684 replies to this topic

[Nadarr]

Okay so no one else vote WP for now, as he is well in line for the lynch and we dont want to end the day 6 days early...  but WP is def the right call for tonight.  and Rhizo is right, SBG is only a vanilla cop.  That would be very unfortunate if that was our only cop in the game, as all it would tell us is if someone has a PR or is a VT-basically a weak role cop   So there is a chance we have a real cop out there somewhere.  Could it be WP?  Maybe.  But he could also be lying, which is fairly likely as well.  The only way he is telling the truth is if their is a ninja.  I still think its much more likely that WP is some form of scum (either SK or mafia).  Only reason I say he might be SK over scum is the group PM debacle.  However, my money would be on him flipping mafia.  I dont think WP would have killed n1 as a SK, as he is a really experienced player, and it makes sense that the target for the mafia kill would have been someone different than the PM to avoid having their kill blocked.   So I guess I disagree that he was killed by an SK, and I think the knife thing has nothing to do with the role and is just pointless flavor.  With my recent game and the Pokemon game being won basically off the flavor, I would not be shocked if TW threw us a curve ball and tried to trick us with the flavor and made it meaningless.  

 

One quick thought, though I am not throwing all my weight behind it but it is worth looking at. What if Kvrest is trying to mislead us? A role claim basically means nothing in this game without proof. He could be starting suspicion on someone by claiming to be town and having a role that allows him to see visitors at night.  I am new, so basically I am proposing this to more experienced players to see their opinions. Is it possible Kvrest is scum trying to get us to mislynch WP?

[brewersalliance]

Okay so no one else vote WP for now, as he is well in line for the lynch and we dont want to end the day 6 days early...  but WP is def the right call for tonight.  and Rhizo is right, SBG is only a vanilla cop.  That would be very unfortunate if that was our only cop in the game, as all it would tell us is if someone has a PR or is a VT-basically a weak role cop   So there is a chance we have a real cop out there somewhere.  Could it be WP?  Maybe.  But he could also be lying, which is fairly likely as well.  The only way he is telling the truth is if their is a ninja.  I still think its much more likely that WP is some form of scum (either SK or mafia).  Only reason I say he might be SK over scum is the group PM debacle.  However, my money would be on him flipping mafia.  I dont think WP would have killed n1 as a SK, as he is a really experienced player, and it makes sense that the target for the mafia kill would have been someone different than the PM to avoid having their kill blocked.   So I guess I disagree that he was killed by an SK, and I think the knife thing has nothing to do with the role and is just pointless flavor.  With my recent game and the Pokemon game being won basically off the flavor, I would not be shocked if TW threw us a curve ball and tried to trick us with the flavor and made it meaningless.  

 
One quick thought, though I am not throwing all my weight behind it but it is worth looking at. What if Kvrest is trying to mislead us? A role claim basically means nothing in this game without proof. He could be starting suspicion on someone by claiming to be town and having a role that allows him to see visitors at night.  I am new, so basically I am proposing this to more experienced players to see their opinions. Is it possible Kvrest is scum trying to get us to mislynch WP?

That's highly unlikely to happen d2, as we would know for sure kvrest is scum then and we would lynch or kill him tomorrow. Only way this would even be possible is Kvrest is a Jester or lyncher, but that shouldn't stop us from this Lynch.

It WP turns up town, Kvrest would be on the chopping block tomorrow or killed tonight by a vig (if we have one). So I just don't see this as an actual possibility.

[Nadarr]

Okay. I just wanted to think of all possibilities.

[Robert2424]

Ok. I miss understood.

Watcher is damning. Only way we didn't see another was because of a ninja. But Im willing to place hammer on wolfpacks once people are ready to end the day.

[Nadarr]

Ok. I miss understood.

Watcher is damning. Only way we didn't see another was because of a ninja. But Im willing to place hammer on wolfpacks once people are ready to end the day.

 

I very much am too. It is the debater in me wanting to play devil's advocate and look for all available arguments.

[Rafay]

Vote: Wolfpacks

 

On the possibility that you are wrong Kverst then you should know who we'd be voting for next. Okay?

[Robert2424]

He is already at l -1

[brewersalliance]

yeah, no one vote for him any more please.  we do not want to end the day so quick.  

FoS on anyone if they cast the hammer... lets slow down.  we still have like 6 days left to discuss stuff.  

for all we know, we have a real cop out there or maybe a role cop or something that found another scum! so lets just slow our roll a bit 

[Sister Midnight]

I think it is entirely possiblele that there is more than one cop, or more than one jailor for that matter. But,

sbg died
alright,
 
I do have something interesting to share. I will sacrifice myself for the good of the town. 
 
I saw one Mr. Wolfpacks stalking SBG last night. 

Kverst did not claim cop. Are you a cop or a watcher of some sort? Do you have a flavor, or are you vanilla?

WP, you claim are a 3 shot cop. Why did you investigate SBG?

I would also request delaying execution until closer to deadline just so we can hear from more town.

[iSocialism]

Wouldn't a FoS on whoever lay down the hammer also be a quasi-FoS on those who haven't voted? I mean no one on WP wagon have the ability to be the hammer as of right now. But those off the wagon do. It might just be applying that it's the action of being the hammer that makes someone fos you. If it's the action, then the promotion of the action could also be FoS-able. Also the caution to other scums to be careful of not making suspicious action be also a FoS. Either way

FoS brewer

[brewersalliance]

Lol no, not what I meant. I just meant if someone ends the day early with 6 days to go, that would be suspicious to me. So I'm not saying everyone who hasn't voted is an FoS. Maybe you misunderstood what I meant. I don't think you're trying to intentionally put words in my mouth to make me look bad, as I am 99% sure you are town.

I mean if someone hammered him in right now, wouldn't you be suspicious of that person too for ending the day early?

[The Warrior]

Vote Count

 

Brewersalliance (0):

Colonel Medved (0):

iSocialism (0):

KevinH (0):

Kverst (0):

Lachiton (0):

Lord MK (1): KevinH

Nadarr (0):

Rafay (0):

Rhizoctonia (0):

Robert2424 (0):

Sister Midnight (0):

Wolfpacks (6): Brewersalliance, Kverst, iSocialism, Lachiton, Colonel Medved, Rafay

 

No Lynch (0):

 

Not Voting: Lord MK, Nadarr, Robert2424, Rhizoctonia, Sister Midnight, Wolfpacks

 

With 13 players alive it take 7 to lynch or 4 at deadline.

Deadline will be at 9:30am CN Server time on Thursday, December 27th.

[Colonel Medved]

Well the good news is if WP does end up being scum, we will have our first confirmed town. All things considered, I would say we are off to a great start

[iSocialism]

Not really, most of the talk should be about him. Unless we want to try an different approach, and have the lynch set up and try to figure out the next lynch subject today. He's destined to be lynched, no scum will try to save him. Unless it was me, I'm pretty I have the power to try saving scum and live for a while. Side note I haven't seen KK in a while. We won't get that much of discussion as people speaking up. There's no risk of being lynched. I think another round of night action would be more
Beneficial for more discussion along as we do allow a little bit of time for everyone to voice their minds, because not everyone will be here tomorrow.

I have always said a hammer vote is just that, a hammer vote. Personally it makes me feel like I have a little more power to do so, so much so

Unvote

Let get a bumper, though next one to vote will follow up with me saying about being the hammer and voting.

[brewersalliance]

Who is KK?

[Colonel Medved]

Who is KK?

I think he meant to say MK

[The Warrior]

Vote Count

 

Brewersalliance (0):

Colonel Medved (0):

iSocialism (0):

KevinH (0):

Kverst (0):

Lachiton (0):

Lord MK (1): KevinH

Nadarr (0):

Rafay (0):

Rhizoctonia (0):

Robert2424 (0):

Sister Midnight (0):

Wolfpacks (5): Brewersalliance, Kverst, Lachiton, Colonel Medved, Rafay

 

No Lynch (0):

 

Not Voting: iSocialism, Lord MK, Nadarr, Robert2424, Rhizoctonia, Sister Midnight, Wolfpacks

 

With 13 players alive it take 7 to lynch or 4 at deadline.

Deadline will be at 9:30am CN Server time on Thursday, December 27th.

[iSocialism]

Nope, kitkat

[brewersalliance]

Kitkat isnt in this game lol he hasnt been in a while

 

or is that what you meant, like you havent seen him play in a while lol

[Wolfpacks]

I think it is entirely possiblele that there is more than one cop, or more than one jailor for that matter. But,

sbg died
alright,

I do have something interesting to share. I will sacrifice myself for the good of the town.

I saw one Mr. Wolfpacks stalking SBG last night.

Kverst did not claim cop. Are you a cop or a watcher of some sort? Do you have a flavor, or are you vanilla?

WP, you claim are a 3 shot cop. Why did you investigate SBG?

I would also request delaying execution until closer to deadline just so we can hear from more town.

It was pretty much on your recommendation, your right SBG has been scum pretty much a lot, so I thought I'd use my first shot on him, im not sure what kverst has to gain by fingering me but hes barking up the wrong tree, im guessing he is a watcher but he could be the other cop, why would he be watching SBG, please explain that.