363 replies to this topic

[KevinH]

I didn't find a diagnoser mafia role, but I found the term in reference to The Rosenhan Experiement

"On Being Sane in Insane Places" concludes "it is clear that we cannot distinguish the sane from the insane in psychiatric hospitals"

[Lyner]

Where's CM

Vote: CM

[Robert2424]

Yeah. Diagnose. Has to be if someone is insane. Now that he's gone. I guess it's we are all insane till somehow proven sane beyond a doubt. But. I think going into this game, for the name sake, we should be expecting insane things and happenings?

I'm going to have to reread. Or get some sleep and read. I have to admit. I'm a bit lost.

[KevinH]

We can't trust investigations due to sanity problems.
Let's go with votes.

 

FERASTICAL (7) Canik, MK, Cod, LWW, KevinH
MK (1) Ferastical
ROBERT2424 (1) Robert2424

Not Voting: Captainjf, Colonel Medved, Lyner, Rafay, Suyash

 

Robert's vote on himself was never explained. He tried to unvote but it didn't work.

 

Probable town: Those that voted Ferastical

Possibly scum: Those that didn't vote

[captainjf]

Due to voting with no explanation:

 

VOTE: Suyash

 

Unless the votes are explained or more participation occurs. 

[Chaplain of death]

Due to voting with no explanation:

 

VOTE: Suyash

 

Unless the votes are explained or more participation occurs. 

 

This is about where I am at currently, but gonna wait to pile on since we have a role that gets multiple votes in play.

[Lyner]

This is about where I am at currently, but gonna wait to pile on since we have a role that gets multiple votes in play.

 

 

If this double voter(s) is town then shouldn't it be better for him to come out?

[Chaplain of death]

Not sure. Chances are people will figure out who they are within a day or 2 anyway from voting records but they'll have a target on their back since they make it harder for scum to win.

[Robert2424]

Yeah. I don't see a point in the double voter coming out. All your doing is painting more of a target on there back.

I feel we are kind at square one here. Though the wagon was good for town. It happened really fast. With potentially two scums, it's possible scum team B jumped into scum A. So it's more of a guessing game. But doesn't mean we didn't learn anything from the lynch though. But potentially not as much as we could have.

[Robert2424]

Also kevin. I'm willing to bet it was cause I voted for brewers for adding a Jester to the game. It's a bad role and he knows my personal distaste for it. I'm sure he knew when the Jester was lynched that was probably going to happen and in retaliation he decided to make me self vote. Petty but whatever. He messaged me personally to try to fill a slot for this game and I decided to give his GMing another shot. So not a good start for him to say the least.

[KevinH]

Brewers gave me a hidden modifier one game that I couldn't change my vote on Day 1.

It didn't make a big difference in that game but it makes me wary for future games.

[Lyner]

Unless it's a hidden ability, it's more likely that the double voter is scum.

 

If he's town why would he vote early yesterday? Either it's a really confident vote or it's a malicious one (another evidence there is a second scum faction)

[KevinH]

VELOCITY (5) Canik, Suyash, KevinH, Lyner, Ferastical
CANIK (1)  CoD
CM (1) CAPTAINJF
RAFAY (1) CM
SUYASH (1) LWW
 
No Lynch:  MK
 
Not Voting:  Anglet Green (now CaptainJF 2.0), Colonel Medved, Rafay, Robert2424
 
Velocity, a Jester, was lynched D1

FERASTICAL (7) Canik, MK, Cod, LWW, KevinH
MK (1) Ferastical
ROBERT2424 (1) Robert2424

Not Voting: Captainjf, Colonel Medved, Lyner, Rafay, Suyash

 

We also know that Ferastical (revealed as scum ninja) visited Chaplain of Death Night 1

 

Vote: Colonel Medved

 

...for not voting ever

[Chaplain of death]

Vote: Suyash

 

Because of inactivity, an unwillingness to explain themself and their reasoning, and for voting for a non-scum aligned Day 1 and not voting for the scum aligned on Day 2.

[brewersalliance]

Well this game died

Let's spice things up a bit

If this thread hits 15 more posts by the time I check in next I'll do something awesome. If not I'll do something evil

[Chaplain of death]

I vote for evil.

[Colonel Medved]

Oh... Hello everyone! 

 

I would like to blame it on a certain person for not adding me into the group chat when i was placed in the game, but honestly i should have checked in lmao

 

das my bad 

 

 

Vote: CM A random suspect but he's been too quiet for my liking.

 

 

Fair point. I need to improve on that, I'm going to make more of a commitment from here on out. If i don't, then put me in my straight jacket and give me the sleep sleep juice lol

 

Where's CM Vote: CM

 

 

Anyone want to theorize about what a diagnoser could be?   Personally, sounds like a potential way to discover sanities!

 

 

That's a good thought. I found the Psychologist role, could fit the bill. 

[lilweirdward]

Well this game died

Let's spice things up a bit

If this thread hits 15 more posts by the time I check in next I'll do something awesome. If not I'll do something evil

Yeah ok that's obviously not happening, so just do the evil thing.

Also I've been pushing to get Jaden/Suyash lynched since Day 1 because he keeps doing things that hurt town at best and are blatantly scummy at worst (voting for Velocity twice, posting nothing except to vote, refusing to engage with town), so I'm glad that he seems to be leading the vote. I'm going to wait to see a vote count though before voting for him though. @brewers before you do the evil thing, can you do a vote count please?

[Lyner]

Vote: Suyash

[captainjf]

I'm indifferent