622 replies to this topic

[Sister Midnight]

Okee dokee, right now I believe either Rafay or Wolfpacks is scum.

Have either of them ever voted to shoot scum? I cannot find the vote counts.

Both Rafay and you stayed out. WP did vote for both TW and SBG. Did you vote for TW though? I know you voted for Robert and he turned out town.

So to be fair I am dropping WP from my suspect's list for now. Brewers was never on it.
 
So currently there's both of you on the radar.

I voted for TW and for SBG.

[Lachiton]

Yeah my bad. Medved didn't count your vote so I missed that.

[brewersalliance]

And btw, this is further proof that SBG IS ALMOST ALWAYS SCUM WHEN I PLAY.

I will no longer doubt you on that lol  

 

 

so as long as we dont miss EVERY single shot for the rest of the game we will win!  hopefully robert can just run the table here and finish this today

 

Okee dokee, right now I believe either Rafay or Wolfpacks is scum. Have either of them ever voted to shoot scum? I cannot find the vote counts.

 

 

WP was the second vote on SBG

 

SeaBeeGipson (3): brewersalliance, Wolfpacks, Lachiton

 

 

 

As for Rafay I am not sure if has has voted for scum or not

[Sister Midnight]

If Wolfy voted for both TW and SBG, then I believe Rafay most likely is scum.

Incidentally, TW was gunning for me.

[brewersalliance]

 

 

Okee dokee, right now I believe either Rafay or Wolfpacks is scum.

Have either of them ever voted to shoot scum? I cannot find the vote counts.
 

Both Rafay and you stayed out. WP did vote for both TW and SBG. Did you vote for TW though? I know you voted for Robert and he turned out town.

So to be fair I am dropping WP from my suspect's list for now. Brewers was never on it.
 
So currently there's both of you on the radar.

I voted for TW and for SBG.

 

 

you did? I thought u voted rafay not TW.  I thought only Wolfpacks voted TW

[Sister Midnight]

 

 

Okee dokee, right now I believe either Rafay or Wolfpacks is scum.

Have either of them ever voted to shoot scum? I cannot find the vote counts.
 

Both Rafay and you stayed out. WP did vote for both TW and SBG. Did you vote for TW though? I know you voted for Robert and he turned out town.

So to be fair I am dropping WP from my suspect's list for now. Brewers was never on it.
 
So currently there's both of you on the radar.

I voted for TW and for SBG.
 

 
you did? I thought u voted rafay not TW.  I thought only Wolfpacks voted TW

You may be right. Nom, I prolly did vote Rafay. But TW WAS gunning for me.

[Lachiton]

I will no longer doubt you on that lol       so as long as we dont miss EVERY single shot for the rest of the game we will win!  hopefully robert can just run the table here and finish this today

 

We have 1 scum left likely so cant lose as long as I am not shot 

 

Also SBG as scum in every game SM plays is not true. Both of them were town in the Last Jedi mafia.

[Sister Midnight]

Follow up pos correcting autocorrect, not nom, nm.

I will no longer doubt you on that lol       so as long as we dont miss EVERY single shot for the rest of the game we will win!  hopefully robert can just run the table here and finish this today

 
We have 1 scum left likely so cant lose as long as I am not shot 
 
Also SBG as scum in every game SM plays is not true. Both of them were town in the Last Jedi mafia.

I said almost every game I play.

[Lachiton]

Ok fair enough!

[Rafay]

For the love of God Robert, you're on a roll so don't shoot me and break it and cost us a game!!!

 

Its SM or WP.

 

This clears brewsers I think.

[Sister Midnight]

For the love of God Robert, you're on a roll so don't shoot me and break it and cost us a game!!!
 
Its SM or WP.
 
This clears brewsers I think.

NOW you suddenly have opinions? Really?

[brewersalliance]

I still think Rafays best defense was the whole MK thing from d1, however, it is possible that Mk was bussing from rafay.  His rafay vote included three people:  Him, Rafay and TW.  He also went on to vote SBG for being drunk right after that.  Is it possible that MK called out the entire scum team d1?  

 

Is Rafay our last scum?  Maybe.  But with all of the momentum making an SBG shoot look like a for sure thing, scum could also have joined the wagon to bus from SBG after it became obvious he was the target.

 

So that gives us two groups.

 

Group A: Wolfpacks, Lachiton, SM 

 

Group B:  Rafay

 

So which do we think is more likely?  Scum tried to bus or scum stayed of SBG all together?

 

The thing that sticks out the most to me is SM joined the wagon very late, basically after it was already a foregone conclusion that SBG was getting shot.  She took zero risk in pushing the wagon along, but joined it at the end giving her the ability to say "hey i voted to shoot the scum player"  add that to her saying SBG was scum because he is scum in every game she is in with him (while in reality the last game i played with SM and SBG, he was actually town)  the entire game -yes I know she said it was a joke but SM is always very playful, so perhaps she was using that to her advantage.

 

so for now

 

vote SM

[Rafay]

SBG shoot look like a for sure thing, scum could also have joined the wagon to bus from SBG after it became obvious he was the target.

 

this this. 

 

Why can't I come up with such good defense..... 

SBG shoot look like a for sure thing, scum could also have joined the wagon to bus from SBG after it became obvious he was the target.

 

this this. 

 

Why can't I come up with such good defense..... 

[Wolfpacks]

Tbh it could still be anyone of you.

Brewers could have chucked his scum pal under the bus to push away suspicion of him, made himself look like town.

Lachiton, I've been pretty suspicious of him from day 2 but he knew the message that his vote is his weapon, I'm not sure scum would know this.

Sister Midnight has been active but hasn't really given much but following wagons, defends herself well but maybe too much

Rafay is playing it like he always does quietly, just doing enough, calling out myself and SM could be inspired or just clutching as straws, im backing the latter.

Robert is the shooter, Innocent.

Im afraid I can get the double bluff out of my system and my gut feeling isn't doing so bad lately

Vote Brewers

[brewersalliance]

That would be virtual suicide of me to do that.  If I was partners with SBG, the only way I would win then is if town missed every single shot for the rest of the game.  With two scum alive, the chances for a scum win would be much much greater.  It would be a terrible play imo, and with lachtion basically confirmed town, it would pretty much guarantee a loss for me if I was scum.  

 

And lets be real, if I was the very last scum, would I honestly be suggesting we go after SM?  If I am scum that means SM is town, and if she was shot, I would be suspect #1 and probably shot next for doing so.  

[Sister Midnight]

And yet, I am town, and I have had more than one gut feeling that Brewsky is scum, however, I’ve ignored that gut feeling consistently, relying on reason because Brewers is acting more town than scum and gunning for SBG was very townie-like. I’m using reason in making the decision to finger Rafay. His refusal to participate until just recently and his voting history make him look bad to me. If Robert shoots me he will be committing suicide and giving me the gun.

[Robert2424]

Hmm

[Wolfpacks]

That would be virtual suicide of me to do that. If I was partners with SBG, the only way I would win then is if town missed every single shot for the rest of the game. With two scum alive, the chances for a scum win would be much much greater. It would be a terrible play imo, and with lachtion basically confirmed town, it would pretty much guarantee a loss for me if I was scum.

And lets be real, if I was the very last scum, would I honestly be suggesting we go after SM? If I am scum that means SM is town, and if she was shot, I would be suspect #1 and probably shot next for doing so.

I had also factored that in my mind,but im still not convinced that Random Rafay is scum, which kinda leaves 3 people, Brewers and SM and Lach.
Lach still seems town to me
Brewers could be town
SM could be town

But if you shoot either one it's only suicide for Robert, for instance shoot SM and she's town then she shoots brewers and he's scum town wins, Shoot brewers and he's town he shoots SM and she's scum town wins, only downside of this is Lach really Town, I think so because of the wording of his role message, mine was the same.

[Lachiton]

If brewers is scum then it would be a very stupid play to sacrifice his only remaining partner, knowing fully well that as long as the gun bearer doesn't shoot me or anyone at all then scum has no chance of wininng.

 

With 5 town and 1 scum, town's not losing this. Even if next 3 shots get 3 gun bearers killed and the ratio is 2:1, assuming I am alive and not the gun-bearer, that will mean we will have 2 confirmed townies and the gun-bearer will know whom to shoot. So it is extremely unlikely that brewers will leave it to the last gun bearer to doubt my innocence so that he can manipulate him/her to shoot me and win it for scum. Remember as long as gun-bearer is active and I am not shot, 1 scum cant win this. So keeping this in mind, I do think brewers is town.

 

Coming on to WP, he has been suspecting me and brewers for a while now. He has eased up on me but still suspect brewers, at least that is consistent of him. He was the lone vote on TW and was the 2nd one on SBG so that earn him townie points in my eyes.

 

So that leaves Rafay and SM. Rafay doesn't vote at all so that's a problem even though he has been throwing accusations at both WP and SM. SM looks to be playing safe with never fully committing to her suspicions unless someone else has already went ahead and formed the charge, in which case she would likely join in. Not necessarily scum tell but scum also tends to hesitate so as to not draw unnecesary attention.

 

At this point it can be either Rafay and SM, with SM my likely choice at this point. And even she is town, she is active and participates so we can try to scum hunt again the next day.
Robert may die if he shoots SM and she turns out town but with 2 successful shots already under his belt, town is in excellent shape and won't lose unless makes some drastic mistakes.

 

 

Okay SHOOT SISTER MIDNIGHT Bam. Let's move on to Day 7 now.

This is interesting though. It may be Seabee just being Seabee but he did the same with TW which got brewers on his back and this may be a last ditch attempt to save SM, as who would trust a known scum.

So placing my vote for now

Vote: SM

[brewersalliance]

the only way we lose is if our gunbearer forgets to shoot by the deadline.  if that happens, obviously our last scum would make lachiton the gun bearer and hope he gets it wrong

 

so we should operate like the deadline is 12 hours sooner than it is in order to avoid that situation

well i guess if lachiton is scum we will probably loose too haha but i would be very very very shocked if he is