d3mon

Really.. you role claimed to disprove my role claim.. Why would you do that? I am not sure how you role claiming Vanilla townie disproves anything. Claiming that a vanilla townie and a security guard make the game unbalanced sounds a little far fetched to me.

I will try to answer your questions 1) About my role - Yes, I am claiming that my role is same. 2) About TC being Janitor - I have answered the TC janitor question more than once... I will try to answer it again i) His comment indicates that he is mopping. I am not sure what I should make out from this.. was it was a joke?? I dont think so. Remember there are 3 newbies (no offence) in this round. I just believe that it was a very obvious mistake by one of them. ii) I have a role PM that indicates that there are characters similar to #1. iii) As part of initial game description mole has confirmed that this is not a one of thing. 3) I claimed to be a character from last round without any need - Seriously?? I think I was the prime suspect at that time. ( I still am ) Moreover, in your own comments... there were plenty of negative/weak power roles. As long as I claimed that I was just one of the eight.. it shouldnt have made any difference. 4) It is better for mafia to blend in - By the same argument I am a definite townie. : Well.. you talked about inconsistencies.. so I had some questions 1) You were pretty adamant that when I claimed to be a character from last round, I was helping the mafia. Now you agree wih my presumption that there were plenty of weak/negative townie roles to balance out the stronger roles... is this inconsistent? 2) After bashing me for revealing something about my character.. you are now role claiming... is this consistent? You were definitely not a suspect and I dont understand the need for you to roleclaim. Also, may I ask you to paraphrase

Would you be so kind to point to any inconsistencies in my posts. I wonder... why you want me to paraphrase (since I am essentially claiming a role that you are very familiar with)... still since you want more information. I would recommend you read Mole's post here My link To answer your other question... assuming you are scum.. wouldn't it be better for you if the town lynched a power role and you could use your nightkill on someone else?

AWO

4

4412

k.. so I am back... well.. with 4 votes (am I counting right?).. I will probably get the majority/2 lynch.. CD.. best of luck for day 2.. I hope you would be able to explain your actions better than I did.

7/10 I think I have seen you around here.

AWB

VIII

4418

:grenadekx1:

20

Good going.. next target 1000.

VI

I would have to say that scum has really played well.. I claim that I am the security guard. Does this change anything? P.S. I will be out of town tomorrow.. so might not be able to post. Have fun discussing if my claim is true.

AVZ

AVV

CaoCao, by negative town role, I mean someone like the insomniac or the cowardly lifeguard.

4

At the risk of repeating myself.. I dont think a role claim would help the town or me. @Preston - According to me the vote count is 4-2. Cao Cao has not indicated his opinion and has mostly raised questions regarding the need for a role claim. Also, I suspect that scum is voting for a role claim (why not??), so the actual townie votes might be 3-2, 2-2 or even 1-2 Assuming, I role claim to avoid being lynched on day1. I see the following scenarios 1) I have a strong power role - Assuming scum has a role blocker, they can block my night actions and ensure that I have nothing to prove the next day. With all this suspicion, I would probably be lynched on day 2. 2) I claim a weak role - Again a role blocker would create a scenario pretty similar to 1. This also might not stop the town from lynching me. 3) I claim a negative town role - Town lynches me. So, in all, the question for me is... Do you want to be lynched on day 1 or day 2? I will take day 1 with no role claim. I would also like to see the opinion of inactives/replacements.

I attack the hill with an army of racoons... My hill..

I

MOD: Nerau and Herodez have not posted in a while. Please prod.