494 replies to this topic

[brewersalliance]

As much as I suspect Rafay at this moment, I am not opposed to voting for iSoc or Canik if they don't start contributing.

 

 

why leave shawdi off this list?  she has posted the least of anyone and has not been on since august 27th (tho I really think MK should replace her as its not fair to her teammates, regardless if its scum or town)

[iSocialism]

Rafay is an easy target. Normally he follows suit with his scum buddies if he's scum. He's been a little more to himself as in not following anyone too much.

We're to the point where it's doesn't matter about taking out roles or players who are a threat. It's more about just getting a lynch in.

[Canik]

My brother threw his back out yesterday. Figures that's the same day MK FINALLY starts the next day.

I skimmed over everything just now. I think TW made an interesting arguement about Kevin voting Medved. Tho last game when he made essentially the same arguement with Brewers he was wrong that it was a clue left by Brewers and just got lucky. (at least that's what I gathered from Brewers post-game response). xD

Still, it is probably the best arguement so far. Rafay's accusations I don't really follow. Yeah, TW & Brewers may have been part of a mislynch but so was Kevin and we know for sure he was town. Being part of a mislynch doesn't automatically = scum.

 

[The Warrior]

I am less sure that medved is town than I was at the start of the day but the one thing that continues to give me pause concerning him is his roleclaim. Again, the scum may have gotten safe claims, therefore he would at least know that his character claim was safe and he could have chosen to claim as a protector because it’s a less commonly used role and not likely to be counterclaimed, but his claim was still gutsy to make. However, on the other hand, it was also done out of necessity due to him being in line to be lynched. That doesnt mean he’s scum either since a townie should do the same thing but attempting to save oneself would cause a scum to get desperate too. And to add to that his claim isn’t one that can really be verified either.

Rafay is still very high on my list because of the way he attacked brewers (who I believe to be town) and myself (I am town) in standard scum fashion.

[Robert2424]

I'm currently more inclined to a Medved lynch at this point. Rafay is second because of his OMGOUS. 

[brewersalliance]

Again, the scum may have gotten safe claims, therefore he would at least know that his character claim was safe

 

 

I dont see any way James Rhodey isnt used as town.  He is Tony's best friend and war machine is a fairly important character in the movies.

 

Lets look at the deaths.  Happy Hogan, Tony Stark, Pepper Potts, Nick Fury... all of them are main characters from Iron Man.  So I think its pretty reasonable that James Rhodey would be used as well

[Colonel Medved]

I'm currently more inclined to a Medved lynch at this point. Rafay is second because of his OMGOUS. 

 

No surprise there, Robert is more inclined to lynch the person hes already voted for with no explanation than someone who is known for throwing games. Not only that, but you said the exact same thing just 2 days ago. Fluff posting?

 

I'm currently cool medved is my top suspect. Rafay just got on my list though with his omgosh vote on tw. Who I'm leaning town right now.

 

 

If i'm not on your list for the no lynch stance, then why are you voting for me Robert? Other than saying "I'm just going to do this"

 

 

Like i've said before, there is literally nothing i can say that can prove that i am telling the truth. I've given all the information i can give, if you have questions ask away, i'll try to answer them to the best of my ability. No one has investigated me i'm assuming since no one has come to my defense.

 

We are already down 4 town with nothing to show for it, no one has gotten anything so far?? Withholding information is only hurting town, and the longer we wait the more in the hole we will be. Another mis-lynch could just give the game to scum, assuming there is 3-4 scum.

 

I'm leaning towards Robert being scum, what other explanation would there be for his reckless voting when we are already down this far in townies? Either he is continuing the random voting train (which has only killed townies so far), or he is scum picking off a easy target because i'm already in the spotlight. 

 

FoS Robert

[Wolfpacks]

I'm getting a feeling that col Medved is town, I'm happy to believe he is what he claims, I think msshawdi should be replaced,

I want to hear more on the Raf/TW debate before I decide which way I'm going to go

[Robert2424]

If you count voting for the person you believe is scum Col Medved, sure we can call the reckless. Along with everybody else votes. Apparently we supposed to lull around and vote for people we don't expect to scum. You seem to only come around when somebody votes for you. go ahead, FOS me all you like, cause it dose nothing. 

 

If I am to believe your Role claim, I'm pretty sure there is no doc. just saying. But mafia went and targeted seabee at random. I don't see any other reason he pick over me, TW, Brewers, or active participants. If you would be telling the truth mafia know your a power role, and would of offed the closest thing to a doc. Now there could well be another doc out there, but I find it unlikely with your role. Plus trying to think of somebody in the IRON MAN movie who is a main character that can be considered a doc....Not really thinking of any. Your name in your claim is the only thing that credits you at this point from somebody else jumping on voting for you again. however my vote on you makes you still a valid option today. 

[Colonel Medved]

If you count voting for the person you believe is scum Col Medved, sure we can call the reckless. Along with everybody else votes. Apparently we supposed to lull around and vote for people we don't expect to scum. You seem to only come around when somebody votes for you. go ahead, FOS me all you like, cause it dose nothing. 

 

If I am to believe your Role claim, I'm pretty sure there is no doc. just saying. But mafia went and targeted seabee at random. I don't see any other reason he pick over me, TW, Brewers, or active participants. If you would be telling the truth mafia know your a power role, and would of offed the closest thing to a doc. Now there could well be another doc out there, but I find it unlikely with your role. Plus trying to think of somebody in the IRON MAN movie who is a main character that can be considered a doc....Not really thinking of any. Your name in your claim is the only thing that credits you at this point from somebody else jumping on voting for you again. however my vote on you makes you still a valid option today. 

 

I don't just pop in when i'm voted for, I'm here checking on the game a couple times during the day (more on the weekends). I only post when i feel necessary, and being that i have been voted for i wouldn't want to sit quietly waiting for more votes to stack up.

 

As for you not believing my RC, i suppose that is your own choice. I know that i am town, no one can really back my story which is both bad for me and town. At this point this game is dead in the water, i honestly will be surprised if town wins at this point. If there is any other power roles, they either haven't gotten anything or they are all dead. Either way, we are down 4 towns with nothing to show for it. We are getting close to being outnumbered.

 

I know that doc doesn't sound like it fits James Rhodes, that's because it doesn't. Like i said in my RC, i am a Protector. After further clarification, i was told that i'm actually a doctor. The original role sounded more fitting to the name, but was intended to have the same power as a doctor. I posted the clarification as soon as i got it into the game chat, which can be seen here

 

I got some more clarification on my role. I am more like a doctor, preventing my targeted player from a single kill during the night

 

 

I don't want to keep repeating the same thing, so i will not post again about this. 

[Canik]

 

Again, the scum may have gotten safe claims, therefore he would at least know that his character claim was safe

 

 

I dont see any way James Rhodey isnt used as town.  He is Tony's best friend and war machine is a fairly important character in the movies.

 

Lets look at the deaths.  Happy Hogan, Tony Stark, Pepper Potts, Nick Fury... all of them are main characters from Iron Man.  So I think its pretty reasonable that James Rhodey would be used as well

 

James Rhodey = Warmachine right? He does face off with Iron Man for a short time in later movies I think. Or maybe that was just the comics. He's with the Gov and Stark does his own thing you know so they do have moments of conflict. 

In the first movie I think a bit of that may be shown but he's still quite loyal overall. It is hard to imagine him not being town but who else would be a better candidate for a safeclaim?

[Lord MK]

Vote Count

The Warrior (1): Rafay
Rafay (1): brewersalliance
Colonel Medved (1): Robert2424
Canik (0):
Wolfpacks (0):
Robert2424 (0):
MsShawdi (0):
Brewersalliance (0):
iSocialism (0):

No Lynch (0):

Not Voting: Colonel Medved, Canik, Wolfpacks, MsShawdi,
The Warrior, iSocialism


with 9 alive, it takes 5 to lynch or 3 at deadline.

Deadline is on Sunday, September 16st, 2018 at 12 am CN time.

[Robert2424]

His name would technically be town. I don't think they faught till IRON man 2. 

[The Warrior]

A name claim means nothing if the scum are given safe claims. There were several times that main characters in the Harry Potter series were safe claim names for the scum team.

@MK - Has there been any attempt to contact or replace MsShawdi?

[Lord MK]

@MK - Has there been any attempt to contact or replace MsShawdi?

Has been prodded.
No response yet.

I am already looking for a replacement.

[Wolfpacks]

@MK - Has there been any attempt to contact or replace MsShawdi?

Has been prodded.
No response yet.

I am already looking for a replacement.

Has anyone tried her on Discord

[brewersalliance]

 

 

@MK - Has there been any attempt to contact or replace MsShawdi?

Has been prodded.
No response yet.

I am already looking for a replacement.

Has anyone tried her on Discord

 

I have, she said she was super busy with RL and has had a bunch of stuff going on.  I dont think we are going to see her at all any more. 

[brewersalliance]

This has been really dead... no one is really sharing anything (outside of like four of us)

 

if town wants any chance at winning we need to get active, otherwise might as well just hand the game to the scum

[Wolfpacks]

Agreed this isn't going anywhere

[iSocialism]

Because it's all speculation posting, only one RC that hasn't provide a lot of info.