199 replies to this topic

[Lachiton]

Well shit. At least now y'all know it wasn't me! Good luck y'all!

 

I had pretty good inclination that it wasn't you. I asked Jazzy to investigate you just to be safe.

Anyways I protected Jazzy as promised but he was not targeted. 

Surprised I wasn't targeted and not targeting Jazzy makes sense.

So Kevin anything more to say?

[Jazzy95]

Vote: Kevin

[Lachiton]

@Kevin - Probably your last chance to defend yourself.

[Lachiton]

Alright so Kevin is MIA and with deadline approaching I have to place my vote.

I am quite confident Kevin is our last scum, but if Jazzy turns out scum I will say well played and town wouldn't have figured it out in any way.

Also quite sure our last scum is SK.


Vote: KevinH

 

 

(Remembered to bold it this time lol)

[KevinH]

I'm dead.

[Rafay]

KevinH, the Serial Killer has been Lynched.

 

Town (Jazzy95, Lachiton, brewsersalliance, Lord MK, Wolfpacks, Colonel MedVed, MsShawdi) Wins

Jazzy was the Cop and Lachiton the Doctor

 

N1: 

brewsers and Kevin did nothing.

Jazzy investigated Robert

Mafia blocked MedVed killed Lord MK

Lachiton saved Kevin

 

N2:

brewsers killed MedVed

Kevin killed brewsers.

Jazzy investigated Wolfpacks

Mafia could not submit night actions due to deadline.

Lachiton saved Jazzy

 

N3: 

Kevin did nothing.

Jazzy investigated iSocialism but was blocked

Mafia blocked iSocialism

 

Lachiton saved Jazzy

 

N4: 

Kevin killed Wolfpacks.

Jazzy investigated Lachiton

Lachiton saved Jazzy

 

N5:

Kevin killed MsShawdi

Lachiton saved Jazzy

Jazzy investigated MsShawdi.

 

Mod Comments: The town didnt deserve to win. Played really badly and most were inactive. IMO Kevin was the best player. I' surprised that the game lasted till D6!!! I was expecting the end by D2 or 3 max. But why didn't you guys use your powers? Lachiton was good too btw he saved the game for the town.

[Jazzy95]

I was fine lynching Kevin, as I believed he was scummy in some way, D5, I just believed Lach's doctor claim and so was fine waiting.

 

Not sure why Kevin killed MsShawdi, Lach seemed like the better target due to inactivity.

 

Lachiton was good too btw he saved the game for the town.

RIP my efforts  

 

 

 

Robert's lynch was total luck on role assignments. I did visit him N1 hoping he'd be guilty so I could get back at him, the stars just aligned for that to happen.

[KevinH]

Not sure why Kevin killed MsShawdi, Lach seemed like the better target due to inactivity.

 

I thought my best chance was to paint Lachiton as a godfather.
"Working theory #1: Lachiton is a godfather that kept iSocialism alive Day 3, but decided get town cred by joining the lynch on Day 4."

(and it was plausible)

 

I was a serial killer and would have come up as not guilty in an investigation so I was sort of hoping to be investigated.  Then Lach and I would have been on equal footing regarding in terms of investigations and my voting history was more townie.  MsShawdie had the same history as me with the benefit of being the hammer on the first mafia killed when she could have not voted and kept him alive.

[iSocialism]

I wasn't able to RB and sumbit a kill in the same night as the only scum left. Deadline was only 24 hours. Lach was my target the night before my lynched. I would've false claim as a watcher saying I saw Kevin visit lach. I could have still false claim or said that I known that there was a SK. But I rather have town lose.
Plus after n3 I was just done with the game

[Lachiton]

I was almost sure Kevin was the last scum on D5 and depending on the extra kills I blocked and voting patterns, it was quite evident we had a SK.

But I need some clarification here - I got 2 "Successful" messages from Rafay, on N2 and N3 while protecting Jazzy. I thought I had blocked 2 attempts to kill him, which eventually led me to believe we have one scum who got an extra kill. I initially thought we might have a mafia JOAT, especially after Jazzy was blocked on N3. But after iSoc came up as RB, I was confident we got SK who was extremely crafty and surely a veteran. Kevin fit the bill perfectly. So to be fair, the successful messages I got back helped a lot in making up my mind about SK. So I am confused as to why I was given those messages if mafia didnt target Jazzy (why wont you target him btw?). Rafay says it was N2 where mafia didnt submit a kill, iSoc says it was N3, again confusion lol.

Lach was my target the night before my lynched. I would've false claim as a watcher saying I saw Kevin visit lach. I could have still false claim or said that I known that there was a SK.

How would you have framed Kevin though? If you even figured out there was a SK, it would have been a wild guess as to who it was. Besides Kevin had more townie cred than you at that point and even if you successfully framed Kevin, there was big possibility he would have been town and you would have been dead man walking after his lynch. So without being sure it was Kevin as SK, you would have been taking a huge potential risk. Also if you have not been lynched and revealed as RB, presence of a SK wouldn't have crossed my mind either. Mafia JOAT is what my assumption was before your lynch. 

[Lachiton]

Lachiton was good too btw he saved the game for the town.

Thank you for the mention. Knowing about extra kills and revealing of iSoc as RB led me to the serial killer theory. Coupled that with Kevin's incessant push for his godfather theory, it became evident that he wanted to derail the discussion.

Jazzy deserves credit too btw. If it hadn't been for our perfect first lynch, we wouldn't have got iSoc under the scanner so early. Also it helped me stick with the one confirmed townie. I was hoping to survive as long as I can and help Jazzy survive till the end as well. I only needed him to trust me, so in hindsight I was happy he decided to investigate me and after that it was perfect time for me to role claim and put forward my suspicion of a SK presence.

Well played Kevin as well. Playing as SK is never easy as you are essentially alone and Kevin being the veteran, covered up his kills very well and almost won it for himself.

[brewersalliance]

 

Not sure why Kevin killed MsShawdi, Lach seemed like the better target due to inactivity.

 

I thought my best chance was to paint Lachiton as a godfather.
"Working theory #1: Lachiton is a godfather that kept iSocialism alive Day 3, but decided get town cred by joining the lynch on Day 4."

(and it was plausible)

 

I was a serial killer and would have come up as not guilty in an investigation so I was sort of hoping to be investigated.  Then Lach and I would have been on equal footing regarding in terms of investigations and my voting history was more townie.  MsShawdie had the same history as me with the benefit of being the hammer on the first mafia killed when she could have not voted and kept him alive.

 

I think your best chance to win would have been kill lach andpaint jazzy as the sk.  jazzy claimed he was RB'd the night there were no kills, so it would have been easier to frame him than lachiton.

 

and no offense to msshawdi, but if i had to pick a player to try to convince and put 100% of my fate in their hands, I would have wanted to go with the player who was in their very first game of mafia.  sure she seems to have a decent understanding, but it was still only her first game, and combine it well a well written argument that jazzy was the SK and you could have won.

 

I had my reasons for thinking jazzy was the sk.  MsShawdi dying actually made me very sure it was jazzy.  I thought no way would kevin leave Lach alive, especially cause he could have protected your target but not himself. plus lachiton seemed like he was 100% going to vote for kevinH anyways, so when msshawdi died, I thought it was jazzy setting up a for sure lynch of kevin to win the game.  but im glad i was wrong!
 

 

And when I shot medved, it was a coinflip between him and KevinH but I went with medved because i figured if they were both town id rather loose medved since I know hes going to be very inactive.  I was leaning towards kevin at first because of starting the second wagon and where he was in the post count (thought he was trying to hide in the middle) but changed my mind at the last second.  Should have just stuck with my first thoughts and shot him lol

But why didn't you guys use your powers?

 

 

 

Also, who didnt use their powers?

[KevinH]

I skipped kills on N1 and N3.

N1 I wasn't sure if I would be tracked.

N3 I thought that the mafia faction would kill somebody we would have an odd number in D4; that didn't work out.

[Lachiton]

I had my reasons for thinking jazzy was the sk. MsShawdi dying actually made me very sure it was jazzy. I thought no way would kevin leave Lach alive, especially cause he could have protected your target but not himself. plus lachiton seemed like he was 100% going to vote for kevinH anyways, so when msshawdi died, I thought it was jazzy setting up a for sure lynch of kevin to win the game. but im glad i was wrong

I actually had the same suspicion as well lol. I had been protecting Jazzy throughout the game and was confident he was town till Shawdi was killed. I was having two thoughts then - 1) Kevin kept me alive to paint me as godfather (which coincidentally was Kevin's line of thought) 2) Jazzy knew I was gonna vote for Kevin from my previous day arguments so kept both me and Kevin alive. I was thinking the worst case scenario might be Jazzy as a SK with cop/tracker role.

 

That is why I waited to place my vote on the last day and wanted Kevin to make his move first. When he didnt show up, I went with my instincts and hoped my trust in Jazzy was not misplaced.

[Lord MK]

So why was i killed?
Colonel Medved

[Lachiton]

iSoc and Robert chose you lol
Medved got killed by brewers.

[Lachiton]

Lol, this one is getting interesting. I bet that Kevin will win this one. Whichever side he's on.

Also lol at this. You seem to be getting most of the things wrong with mafia nowadays

[Wolfpacks]

See I was wondering why Kevin hadn't died,

[Lord MK]

See I was wondering why Kevin hadn't died,

Thus why i guessed that he will win.



Also
Why did you choose me?
iSocialism Robert2424

I am becoming a threat these days, i guess. 😎

[Robert2424]

opted to kill somebody that hasn't died n1 yet to be fair to everyone. Keven if frequently killed n1. Course I wanted to kill jazzy n1 as well but isoc talked me out of it. So if I could of convinced Isoc, this game could of went entirely different.