Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

IRON Forums Website

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

MSGSHCI - Game Thread

Featured Replies

  • Replies 894
  • Views 36.4k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

This seems to me like a very well thought out plan by KevinH and EM. KevinH cast suspicion towards a vocal player, Falzis, but doesn't risk first vote. Once public begins to agree, he places his vote. There is now a strong case aganist a townie.

I went from FOS to SFOS to Vote in less than 24 hours.

 

OK

 

FOS: Electric Mango and Falsis

 

If Sojourner had been lynched and found to be innocent, the suspicion would have been on them.

SFOS: Electric Mango and Falzis
One more vote at the deadline and he'd have been dead. That's not close?

Vote: Falzis

for attempting to mislead.

 

If I'd have voted any faster, I'd have been accused of being hasty.

I gave reasons for my vote when I made it; that's not waiting for the public to agree.

Might as well name two my self: Falzis and EM (I promissed a FoS - well here it is ...).

 

I'm not gonna repeat everything about Falzis ... the fact that sojourner died just additionally confirmes my suspicions, I had a hunch about EM 'cause of all the support he was giving Falzis, that hunch is now a FoS.

 

First time I expressed my opinion that EM was scum ... and persisted with that to his lynch.

 

In Theo's case, there could have been some unvotes but his vote prevented that. Yes, the motivation could have been "EM's going down, I better join in" but it could also have been "I want to lynch EM and I'm not going to allow any last minute unvotes."

 

My vote for EM was based on the fact that I was convinced he was scum, and I saw no harm in moving my vote from Falzis to EM to end that round. Remember at that point I was still SURE that Falzis was scum and EM his "mate" ... so lynching either was fine with me.

maybe maybe not, but that does seem to be their plan.

 

@the other townies: we need to lynch someone today. we are in LYLO if there are 2 scum left(which there likely are). we have to lynch scum. so my suggestion would be to vote for the person you believe most likely to be scum at this point in time.

Well, it seems like it will be either KevinH or Sir Jesus. I am going to vote now, because I think everyone should get their votes in. We don't want the mafia to be able to come in a few hours before deadline and decide the lynch.

 

Both KevinH and Sir Jesus have done something that could be suspicious. EM had been aggresively targetting Sir Jesus throughout day 3. So that makes me think that Sir Jesus is less likely to be scum. KevinH on the other hand hasn't been able to convince me that he is a townie. So I will:

 

vote: KevinH

Personally, I think that KevinH is scum.
KevinH on the other hand hasn't been able to convince me that he is a townie.
I'll have to vote for KevinH.

 

Well, what can I do to prove my towniness other than die? The three votes against me could easily be misguided townies, and Sir Jesus hasn't voted yet ...

 

This post is where I quoted Aquinas and Falzis. They both suspected Sir Jesus. Falzis also added Narsis.

 

I thought the voting patterns made Sir Jesus the best choice but there are already three votes that disagree with me.

 

Unvote: Sir Jesus

 

Assuming there are 2 scum, Narsis is my next choice.

 

Vote: Narsis II

 

Theophilos and Sir Jesus: if you are townies, I urge you to vote for Narsis with me. Maybe one of the townie votes on me will shift to make is a lynch.

 

If there are 2 scum and I die, then the town loses. If there's only 1 scum and I die, then please consider what I have posted.

 

Lots of activity, so here's another quick count.

VOTE COUNT

KevinH (3): Narsis II, Martino, Kaziocore

Narsis II (1): KevinH

 

Not Voting (2): Theophilos, Sir Jesus

 

With 6 Alive, 4 is needed to lynch.

Edited by molestargazer

I guess my vote can't hurt ... so vote: Narsis ... might as well give Kevin a chance to stay alive if he indeed is a townie ...

 

That said I'm still not sure who are the 2 remaining scum <_< ... as I said my vote in it self changes nothing so ...

  • Author

VOTE COUNT

KevinH (4): Narsis II, Martino, Kaziocore, Sir Jesus

Narsis II (2): KevinH, Theophilos

 

With 6 Alive, 4 is needed to lynch.

 

Without any further ado, the lynch mob quickly drag KevinH back to his cell. He screamed in pain as he was pushed against the cold stone wall, then stepped forward and continued to push his innocence.

Slowly, tempers frayed. It was Sir Jesus who stepped forward and delivered a blow of massive force to KevinH's head, whose head snapped back with the force of the punch. There is a horrible dull thud as KevinH's head hits the wall. Rocked by momentum, the body of KevinH falls forward and blood begins to spread across the floor of his cell.

 

Frantically, the inmates begin to search the cell. After a few minutes, two of the inmates shake their heads sadly and walk out the cell. The others continue to search, but find nothing that points to KevinH being guilty.

 

KevinH, TOWNIE, has been lynched.

  • Author

"Dammit!" Theophilos finally stands up with anger. "Nothing! And where have those two gone?"

Realisation dawns in the eyes of Narsis, who stands up slowly. "Oh, god..."

Kaziocore whips around just as Sir Jesus and Martino walk back into the cell and cover the doorway. They are each holding a very long kitchen knife.

 

Kaziocore lets out a scream and charges at the scumpair. Taken by surprise, Martino falls back, but Sir Jesus stands his ground and plunges the knife into Kaziocore's torso. Looking into his eyes, the remaining inmates see no trace of madness at all. Sir Jesus is perfectly sane - and out to make a profit. Martino chuckles madly, and moves forward again. They make short work of the unarmed pair.

 

Kaziocore, TOWNIE, has been killed in the endgame.

Narsis II, TOWNIE, has been killed in the endgame.

Theophilos, COP, has been killed in the endgame.

 

MAFIA WIN!

- SIR JESUS (Godfather)

- ELECTRIC MANGO (Goon)

- MARTINO (Goon)

 

 

 

 

 

 

ROLES

Theophilos - Paranoid Cop (Receives 'Guilty' to all investigations)

Sojourner - Townie

Nerau / Narsis II - Townie

Sir Jesus - Godfather

CanucksDynasty - Townie

Narsis - Weak Doc (Dies if protects scum)

Electric Mango - Scum Goon

Martino - Scum Goon

Junkahoolik - Macho Cop (Cannot be doc protected)

Falzis - Townie

Kaziocore - Townie

KevinH - Townie

Aquinas - Townie

 

NIGHT ACTIONS

N1:

Para. Cop - Investigates Falzis

Scum - Kill Junkahoolik

Weak Doc - No Action

Macho Cop - Investigates Sir Jesus

 

N2:

Para. Cop - Investigates Electric Mango

Scum - Kill Narsis

Weak Doc - Protect Aquinas

 

N3:

Para. Cop - Investigates Sir Jesus

Scum - Kill CanucksDynasty

 

N4:

Para. Cop - No Action

Scum - Kill Aquinas

  • Author

ROLE PMS

 

SIR JESUS

Actually, the situation wasn't that bad. It was stupid of you to get arrested, but the wild arrest had paved the way for a very successful insanity plea in court. Of course, that was nonesense. You're as clear-headed as you ever was.

You are Tony, currently the head of the Sicilian Mafia. Originally, you had just intended to escape this insitution - but then you saw a way to make a little profit. Together with your partner-in-crime, ELECTRIC MANGO, and a quick-witted patient who had also joined the cause, MARTINO, you could make a nice profit from this.

 

You are the MAFIA GODFATHER.

You will appear Innocent to any investigative role in the game.

You may talk with your partners ELECTRIC MANGO and MARTINO during NIGHTS only, in this quicktopic - CLICK HERE.

Once per night, YOU may send in to me the name of someone to be killed. If you die, ELECTRIC MANGO takes over sending in kills.

You win when the Mafia equals or outnumbers the town.

Please confirm you have received your Role by replying to this PM.

 

ELECTRIC MANGO

Actually, the situation wasn't that bad. It was stupid of you to get arrested, but the wild arrest had paved the way for a very successful insanity plea in court. Of course, that was nonesense. You're as clear-headed as you ever was.

You are Joey, a member of the Sicilian Mafia. You followed your godfather, SIR JESUS, and was arrested - however, you were now in this institution - and had hatched a plan to make a nice profit, along with a patient who had joined the cause, MARTINO.

 

You are a MAFIA GOON.

You may talk with your partners SIR JESUS and MARTINO during NIGHTS only, in this quicktopic - CLICK HERE.

Once per night, SIR JESUS may send in to me the name of someone to be killed. If he dies die, YOU take over sending in kills.

You win when the Mafia equals or outnumbers the town.

Please confirm you have received your Role by replying to this PM.

 

 

MARTINO

You, Jesse, had originally booked yourself into the psychiatric hospital after being convicted of ABH by the local courts. For some time prior to the incident, you had been hearing quiet voices in your head. You decided it needed medical attention. However, a few days after he was admitted, the voices had stopped. All of a sudden. He hadn't even taken any medication. Now you wanted to get out, and after overhearing talks between two mafia members planning an escape and robbery, you decided to throw yourself in.

 

You are a MAFIA GOON.

You may talk with your partners SIR JESUS and ELECTRIC MANGO during NIGHTS only, in this quicktopic - CLICK HERE.

Once per night, SIR JESUS may send in to me the name of someone to be killed. If he dies, ELECTRIC MANGO takes over sending in kills.

You win when the Mafia equals or outnumbers the town.

Please confirm you have received your Role by replying to this PM.

 

 

THEOPHILOS

You are Roy, an ex-police officer who was arrested after brutally killing an inmate in your local police station suspected of raping a close relative. Now the killings have started again, you have decided to put your previous experience to good use.

 

You are a COP.

Once per night, you may send in the name of a player to me and you will discover their alignment - 'Pro-Scum' or 'Pro-Town'.

You win when all members of anti-town factions are dead.

Please confirm you have received your Role by replying to this PM.

 

 

JUNKAHOOLIK

You are Joe, a guard at the MSG Secure Hospital for the Criminally Insane. In the small hours of the morning, you check your pocket to find your keys have gone missing. Then the killings start. You can now use your position to try and find the killers.

 

You are a MACHO COP.

Once per night, you may send in the name of a player to me and you will discover their alignment - 'Pro-Scum' or 'Pro-Town'.

Since you are not a patient in the hospital, you cannot be protected by any of the Doctors of the hospital.

You win when all members of anti-town factions are dead.

Please confirm you have received your Role by replying to this PM.

 

 

NARSIS

You are Lauren, a Nurse at the MSG Hospital. Your job as Night Manager is to ensure that all of the patients are safe in their cells. This means that you are able to protect a patient during the night from a horrible fate. However, your tendency to be careless with your job could mean danger for you if you protect the wrong person…

 

You are a WEAK DOC.

Once per night, you may send in the name of a player to me and that player will be protected from any Night-Kill attempts against them.

You will die if you attempt to protect a member of the Mafia.

You win when all members of anti-town factions are dead.

Please confirm you have received your Role by replying to this PM.

 

 

SOJOURNER

You are Greg, a drug addict admitted to the MSGSHCI after knocking several pharmacy staff unconscious in a robbery to score narcotics. Now the deaths have started, you need to track down those responsible and lynch them… before they kill everyone inside.

 

You are a VANILLA TOWNIE.

You have no powers other than your lynch vote during the day. Use it.

You win when all members of anti-town factions are dead.

Please confirm you have received your Role by replying to this PM.

 

 

NERAU

You are Eric, admitted to the MSGSHCI after being convicted of stalking your ex-wife. Now the killings have started, you need to kill them first… before they kill everyone inside.

 

You are a VANILLA TOWNIE.

You have no powers other than your lynch vote during the day. Use it.

You win when all members of anti-town factions are dead.

Please confirm you have received your Role by replying to this PM.

 

 

CALDERONE

You are Alison, admitted to the MSGSCHI after viciously attacking and biting a police officer who was attempting to stop-search you. Now the killings have started, you need to find out who’s doing the killings before you die yourself.

 

You are a VANILLA TOWNIE.

You have no powers other than your lynch vote during the day. Use it.

You win when all members of anti-town factions are dead.

Please confirm you have received your Role by replying to this PM.

 

 

FALZIS

You are Rob, admitted to the MSGSCHI after an incident in a hospital where you attacked a doctor trying to diagnose you. You don’t know why. But now the killings have started, you need to stop those who are doing it before they kill everyone in the hospital.

 

You are a VANILLA TOWNIE.

You have no powers other than your lynch vote during the day. Use it.

You win when all members of anti-town factions are dead.

Please confirm you have received your Role by replying to this PM.

 

 

KAZIOCORE

You are James, admitted to the MSGSCHI after poisoning your ex-wife over dinner. Now someone has been found dead, you need to help the others find who the killers are and stop them. ‘Stop’ with a noose. And perhaps an overdose of pills if you’re feeling particularly lucky.

 

You are a VANILLA TOWNIE.

You have no powers other than your lynch vote during the day. Use it.

You win when all members of anti-town factions are dead.

Please confirm you have received your Role by replying to this PM.

 

 

KEVINH

You are Lisa. You can’t actually remember why you’re in the MSGSHCI, but you must’ve done something bad… so you need to make up for it, right? You need to kill off all the bad guys killing people.

 

You are a VANILLA TOWNIE.

You have no powers other than your lynch vote during the day. Use it.

You win when all members of anti-town factions are dead.

Please confirm you have received your Role by replying to this PM.

 

 

AQUINAS

You are Dara. You’re not actually sure why you’re in the MSGSHCI, but the fact that you have a guard outside your cell at all times shows that, well, it was probably pretty bad. Still. You need to help the others out now – your guard is dead, and you need to find out who the killers are before they kill everyone inside.

 

You are a VANILLA TOWNIE.

You have no powers other than your lynch vote during the day. Use it.

You win when all members of anti-town factions are dead.

Please confirm you have received your Role by replying to this PM.

AWWW YEEAAHH!! Good stuff guys. :)

 

NIGHT ACTIONS

N1:

Para. Cop - Investigates Falzis

Scum - Kill Junkahoolik

Weak Doc - No Action

Macho Cop - Investigates Sir Jesus

 

Wow, that was close.

AWWW YEEAAHH!! Good stuff guys. :)

 

 

 

Wow, that was close.

 

actually, i got a innocent result :P

 

why did you choose me?? did you think i was the cop or was it cause i was too active??

  • Author

Indeed. Godfathers always get innocent in my games (With the exception of the paranoid cop):

You are the MAFIA GODFATHER.

You will appear Innocent to any investigative role in the game.

You may talk with your partners ELECTRIC MANGO and MARTINO during NIGHTS only, in this quicktopic - CLICK HERE.

Once per night, YOU may send in to me the name of someone to be killed. If you die, ELECTRIC MANGO takes over sending in kills.

You win when the Mafia equals or outnumbers the town.

Please confirm you have received your Role by replying to this PM.

actually, i got a innocent result :P

 

why did you choose me?? did you think i was the cop or was it cause i was too active??

 

 

Martino   7   06-12-2009 02:32 AM ET (US)   For me it is pretty much the opposite. I think this is the fourth or fifth game in a row that I am mafia. Anyway, about our target. I think you forgot about Narsis in the experienced player list; I believe he is a bigger threat than Falzis. With this few experienced players on the town’s side, it is actually a pretty hard choice If we eliminate Narsis and KevinH in the first two night, then we should be able to win. However if the town concludes that we were eliminating the experienced players, it will lead them straight to us. How about targeting Junkahoolik or Falzis? With this many inexperienced townies and because Sojourner is new, we may actually get them to believe he took one of his voters out himself. Of course, we have to be careful not to mention this theory ourselves.

 

Electric Mango   8   06-12-2009 08:04 PM ET (US)   I wouldn't mind targeting Junkahoolik and I agree with this strategy. I would rather have Falzis stay alive because he already gave me the pro town vote of confidence.

 

Sir jesus   11   06-14-2009 03:04 PM ET (US)   Sorry guys, been busy and poppin in and out really fast.I would agree with killing Junka, if you guys want to that can be our kill.

 

As you can see, it was an highly analyzed decision. :P

Narsis was chosen by my intuition. :D

 

Sir jesus   16   06-29-2009 11:13 PM ET (US)   So guys, what do you think?My gut reaction says to kill Narsis.

 

Martino   17   06-30-2009 03:28 AM ET (US)   I could agree with killing Narsis.

 

EM   18   06-30-2009 11:42 AM ET (US)   I'd be fine for killing Narsis as well. I was thinking him or Kevin, or even CD

 

Sir jesus   19   06-30-2009 06:33 PM ET (US)   I want to kill Kevin, but I feel like he has enough heat on him that the town may lynch him without our help. I feel like killing a replacement is less likely to take out a power role.I'm confirming the kill of Narsis with Mole now.

Theophilos, you investigated me on N1. So that's why you really believed I was scum. WTF on that role.

 

Martino, why did you make a case for lynching Electric Mango? Indeed, as KevinH predicted, you played a perfect game. I was sure Sir Jesus was scum when EM was proven to be one since they were in sync on D1 and used the same approach to me (saying I was townie and such). I would never have thought Martino to be scum.

Yep, that's why I was sure you were scum ... so imagine my shock when Mole wrote the story line and you were declared a townie. I was going WTF!? Even wrote Mole a PM if he made a mistake >.< (yeah, yeah my first Mafia game, I know).

That was well-played by the scum.

 

Martino was the least suspicious so deserves lots of credit. EM set up Falzis so he gets credit, too.

 

Regarding my towniness, "I told you so!"

 

EM: were you role-fishing just prior to getting lynched?

Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.