622 replies to this topic

[Lachiton]

I am town so let's not overcomplicate this. Stop all your conspiracy theories lol

 

[Sister Midnight]

If brewers is scum then it would be a very stupid play to sacrifice his only remaining partner, knowing fully well that as long as the gun bearer doesn't shoot me or anyone at all then scum has no chance of wininng.
 
With 5 town and 1 scum, town's not losing this. Even if next 3 shots get 3 gun bearers killed and the ratio is 2:1, assuming I am alive and not the gun-bearer, that will mean we will have 2 confirmed townies and the gun-bearer will know whom to shoot. So it is extremely unlikely that brewers will leave it to the last gun bearer to doubt my innocence so that he can manipulate him/her to shoot me and win it for scum. Remember as long as gun-bearer is active and I am not shot, 1 scum cant win this. So keeping this in mind, I do think brewers is town.
 
Coming on to WP, he has been suspecting me and brewers for a while now. He has eased up on me but still suspect brewers, at least that is consistent of him. He was the lone vote on TW and was the 2nd one on SBG so that earn him townie points in my eyes.
 
So that leaves Rafay and SM. Rafay doesn't vote at all so that's a problem even though he has been throwing accusations at both WP and SM. SM looks to be playing safe with never fully committing to her suspicions unless someone else has already went ahead and formed the charge, in which case she would likely join in. Not necessarily scum tell but scum also tends to hesitate so as to not draw unnecesary attention.
 
At this point it can be either Rafay and SM, with SM my likely choice at this point. And even she is town, she is active and participates so we can try to scum hunt again the next day.
Robert may die if he shoots SM and she turns out town but with 2 successful shots already under his belt, town is in excellent shape and won't lose unless makes some drastic mistakes.
 
 

Okay SHOOT SISTER MIDNIGHT Bam. Let's move on to Day 7 now.

This is interesting though. It may be Seabee just being Seabee but he did the same with TW which got brewers on his back and this may be a last ditch attempt to save SM, as who would trust a known scum.So placing my vote for now

Vote: SM

Scum says to shoot me so you all follow scum’s advice? AYFKM?

TW throws me under the bus. SBG throws me under the bus. Hey! It must be a great idea to shoot me if 2 scum push for it! /sarcasm. Look at who else has been gunning for meal game: Brewsky

VOTE BREWERS



Addendum: * been gunning for me all game: Brewsky

[brewersalliance]

 

If brewers is scum then it would be a very stupid play to sacrifice his only remaining partner, knowing fully well that as long as the gun bearer doesn't shoot me or anyone at all then scum has no chance of wininng.
 
With 5 town and 1 scum, town's not losing this. Even if next 3 shots get 3 gun bearers killed and the ratio is 2:1, assuming I am alive and not the gun-bearer, that will mean we will have 2 confirmed townies and the gun-bearer will know whom to shoot. So it is extremely unlikely that brewers will leave it to the last gun bearer to doubt my innocence so that he can manipulate him/her to shoot me and win it for scum. Remember as long as gun-bearer is active and I am not shot, 1 scum cant win this. So keeping this in mind, I do think brewers is town.
 
Coming on to WP, he has been suspecting me and brewers for a while now. He has eased up on me but still suspect brewers, at least that is consistent of him. He was the lone vote on TW and was the 2nd one on SBG so that earn him townie points in my eyes.
 
So that leaves Rafay and SM. Rafay doesn't vote at all so that's a problem even though he has been throwing accusations at both WP and SM. SM looks to be playing safe with never fully committing to her suspicions unless someone else has already went ahead and formed the charge, in which case she would likely join in. Not necessarily scum tell but scum also tends to hesitate so as to not draw unnecesary attention.
 
At this point it can be either Rafay and SM, with SM my likely choice at this point. And even she is town, she is active and participates so we can try to scum hunt again the next day.
Robert may die if he shoots SM and she turns out town but with 2 successful shots already under his belt, town is in excellent shape and won't lose unless makes some drastic mistakes.
 
 

Okay SHOOT SISTER MIDNIGHT Bam. Let's move on to Day 7 now.

This is interesting though. It may be Seabee just being Seabee but he did the same with TW which got brewers on his back and this may be a last ditch attempt to save SM, as who would trust a known scum.So placing my vote for now

Vote: SM

Scum says to shoot me so you all follow scum’s advice? AYFKM?

TW throws me under the bus. SBG throws me under the bus. Hey! It must be a great idea to shoot me if 2 scum push for it! /sarcasm. Look at who else has been gunning for meal game: Brewsky

VOTE BREWERS



Addendum: * been gunning for me all game: Brewsky

 

cause you have acted scummy.  like lachiton said, your vote pattern is kind of scummy, and when and where you joined SBG's wagon just feels like a scum move.

 

also, when did SBG gun for you?  and I dont think TW pushed for you any where near as hard as you are claiming.  you keep filling your reasons to vote for me with false information/things that just never happened in this game.  the last time you voted for me you listed a bunch of crap that never happened as your reasons and here you go again listing stuff that never happened/just isnt true.  i cant tell if you are straight up lying or just not going back and reading what actually happened this game

[Rafay]

What are your thoughts Robert??

 

And can we please get a suspicion count.

[brewersalliance]

and you keep flip flopping on me, you go from brewers is townish to nope he voted for me so he must be scum, to nope he is townish to nope he voted for me again so he must be scum...

What are your thoughts Robert??

 

And can we please get a suspicion count.

 

 

SM: Brewers, lachtion

Brewers:  Wolfpacks, SM

[Lachiton]

So Rafay can be the tie breaker   

@Rafay, here's your opportunity, you can make a difference here. You have not voted the entire game but by voting you can help Robert find the last scum.

 

 

Robert is doing the right thing imo by just reading through the arguments and counter arguments of other players and not jumping in with his thought atm. He will take the final decision so it's the job of rest of the town to find him the best possible and logical choice(s)

[Sister Midnight]

 

If brewers is scum then it would be a very stupid play to sacrifice his only remaining partner, knowing fully well that as long as the gun bearer doesn't shoot me or anyone at all then scum has no chance of wininng.
 
With 5 town and 1 scum, town's not losing this. Even if next 3 shots get 3 gun bearers killed and the ratio is 2:1, assuming I am alive and not the gun-bearer, that will mean we will have 2 confirmed townies and the gun-bearer will know whom to shoot. So it is extremely unlikely that brewers will leave it to the last gun bearer to doubt my innocence so that he can manipulate him/her to shoot me and win it for scum. Remember as long as gun-bearer is active and I am not shot, 1 scum cant win this. So keeping this in mind, I do think brewers is town.
 
Coming on to WP, he has been suspecting me and brewers for a while now. He has eased up on me but still suspect brewers, at least that is consistent of him. He was the lone vote on TW and was the 2nd one on SBG so that earn him townie points in my eyes.
 
So that leaves Rafay and SM. Rafay doesn't vote at all so that's a problem even though he has been throwing accusations at both WP and SM. SM looks to be playing safe with never fully committing to her suspicions unless someone else has already went ahead and formed the charge, in which case she would likely join in. Not necessarily scum tell but scum also tends to hesitate so as to not draw unnecesary attention.
 
At this point it can be either Rafay and SM, with SM my likely choice at this point. And even she is town, she is active and participates so we can try to scum hunt again the next day.
Robert may die if he shoots SM and she turns out town but with 2 successful shots already under his belt, town is in excellent shape and won't lose unless makes some drastic mistakes.
 
 

Okay SHOOT SISTER MIDNIGHT Bam. Let's move on to Day 7 now.

This is interesting though. It may be Seabee just being Seabee but he did the same with TW which got brewers on his back and this may be a last ditch attempt to save SM, as who would trust a known scum.So placing my vote for now

Vote: SM

Scum says to shoot me so you all follow scum’s advice? AYFKM?

TW throws me under the bus. SBG throws me under the bus. Hey! It must be a great idea to shoot me if 2 scum push for it! /sarcasm. Look at who else has been gunning for meal game: Brewsky

VOTE BREWERS



Addendum: * been gunning for me all game: Brewsky
 

cause you have acted scummy.  like lachiton said, your vote pattern is kind of scummy, and when and where you joined SBG's wagon just feels like a scum move.
 
also, when did SBG gun for you?  and I dont think TW pushed for you any where near as hard as you are claiming.  you keep filling your reasons to vote for me with false information/things that just never happened in this game.  the last time you voted for me you listed a bunch of crap that never happened as your reasons and here you go again listing stuff that never happened/just isnt true.  i cant tell if you are straight up lying or just not going back and reading what actually happened this game

Okay

SHOOT SISTER MIDNIGHT

Bam. Let's move on to Day 7 now.

That is when he pushed me under the bus. And you agreed TW was gunning for me, which you claimed made you think I’m town. Now you say he wasn’t gunning very much. Make up your mind.

[brewersalliance]

 

Okay

SHOOT SISTER MIDNIGHT

Bam. Let's move on to Day 7 now.

 

 

so your reasoning is based off a joke vote/shot by SBG who was scum and clearly just trolling and trying to give town a scare thinking he made a shot the second the day started with no discussion at all? lol come on SM, that is ludicrous 

his post was one of two things either

 

A) a joke messing with town since he was dead

 

or 

 

B ) an attempt to bus from you to protect you if you are his scum partner

[Sister Midnight]

Also, you have repeatedly twisted my joke statement that SBG is ALMOST always scum when I play( which is absolutely true, btw), by dropping the word almost. It is ALMOST as if you ar3 trying to be confusing.

 

Okay

SHOOT SISTER MIDNIGHT

Bam. Let's move on to Day 7 now.

 

 
so your reasoning is based off a joke vote/shot by SBG who was scum and clearly just trolling and trying to give town a scare thinking he made a shot the second the day started with no discussion at all? lol come on SM, that is ludicrous 

his post was one of two things either
 
A) a joke messing with town since he was dead
 
or 
 
B ) an attempt to bus from you to protect you if you are his scum partner

Of course that is how you choose to interpret things when you try to get a wagon on me.

[Rafay]

Vote: SM

[brewersalliance]

well then please tell me, what else would his "shoot sister midnight" be

 

he was already dead, and everyone was moments away from seeing he was scum.  so how on earth would that post be pushing you?  that makes zero sense whatsoever

 

and furthermore, if i was scum, the last thing I would be doing right now is pushing you.  If I got you shot, you would just turn and shoot me lol so why would I try to get you shot which would get me shot the next day and lose the game.  It makes zero sense

[Sister Midnight]

I’m too lazy to read back. My bad. *blush*

[brewersalliance]

I’m too lazy to read back. My bad. *blush*

 

well maybe u should read back before throwing around accusations lol 

[Wolfpacks]

and you keep flip flopping on me, you go from brewers is townish to nope he voted for me so he must be scum, to nope he is townish to nope he voted for me again so he must be scum...

What are your thoughts Robert??

And can we please get a suspicion count.

SM: Brewers, lachtion
Brewers: Wolfpacks, SM

Oops my bad I meant to remove my vote from Brewers

Unvote

[Robert2424]

ok. my thoughts. 

 

Wolfpacks, not as active, voted for TW, witch gives him townie points. 

Brewers started wagon on Seabee, seabee switched anti, townie points. 

SM, odd one. She has been on wagons, TW did go for her, and so did seabee. 

Rafay, hangs back and dosn't vote. honestly still suspect him. 

Lach is probally town. unless he fools us. 

 

honestly, I don't see why we aren't considering Rafay here. 

[Rafay]

honestly, I don't see why we aren't considering Rafay here. 

 

Big mistake even if ya thinkin bout it.

 

You've been amazing so far. Don't waste it with one wrong shot. 

[Sister Midnight]

I was seriously looking at Rafay, but then Brewers started saying stuff that struck me as scummy, and as I said my gut has been to go after him, but now I’m second guessing myself. Using pure reason, Rafay looks bad. Using more gut, and observing some of his behaviors Brewers looks bad. I’m not ready to change my vote. I need to read back, and now is not a good time.
Addendum: Rafay posted whil I was writing.

honestly, I don't see why we aren't considering Rafay here. 

 
Big mistake even if ya thinkin bout it.
 
You've been amazing so far. Don't waste it with one wrong shot. 

Umm. That does not inspire me to stop fingering you suspiciously.

[brewersalliance]

I was seriously looking at Rafay, but then Brewers started saying stuff that struck me as scummy, and as I said my gut has been to go after him, but now I’m second guessing myself. Using pure reason, Rafay looks bad. Using more gut, and observing some of his behaviors Brewers looks bad. I’m not ready to change my vote. I need to read back, and now is not a good time.
Addendum: Rafay posted whil I was writing.
 

 

honestly, I don't see why we aren't considering Rafay here. 

 
Big mistake even if ya thinkin bout it.
 
You've been amazing so far. Don't waste it with one wrong shot. 

Umm. That does not inspire me to stop fingering you suspiciously.

 

Im fingering you suspiciously right now too

 

 

Did that sound dirty?

[Wolfpacks]

ok. my thoughts.

Wolfpacks, not as active, voted for TW, witch gives him townie points.
Brewers started wagon on Seabee, seabee switched anti, townie points.
SM, odd one. She has been on wagons, TW did go for her, and so did seabee.
Rafay, hangs back and dosn't vote. honestly still suspect him.
Lach is probally town. unless he fools us.

honestly, I don't see why we aren't considering Rafay here.

That's a good point on TW he did give SM some grief as did Seabee, I'm going to go out on a limb with this one, I think SM is town, theres too many variables in this,sod this shoot Rafay, hes not giving anything to this game
Btw the i have got more active as the games gone on

[Colonel Medved]

Suspicion Count

 

 

"I'm fingering you suspiciously right now too"

- brewersalliance

 

brewersalliance (1): Sister Midnight

Robert2424 (0): 

Lachiton (0):

Wolfpacks (0):

Rafay (0): 

Sister Midnight (3): brewersalliance, Lachiton, Rafay

 

 

Not Voting: Robert2424, Wolfpacks

 

Deadline is September 5th, 9:00AM CN for Robert2424 to Shoot