1469 replies to this topic

[Falzis]

What Narsis said. Though more emphasis on a). CD is/could be the third scum.

Again, just because Martino didn't get lynched doesn't mean he is mafia. It's all WIFOM and assumes certain things). Even with two quick mafia votes, you or Narsis could have removed your votes. You also pointed out the assumption of Samus and SinKon being townies, which I don't believe one of them is.

I'll give you more WIFOM. If the three of us were really scum, why would we go out "supporting" (assuming we are really, and not just merely coincidentally agreeing because we logically saw it to be) each other so obviously as we have done recently? Especially in LYLO, why would we vote for a No Lynch?

You have to concede that in most games, mafia try to rub themselves on to other townies to either get their support or cast similar suspicion on them. Am I saying the three of us are ALL townies? Of course not! One of EM or Martino could and would most likely be scum. But saying the three of us are scum for sure is illogical and impossible (because I'm a townie).

Also, I just thought of this, if you're really so sure of your theory of "the mafia could just pile three votes quickly before deadline and win it", why didn't it happen? Especially when two players are inactive and does not look likely to come back? That only means that your theory could still be correct but it didn't happen because the third scum is inactive!

HMM OH YEAH that must be it!! Now I'm quite sure one of SinKon or Samus is scum.

[Aquinas]

a) I'm townie
I have no reason to doubt Aquinas since he came out to defend me and revealed the item he found.

I'm fairly certain you are townie since Martino did not get lynched.

If Martino was townie...and you were mafia...then he should have been lynched with 2 more quick mafia votes.
That didn't happen (this is assuming that Samus and SinKon are townies).

Since Martino survived the lynch...I can only assume he is mafia as well as EM and Falzis.

@Aquinas - please focus on Martino as I am certain he is mafia.

I will consider it. However, I don't intend to give up any specifics on how my item will be used tonight. It seems like the scum powers we're dealing with lend well to the mechanics of the game and I don't want to make it any easier for them to elude us.

[CanucksDynasty]

I will consider it. However, I don't intend to give up any specifics on how my item will be used tonight. It seems like the scum powers we're dealing with lend well to the mechanics of the game and I don't want to make it any easier for them to elude us.

Fair enough.
Your item...your choice.

[CanucksDynasty]

What Narsis said. Though more emphasis on a). CD is/could be the third scum.

Again, just because Martino didn't get lynched doesn't mean he is mafia. It's all WIFOM and assumes certain things). Even with two quick mafia votes, you or Narsis could have removed your votes. You also pointed out the assumption of Samus and SinKon being townies, which I don't believe one of them is.

I'll give you more WIFOM. If the three of us were really scum, why would we go out "supporting" (assuming we are really, and not just merely coincidentally agreeing because we logically saw it to be) each other so obviously as we have done recently? Especially in LYLO, why would we vote for a No Lynch?

You have to concede that in most games, mafia try to rub themselves on to other townies to either get their support or cast similar suspicion on them. Am I saying the three of us are ALL townies? Of course not! One of EM or Martino could and would most likely be scum. But saying the three of us are scum for sure is illogical and impossible (because I'm a townie).

Also, I just thought of this, if you're really so sure of your theory of "the mafia could just pile three votes quickly before deadline and win it", why didn't it happen? Especially when two players are inactive and does not look likely to come back? That only means that your theory could still be correct but it didn't happen because the third scum is inactive!

HMM OH YEAH that must be it!! Now I'm quite sure one of SinKon or Samus is scum.

You have your theories...I have mine.

Could SinKon or Samus be mafia?...yes.
I have no absolute way of knowing.

However, they have gone inactive...and in all the games I've played in...it's usually townie roles that get abadoned.

[Falzis]

Previous assumptions shouldn't always be relied upon for they are never universally true. By logic, as I illustrated above using your own theory, one of the two inactives must be scum.

[CanucksDynasty]

Previous assumptions shouldn't always be relied upon for they are never universally true. By logic, as I illustrated above using your own theory, one of the two inactives must be scum.

So how many games have you seen where a player abandoned a mafia role?

[Falzis]

Again, just because we've never seen it happen doesn't mean it couldn't.

[CanucksDynasty]

Again, just because we've never seen it happen doesn't mean it couldn't.

So it's like getting hit by lightining.
It can happen but the odds are very low.

[CanucksDynasty]

http://www.iron-command.com/forum/index.php?showtopic=13953&st=0&#entry234647

Looks like SinKon will not be back as he's walked.

[molestargazer]

Junkahoolik replaces Samus.
Looks like I'm gonna need a replacement for SinKon as well.

Dusk'll end in an hour or so, I'll give Junk the time to pick up his PM and make a move.

[junkahoolik]

hey peps. anyone here?? i need some pointers

[junkahoolik]

guess not...

move: room 1

[CanucksDynasty]

Nice to see you again.
Have fun reading/catching up.

[junkahoolik]

damn my trigger-happiness...

[Electric Mango]

Better get comfortable Junkahoolic, you've got some catching up to do, and it's nice to see you back by the way.

While it's true that most mafia roles don't get left behind, this game could be different because:

1. This game is longer and harder than the rest
2. Sinkon walked

[molestargazer]

Electric Mango is randomly assigned to Room 7, the Beach.
SinKon is randomly assigned to Room 3, the Cove.

It is now NIGHT FOUR.
Night actions to me by Wednesday 3rd Jan (Would be tuesday but I won't be here then).

[molestargazer]

AKCPLUTO replaces SinKon. He's awesome. Treat him as such.

[molestargazer]

Due to the stresses of the previous days, the sun is well into the sky before the occupants of the island stretch their legs and walk out of the hastily-constructed camp. As with the macabre scene of the dead cop on the plane, the occupants gather round the wreckage to discuss what's going to happen.
But... what's this? One of them is missing again. The group split up to search for Junkahoolik II, and eventually, a shout is heard coming from the headland. The survivors run to the top of the headland, and look down. Hundreds of metres below, oddly distorted from hitting the rock, is the body of Junkahoolik. The group turns away, sickened, and return to the wreckage.

Junkahoolik II, TOWNIE, has been killed.

It's DAY FIVE.
Deadline for today is the 18TH FEBRUARY.
I'm heading off for a week's vacation on the week of the deadline - anyone who's interested in holding down the fort whilst I'm away please send me a PM - you'll only need to close the thread come deadline. You're gonna have to wait 'til I get back to see what happens.

Edited by molestargazer, 04 February 2010 - 05:22 PM.

[Electric Mango]

So night power people, what did you see?

[CanucksDynasty]

Cove (Area 3) - Falzis, Sinkon
Woods (Area 6) - Aquinas, CD, Narsis
Camp (Area 4) - Martino
Headland (Area 1) - junkahoolic II
Beach (Area 7) - EM



Noone entered into the WOODS since I didn't get a pm during the night.