540 replies to this topic

[The Warrior]

so why hold the game up if you are just waiting on a town role?

 

only thing makes sense is if the scum as a whole have not been very active and did not submit a team kill.

 

So lets look who could be that team.

 

TW:  only posted 1 time on day 1 and should have been mod killed but was not (maybe cause mod killing a scum D1 would not go over well)

 

Kaziocore:  only posted 2 times on day 2, same reasons as TW

 

Rafay:  was also at the bottom of the d1 post count. and last posted March 2nd before the deadline.  

 

Both Rafay and TW kept their votes on me even when a wagon developed and put me in danger of being lynched.  TW never unvoted cause well he was not active at all d1.  Perhapse Rafay was scum hoping the wagon would stick and be able to vote off a very active town player early.

 

Plus Raya always talks about how great Kevin is at Mafai, and if i do remeber correctly, when Rafay is scum, kevin is typically an early kill target for him.  

 

So with that being said

 

Vote Rafay

 

Not every mod pushes forward with starting a new day if they are waiting for night actions. When I mod I usually send private messages to power roles still if they haven't submitted an action before deadline and I give them a little while to respond before updating.

 

As for my day 1, I voted for you as a joke. I didn't unvote due to activity at that time. I have more time right now so that won't happen again.

 

My assumption about why Kevin was targeted last night is simply that he's a veteran that usually provides reasonable analysis as the game progresses. I generally prefer to know which veteran players I can trust in each game so I assume scum factions usually prefer to remove those players as well if they think they can do so.

[iSocialism]

So the true question is, why is TW still alive after day one, must be scum

[Rafay]

My assumption about why Kevin was targeted last night is simply that he's a veteran that usually provides reasonable analysis as the game progresses. I generally prefer to know which veteran players I can trust in each game so I assume scum factions usually prefer to remove those players as well if they think they can do so.

 

Exactly. I think its a well known strategy that almost every mafia adopts. Kill the most active to derail the town. I've done it too as mafia but I'm not one in this case. 

[brewersalliance]

 

so why hold the game up if you are just waiting on a town role?

 

only thing makes sense is if the scum as a whole have not been very active and did not submit a team kill.

 

So lets look who could be that team.

 

TW:  only posted 1 time on day 1 and should have been mod killed but was not (maybe cause mod killing a scum D1 would not go over well)

 

Kaziocore:  only posted 2 times on day 2, same reasons as TW

 

Rafay:  was also at the bottom of the d1 post count. and last posted March 2nd before the deadline.  

 

Both Rafay and TW kept their votes on me even when a wagon developed and put me in danger of being lynched.  TW never unvoted cause well he was not active at all d1.  Perhapse Rafay was scum hoping the wagon would stick and be able to vote off a very active town player early.

 

Plus Raya always talks about how great Kevin is at Mafai, and if i do remeber correctly, when Rafay is scum, kevin is typically an early kill target for him.  

 

So with that being said

 

Vote Rafay

 

Not every mod pushes forward with starting a new day if they are waiting for night actions. When I mod I usually send private messages to power roles still if they haven't submitted an action before deadline and I give them a little while to respond before updating.

 

As for my day 1, I voted for you as a joke. I didn't unvote due to activity at that time. I have more time right now so that won't happen again.

 

My assumption about why Kevin was targeted last night is simply that he's a veteran that usually provides reasonable analysis as the game progresses. I generally prefer to know which veteran players I can trust in each game so I assume scum factions usually prefer to remove those players as well if they think they can do so.

 

 

I know thats why you did not unvote, you were inactive.  however my vote isnt on you, so stop being so defensive   its on rafay

 

i think its more likely we were waiting on the scum than town for an action.  

[The Warrior]

I was simply validating your assumption about my vote.

[brewersalliance]

ahhh 

[Lyner]

so why hold the game up if you are just waiting on a town role?

 

only thing makes sense is if the scum as a whole have not been very active and did not submit a team kill.

 

So lets look who could be that team.

 

TW:  only posted 1 time on day 1 and should have been mod killed but was not (maybe cause mod killing a scum D1 would not go over well)

 

Kaziocore:  only posted 2 times on day 2, same reasons as TW

 

Rafay:  was also at the bottom of the d1 post count. and last posted March 2nd before the deadline.  

 

Both Rafay and TW kept their votes on me even when a wagon developed and put me in danger of being lynched.  TW never unvoted cause well he was not active at all d1.  Perhapse Rafay was scum hoping the wagon would stick and be able to vote off a very active town player early.

 

Plus Raya always talks about how great Kevin is at Mafai, and if i do remeber correctly, when Rafay is scum, kevin is typically an early kill target for him.  

 

So with that being said

 

Vote Rafay

 

This is a good analysis

 

Vote Rafay

[Kaziocore]

I think it's likely that the mod waited on a town role than mafia because if there's an inactive mafia member, the others could decide for the team.

 

I could see this theory working if all the mafia members are inactive but this is unlikely lol

---

 

I would echo my thoughts on Rafay in another game. Rafay as town is indistinguishable from Rafay as mafia :/

[Dontavian]

I agree with Lyner, brewers analysis seems thorough, especially the assertion “ only thing makes sense is if the scum as a whole have not been very active and did not submit a team kill.”

—-
Also impressed with the comments the vets have about each other from previous versions...”when xx is scum, he usually always does xx”. Do you folks keep dossiers on players?

[Lord MK]

Do you folks keep dossiers on players?

I know that I am supposed to be non interfering, but yes, we do.
Soon enough, we will know your patterns too.
We are more shady than the NSA. So beware.

[Dontavian]

 

Do you folks keep dossiers on players?

I know that I am supposed to be non interfering, but yes, we do.
Soon enough, we will know your patterns too.
We are more shady than the NSA. So beware.

 

Lol...well, I'm sure it's not the first time some gov't entity has had a dossier on me...in RL and in character     If you figure out my pattern, pls let me know what it is so that I'm aware

[Rafay]

Do you folks keep dossiers on players?

 

Yes it happens but is unethical part of the game. 

[Velocity]

Do you folks keep dossiers on players?

I know that I am supposed to be non interfering, but yes, we do.
Soon enough, we will know your patterns too.
We are more shady than the NSA. So beware.

Does my dossier read that I am a “constant contractor of COVID19 and must be avoided at all costs.”

So the true question is, why is TW still alive after day one, must be scum

Even though scum are supposed to be heartless they won’t always kill an active player on the first night, it may ruin that players experience to die first all the time. Of course, the older and more experienced players would know about that and be more likely to avoid doing it to somebody....

[iSocialism]

Nah , TW alive day 2 = scum

[Lord MK]

Vote Count

Rafay (3): Robert2424, Brewersalliance, Lyner
Brewersalliance (0):
Daviesolu (0):
Robert2424 (0):
Kaziocore (0):
Dontavian (0):
The Warrior (0):
iSocialism (0):
Velocity (0):
Nadarr (0):
Lyner (0):

No Lynch (0):

Not Voting: Daviesolu, Kaziocore, Rafay, Dontavian, The Warrior, iSocialism, Velocity, Nadarr.

11 players are alive. It takes 6 to lynch or 4 at deadline. Deadlne is on 20th of March at 12 AM CN time.

[brewersalliance]

FYI I am on vacation in Miami so I'mma be MIA for several days lol

[Dontavian]

MIA

Nice 

[brewersalliance]

I think it's likely that the mod waited on a town role than mafia because if there's an inactive mafia member, the others could decide for the team.

I could see this theory working if all the mafia members are inactive but this is unlikely lol

---

I would echo my thoughts on Rafay in another game. Rafay as town is indistinguishable from Rafay as mafia :/

You were fairly inactive too, so perhaps you are scum partners from Rafay. Trying to say it's not likely scum was inactive and now quasi defending Rafay while making it look like you're not actually defending him... Hmmmm....
Also I'm drunk so don't take what I say too seriosudly

[Robert2424]

 

I think it's likely that the mod waited on a town role than mafia because if there's an inactive mafia member, the others could decide for the team.

I could see this theory working if all the mafia members are inactive but this is unlikely lol

---

I would echo my thoughts on Rafay in another game. Rafay as town is indistinguishable from Rafay as mafia :/

You were fairly inactive too, so perhaps you are scum partners from Rafay. Trying to say it's not likely scum was inactive and now quasi defending Rafay while making it look like you're not actually defending him... Hmmmm....
Also I'm drunk so don't take what I say too seriosudly

 

Entirely possible. 

[Lyner]

4 days before deadline

 

need one more volunteer to push Rafay