Hippo, when I first read your post I thought it could just be that Robert is trying to move pressure around/increase activity which can be very good for the town.. but then I noticed he never targeted iSocialism.. and that, I find very interesting.. he could just be making a gambit. Hiding in the open. Who would suspect the guy most active, the guy trying to help. (all the while knowing his targets are Townies)

It still doesn't prove his guilt, but it is quite the coincidence, and may be the best info we get today.
 

btw, I didn't target anyone, was busy the last day or two.. and Kevin!! Color the text that says it's now Night! I may have just skimmed passed it.. didn't realize it was night until just now (and now it's day lol)

Yes. if I was mafia, I wouldn't have asked kevin to ping the inactives. Inactives only help the Mafia as they won't vote cause they won't get on to lynch. I didn't lynch Isoc cause he posted more then the others. Second, day 2 no lynch doesn't help us much. Second, I voted for activity as you didn't even care what happened yesterday. Your vote is entirely preemptive strike cause you fear that I was going to after you today. the fact that I didn't vote for isoc, when I was voting for inactives, to get them active, means next to nothing. I went down the list and whoever I thought was the most inactive, I voted. If I was going to vote for somebody who I thought was scum, I would of voted you Hippo. I said just as much yesterday. Reach Hippo, Reach. 

 

I targeted Shamus again to test if my healing power worked, it has. 

 

Hippo probally didn't target anybody, if he is truely a doc. Ego has already said he didn't target anybody. So there is no help there. 

 

The main info we got was ether a CPR doc, or Quack doctor visited Isoc. Therefore, good job whoever visited Isoc. 

 

Now my theory was an experienced mafia was in the mafia. Isoc I'm 70% sure he's played a good amount of games, so my theory still fits. The fact I wasn't killed last night is surprising, but the mafia choose an inactive again. Mario was quite inactive. I need to some rereading here from day 2 as the info I am thinking of could have some value now. 

so if I had to guess who killed Isoc, that would be Rafay. Therefore if Rafay did indeed kill Isoc, that clears Rafay, and I saved Shamus from dying N1. Witch would clear me. 

So to recap the infomation out there. 

 

Mario Visited Big Ego N1. (Confirmed town now). Its anybodys guess who he protected N2. 

Lord Hippo didn't visit anybody N1, probably didn't visit anybody N2. (Neither confirmed). 

I visited Shamus N1 and N2. (If Rafay visited Isoc N2, then it be confirmed)

Rafay Visited Shamus N1, N2 is unknown, but my guess is he visited Isoc. (If so, he is confirmed and a killing doc). 

Big Ego visited Lord Hippo N1, but didn't anybody N2. (Not confirmed). 

Lyner Visted No one N1, ??? N2

Shamus ??????????????????? <I don't know if he said or not. I don't remember it. 

Patient: My stomach is getting awfully big, doctor.

Doctor: You should diet.

Patient: Really? What color?

Vote Count:

Robert2424 (1): Lord Hippo
Samus (0):
Rafay (0):
Lyner (0):
Big Ego (0):
Lord Hippo (0):

No Lynch (0):

 
Not voting (5): Samus, Rafay,  Big Ego, Robert2424, Lyner

Deadline is 5 pm EDT, Wednesday, May 27.
With 6 alive it takes 4 to lynch or 2 at deadline.

I visited iSocialism N2 indeed........So I'm the quack doctor......Damn.

I visited Ego last night. He is still alive.

Lyner did vote 4 mario but mario considered Lord Hippo as scum on D2.

so that confirms me and Rafay as town unless somebody going to say they targeted Isoc last night. (Btw, YOUR WELCOME SHAMUS, I SAVED YOU)

 

Hippo claims to have visited Big Ego. 

 

We need Lyner and shamus to give there info now. Kevin, can you please and thank you ping them both?

 

@Rafay, now you know and you didn't hurt the town. Now if you have to use your night action to try to hit scum you can. 

Rafay is confirmed town. (I'm making an assumption that he's not lying when he said he targeted iSoc, but w/e)           

Rafay is most likely a CPR Doctor. 

Nobody protected iSoc, so he died. 

On N1, Robert protected Shamus, which cancelled out Rafay's CPR-doc powers. Robert confimed townie pending further information. 

I visited Big Ego last night. I cannot confirm anything because of that visit, however. 

Ego visited me on Night1. He cannot confirm anything either afaik.

 

Confirmed Town: {Rafay, Myself, Ego, Robert}

 

Unvote

 

Of course, this is pending further information from the ever absent Shamus and Lyner.  

 

Here's the information we DON'T have: 

 

What kind of Doctor were EM and Mario? 

Is Rafay a Quack or CPR?

Who is the other killer-doctor? Maybe EM or Mario? 

    -Worth noting that it is not myself or Ego. We both targeted each other, and neither of us died.

    -Mario visited Ego in the night as well, and his innocent could have been proved through this as well. 

 

 

 

I can't help but wonder why you visited the same guy twice in a row, Robert. Not trying to pull anything. Legitimately just want to know your reasoning.

 

 

PS. @Mod: Call Lyner and Shamus. We need them.

Bah.

I think I maybe a quack???

Doctor: Have you ever had this before?

Patient: Yes.

Doctor: Well, you've got it again!

Vote Count:

Robert2424 (0): 
Master Master Samus (0):
Rafay (0):
Lyner (0):
Big Ego (0):
Lord Hippo (0):

No Lynch (0):

 
Not voting (6): Master Master Samus, Rafay,  Big Ego, Robert2424, Lyner, Lord Hippo

Deadline is 5 pm EDT, Wednesday, May 27.
With 6 alive it takes 4 to lynch or 2 at deadline.

Rafay is confirmed town. (I'm making an assumption that he's not lying when he said he targeted iSoc, but w/e)           

Rafay is most likely a CPR Doctor. 

Nobody protected iSoc, so he died. 

On N1, Robert protected Shamus, which cancelled out Rafay's CPR-doc powers. Robert confimed townie pending further information. 

I visited Big Ego last night. I cannot confirm anything because of that visit, however. 

Ego visited me on Night1. He cannot confirm anything either afaik.

 

Confirmed Town: {Rafay, Myself, Ego, Robert}

 

Unvote

 

Of course, this is pending further information from the ever absent Shamus and Lyner.  

 

Here's the information we DON'T have: 

 

What kind of Doctor were EM and Mario? 

Is Rafay a Quack or CPR?

Who is the other killer-doctor? Maybe EM or Mario? 

    -Worth noting that it is not myself or Ego. We both targeted each other, and neither of us died.

    -Mario visited Ego in the night as well, and his innocent could have been proved through this as well. 

 

 

 

I can't help but wonder why you visited the same guy twice in a row, Robert. Not trying to pull anything. Legitimately just want to know your reasoning.

 

 

PS. @Mod: Call Lyner and Shamus. We need them.

honestly, it was mainly testing my powers again. Shamus isn't very active so if I was a quack or CPR, i figure if he was town, hes pretty inactive and isn't helping us much anyways. So I didn't have much of a prefence. I don't trust him, but if he was targeted, witch I thought was a possibly. 

 

Also, how in the world are you and big ego confirmed?!?

I used my action on him. He lived. 

He used his action on me. I lived. 

 

There is only one mafioso left alive, and with the way he's been acting since Day1, as well as the abence of Lyner and Shamus, I'm reasonably confidant that he's townie. more than 90%. 

 

Not 100%, but close enough.

So to recap the infomation out there. 

 

Mario Visited Big Ego N1. (Confirmed town now). Its anybodys guess who he protected N2. 

Lord Hippo didn't visit anybody N1, probably didn't visit anybody N2. (Neither confirmed). 

I visited Shamus N1 and N2. (If Rafay visited Isoc N2, then it be confirmed)

Rafay Visited Shamus N1, N2 is unknown, but my guess is he visited Isoc. (If so, he is confirmed and a killing doc). 

Big Ego visited Lord Hippo N1, but didn't anybody N2. (Not confirmed). 

Lyner Visted No one N1, ??? N2

Shamus ??????????????????? <I don't know if he said or not. I don't remember it. 

 

Rafay is most definitely the Quacker

 

I targeted Samus last night. Good news is at least one of us saved him. Bad news is we don't know which one

 

Rafay did a good job, now we have 5 lives to spend if we didn't lynch anybody on the day to figure out which doctor is which and try experimenting during the night, how does it sound?

Yep, seems luck was on our side. We have a good deal of wiggle room now.

Would love to hear Shamus weigh in. What'd you do N2 Shamus?

So, Lyner visited Shamus N2. If true, I still could be CPR doctor. Makes things more complicated. 

n2 I protected Hippo.

 

I've finally finished exams, so i'm gonna give this thread a good old read this evening!

 

Also if you guys call keep calling me Shamus, i'm not notified when i'm mentioned!

 

Samus please <3

Person            N1                    N2

 

Samus...........???...................Hippo

Lyner.............???...................Samus

Hippo.............N/A...................Ego

Robert...........Samus..............Samus

Ego................Hippo...............???

Rafay.............iSoc..................Samus

 

Just making a chart of who visited who on N1 and N2. Obviously someone is lying (Mafia can't visit anyone). We just need to figure out who. There are two problems with this self-selecting the liar among us: 

1. Nobody has proof of who they visited.

2. A visit might result in nothing happening.  

 

That said, it would still be pretty cool if you guys could help me fill this out. It's almost done.

I should have put Shamus ffs. Samus' name messed everything up.

I don't like it auto correcting me, so I've always used Shamus. 

Mrs. Smith: Help me, doctor! My son, John, swallowed the can opener!

Doctor: Don't panic. He'll be alright.

Mrs. Smith: But how do I open the can of beans?! The toast is getting cold!

Vote Count:

Robert2424 (0): 
Master Master Master Samus (0):
Rafay (0):
Lyner (0):
Big Ego (0):
Lord Hippo (0):

No Lynch (0):

 
Not voting (6): Master Master Master Samus, Rafay,  Big Ego, Robert2424, Lyner, Lord Hippo

Deadline is 5 pm EDT, Wednesday, May 27.
With 6 alive it takes 4 to lynch or 2 at deadline.

Person            N1                    N2

 

Master Samus...........???...................Hippo

Lyner...............N/A...................Master Samus

Hippo.............N/A...................Ego

Robert...........Master Samus..............Master Samus

Ego................Hippo...............???

Rafay............Samus..................iSoc

 

Just making a chart of who visited who on N1 and N2. Obviously someone is lying (Mafia can't visit anyone). We just need to figure out who. There are two problems with this self-selecting the liar among us: 

1. Nobody has proof of who they visited.

2. A visit might result in nothing happening.  

 

That said, it would still be pretty cool if you guys could help me fill this out. It's almost done.

I should have put Shamus ffs. Master Samus' name messed everything up.

 

FTFY

 

It's pretty difficult to do the math with only two nights, unless it has the right combination

 

So yes fill this up please

We are running out of time. We only have to Wednesday, and I honestly trust nobody to generate us to the next step of activity. Weather it be this game or the Iron city mafia, inactivity should be a sign of scummness. Shamus was scum in Iron city mafia, and played mainly an inactive card, and now doing the same. I am very suspect of him. Ego activity is very poor, Lyner seems to be perking up, but I'm not holding my breath that he'll post before this day phase ends again. In fact, its surprising there has been this many posts this day phase, but we are running out of time. 

 

If we were playing on the forums I learned how to play on, this game would of been over with due to inactivity, and mafia get the win. The time we've been given is very long compared to 3 day day phases and 1 day night phase. Then peneltys enforced by the mod if there is mass inactivity for all. Meaning even shorter day phases. Role Restrictions were a possibility also. 

 

This game is very winnable still, but if we do nothing with this time to post, we might as well just wait till the mafia pick us off one by one. (unless there are unforeseen circumstances. )

 

We Know me and Rafay are town. I know I have the ability to heal. Rafay can kill a target at night. I would encourage him to pick off inactives, and use his best judgment to who he think is more scummy. Its his role, not mine though. The choice is ultimately his. 

 

So that means one of the following are scum, Shamus, Lyner, Ego, or Hippo are scum. We should choose to lynch one of the following. So, who should we lynch, the most inactive out the 4? Or is there reason enough to lynch one the more active out the 4? Only the last mafia knows he is mafia. If your one of the 4 and you are town and reading this, you know you are, but there is no way to prove you are. 

 

We should make a post count of this day, and one for the entire game. 

 

Honestly, this game could come down to only me and rafay, or Rafay having to kill the last mafia. we have a 25% chance picking correctly. Our odds are hurt if we don't lynch. Mafia will most likely if they can, try to take ether me or Rafay out as we are confirmed if given the chance. However, your abiltys are of your own and you should use them where you think they'll do the most good. Nobody should reveal who they'll be targeting tomorrow. I should make this very clear. 

 

if you can't be active, and your town, you should be replaced. Even if you don't have an idea how to find scum, find some way to contribute to the conversation. At this point, if we can't rally off of killing somebody who is active, we should lynch and inactive, and the most inactive should be first. If they are hiding hoping to slip under the radar, they'll most likely immediately come back to try to defend them self. 

 

Throw ideas out there, or me and Rafay will have to decide everything. 

out of the 4, shamus is the most inactive out the 4. If your not contributing to help find scum, your contributing to help the scum win. I will allow the board to do its auto correct so he can see this. I'm perfectly fine in lynching him. 

 

Vote Samus

 

If you have somebody in mind you think we should lynch besides you Shamus, you should speak now. We have till Wednesday.