward position of being the innocent who spoke up for scum (an amateurish mistake).  

 

I would think that most people would view everyone with suspicion at least to some degree (except the scum who know who's town and who's not).

 

So I think either you're playing is amateurish or you're trying to camouflage yourself.  That's my rationale at least. 

[MutedFaith]

ok. isoc gets the benefit of the doubt.

unvote

[Chaplain of death]

Lynching is always better than not, therefore....

 

Vote Isocialism

[Lyner]

Lynching is always better than not, therefore....

 

Vote Isocialism

 

iSoc has a bigger probabilty of being a townie now, so nah, I'd rather have a no lynch than lynching him

 

Unvote

[Commander Shepard]

Isoc is the jailer?
I prefer if we lynched someone who didn't post much, I'm finished voting and going to the beach.

Unvote : isoc

[Electric Mango]

That was smart of him to think ahead of like that,I'm liking his style.

[im317]

votes:

iSocialism: 4 (Alternate_Tree, Commander Shepard, iSocialism, Kilgor, Lyner, Mango, MF, Lyner, Iron Helix, Chaplain of death)

 

Electric Mango: 0 (Killgor)

 

Commander Shepard: 1 (iSocialism, Ogaden)

No Lynch: 2 (KevinH, KevinH, D3mon)

 

Imran: 0 (Iron Helix, Lyner)

 

KevinH: 2 (Kaziocore, Zacch, Mango)

 

Lyner: 0 (iSocialism)

 

Kilgor: 1 (iSocialism)

 

Ogaden: 1 (Lyner, Iron Helix)

Kaziocore: 1 (Imran)

 

D3mon: 1 (Iron Helix)

[Kaziocore]

I've been extremely busy lately, I'll catch up 16 hours from now...

[Chaplain of death]

Isoc may or may not be townie. he has just as much likelihood as everyone else. and we should lynch someone today. 

[killgor]

unvote

 

has to be done until a counterclaim shows up.

[im317]

votes:

 

iSocialism: 3 (Alternate_Tree, Commander Shepard, iSocialism, Kilgor, Lyner, Mango, MF, Lyner, Iron Helix, Chaplain of death)

 

Electric Mango: 0 (Killgor)

Commander Shepard: 1 (iSocialism, Ogaden)

 

No Lynch: 2 (KevinH, KevinH, D3mon)

 

Imran: 0 (Iron Helix, Lyner)

KevinH: 2 (Kaziocore, Zacch, Mango)

Lyner: 0 (iSocialism)

Kilgor: 1 (iSocialism)

 

Ogaden: 1 (Lyner, Iron Helix)

 

Kaziocore: 1 (Imran)

 

D3mon: 1 (Iron Helix)

[im317]

No Lynch. Final vote tally

 

iSocialism: 3 (Alternate_Tree, Commander Shepard, iSocialism, Kilgor, Lyner, Mango, MF, Lyner, Iron Helix, Chaplain of death)

 

Electric Mango: 0 (Killgor)

 

Commander Shepard: 1 (iSocialism, Ogaden)

No Lynch: 2 (KevinH, KevinH, D3mon)

Imran: 0 (Iron Helix, Lyner)

 

KevinH: 2 (Kaziocore, Zacch, Mango)

 

Lyner: 0 (iSocialism)

Kilgor: 1 (iSocialism)

Ogaden: 1 (Lyner, Iron Helix)

 

Kaziocore: 1 (Imran)

D3mon: 1 (Iron Helix)

 

 

Day 1 is now over. Night 1 will last a minimum of 3 days, and not more then 5 days. if all night actions are in before Thursday 8PM EST then that is when night 1 will end. if not night 1 will end Saturday at 8 PM EST. you may begin sending in night actions now, if you have a night action but do not want to use it let me know. game related posts during the night phase will result in a mod kill

[im317]

Reverend Purdy was on his knees praying when someone snuck up behind him and slit his
throat. Dr. Gibson has just finished treating a patient. She returned to her
room only to find someone already there. Before she could react she was shot
dead.

 

Electric Mango - Reverend Eugene ‘Gene’ Purdy: – Reverend – Town (miller) - You are a
respected leader in the community, as such you have enough sway to stop 1 lynch,
except against yourself.  As a man of God you cannot cast the final lynch vote. You are a strong motivational speaker,
once during the game you may select a player during the night phase. That player will be given a second night action the following night.

 

Killgor - Dr. Janet Gibson – Doctor – Town – Each night you may select a player, that player will be protected from death that night. You may not select the same player consecutive nights.

 

Player list:

 

2: Lyner
3: MF
4: Killgor
5: Alternate_Tree
6: Iron Helix
7: Kaziocore
8: Imran
9: Commander Shepard
10: Chaplain of death
11: KevinH
12: Zacch
13: d3mon
14: iSocialism
15: Ogaden
16: Shadow

Dead:

 

1: Electric Mango - Reverend Eugene ‘Gene’ Purdy – killed night 1

4: Killgor Dr. Janet Gibson – killed night 1

 

It is now day 2. With 14 alive it takes 8 to lynch. Day 2 ends Saturday September 14^th at 10 PM EST. Also a minor rule change. Please vote in the following format ##lynch name. any votes not using the ## will not be counted. oh and i cant figure out how to edit the topic title so if someone can tell me or edit it to say day 2 that would be great

[Electric Mango]

Noooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooo!!!!!

[KevinH]

I'm inclined to believe iSocialism is truly the jailer, but it could be a clever ruse by the scum.

We should ask, "Why were Electric Mango and Killgor selected as targets?"

They both had a vote on iSocialism and then either withdrew it (Killgor) or spoke in favor of iSocialism without actually withdrawing the vote (EM). If iSocialism were scum, I don't think he'd have incentive to kill either of them.

Another question for discussion: "Why is iSocialism still alive?"

The scum would want to eliminate known townies, so I would think iSocialism would be a prime target. Maybe they thought it was early enough in the game to let him live and wanted to use their night kill to catch a cop or other stronger role.

Still another question: "Where did the second night-kill come from?"

Is there a vigilante, serial killer, or something else at large in the game? Stephen King would be proud ...

[Iron Helix]

Since there was a miller role in the game, that means that there is most likely a cop role too (probably Walt Bannerman?).  I know there's the seer (John Smith), but the miller position wouldn't affect the seer I don't think.

 

Also, I'm not saying we should do this, but if everyone has a name accompanied with their role, why couldn't everyone just role/name claim?  Wouldn't the scum be unable to hide?  They'd have to pretend to be someone else (one of the 'good' characters from the show), right?  That would kind of ruin the game though.

 

Also there's probably a serial killer as well as the normal 'mafia' scum. 

[killgor]

just to clarify, i did not die cause i was shot, i died cause of the hole the shot made. 

 

 

also, baah!!