The Warrior

Like I said in game, I didn’t blame you at all for questioning it. I would have too if I was in your shoes. One of my biggest pet peeves in mafia is when people assume they know someone’s role without hard evidence suggesting it. Hell, even with evidence you can’t take anything as gospel in this game.

Frustrating to see that the town couldn’t finish it off. For the record, I successfully identified every scum in the game before they were officially revealed. Called out Kevin and COD early on. Voted to lynch COD and would have voted for Kevin if he wasn’t night killed. And after I was notified that I was killed, I correctly guessed that LWW and Velocity were scum. If I wasn’t killed at night I would have gone after LWW next because my opinion of him changed in the last day that I was alive. Good game nonetheless.

Remember me the way I was yesterday.

I’m just going with my gut here as well. If COD is somehow not scum then it’s likely two of our VT claims have lied. My concern now is that a Godfather might actually exist. There are a couple reasons I believe one might exist: 1) I am a townie (Miller) who investigates as scum. It would absolutely be a Brewers move to also have a scum (Godfather) that investigates as a town in this game. 2) The Cop wasn’t targeted for the kill last night. Could be that mafia thought he could be protected. On the other hand could it be because at least one of the scum isn’t afraid of being investigated? The scum’s choice for night kill tonight could be very telling.

Idk man, I don't have a reason to really doubt the claim, but if anyone is good enough to pull it off, it's TW. Unless CoD is a role cop or got lucky as a tracker or something, then we're probably stuck not being able to confirm or disprove his claim. At this point I'm still taking it at face value since it would be so hard to successfully fake, but I've been trying to analyze his play more to get a better sense that way. Which way are you leaning? I assure you that I’m Town. I’ve tried to be as forthcoming as possible throughout the game. I guess my question for you would be, if you’ve been willing to trust me this far, why change your mind now? Nothing has happened that would indicate that I wasn’t being truthful. Deadline is tomorrow morning so I’m going to go ahead and vote for my top candidate at this point. Vote: COD

This feels fishy to me, encouraging the vig to shoot a specific set of people before the day has even ended. I'm not saying you're scum because I still think it's far more likely that you're a miller as you've claimed, but this strategy would be hugely beneficial to scum if they aren't at least one of the two who haven't claimed.Captain asked for advice about what to do yesterday. I’m offering advice for what to do today based off of what I believe is the correct course of action for the town. Captain can ultimately decide what he wants to do but I think the likelihood is that at least one of the mentioned people is scum.

Deadline is in two days and you are currently tied with two other people (me and Wolfpacks) for the vote lead. I’d say that if you get a second vote against you, you should go ahead and claim. Especially if it means you can confirm something for the town.

I'm leaning towards voting for COD right now for a couple reasons: 1) He was one of the people on my short list initially due to his questioning my role claim. 2) He seemed to come off pretty strong in his opposition to other people role claiming. It sort of seemed like someone who didn't want to see a bunch of role claims yet because he might have to. 3) He's been noticeably less active recently. 4) There is most likely two scum left and he's one of the remaining players that we know nothing about. Now, I make these points with the following caveats: 1) It's everyone's job to question everything, including role claims.. and 2) Mass role claiming isn't allowed. @Captain - If we do lynch one of the unknowns today (COD or Velocity) and they happen to be town, my suggestion would be to shoot the other at night. I would say we have Rafay investigate whichever lives but chances are he will be the scum's target tonight (unless they have a Godfather and aren't worried about letting the Cop live).

I think we’re either going to find one of the following scenarios to be the case: -COD and Velocity are both scum Or -1 of either COD or Velocity and 1 of either Wolfpacks or Dontavian are scum. I think starting with the unknown grouping is our best bet.

Have you pinged Wolfpacks outside of the game?

Which could be LWW. I don’t have any reason to doubt he’s town though currently. I’ve been getting a town vibe from him up to this point anyway.

Yep. I’m not advocating for everyone to role claim just keeping track of everything. @COD - You’ve been a little bit quieter recently. Any thoughts?

AND YOUR GUESS WOULD BE WRONG. ALSO, NOT SURE HOW I ENEDED UP ON TW’S POTENTIAL SCUM LIST, BUT HE’S OFF AS WELL. SO, SINCE I’M APPARENTLY SUS AND WE’RE IN D3, I’LL ROLL THE DICE AND RC NOW, THEN THE INFO IS OUT THERE.I’M “Jhogo, a dothraki screamer and Vanilla Townie” DOTHRAKI SCREAMER...THUS THAT’S WHY ALL MY POSTS HAVE BEEN SHOUTING (SCREAMING). My scum list? The only list you were put on is an unknown list because nothing was known about your alleged role until now. I’d like to know why you chose to role claim now as well though. You weren’t under any sort of pressure. I believe this leaves COD and Velocity as the only two people we have no information (uncovered or given) about now.

I had completely forgotten that you role claimed, probably because what you claimed isn’t really memorable. Of course that doesn’t mean you’re lying necessarily. It just means the role claim doesn’t really stand out — other than supposedly being the only VT to this point (if you’re telling the truth). Either way, every other person on my town list has a good reason to be there. They’ve either investigated as town or claimed a town role that has been “proven” more or less.

Here is where I believe we're at with the remaining players: Town: TW - Town Miller. Claimed on D1/D2. Helped confirm Torres as being a Friendly Neighbor (Town). Captain - Town Vig. Claimed to have shot Kevin (scum) on N2. Rafay - Town Cop. LWW - Role unknown. Investigated as Town to Rafay on N2. Not confirmed town but most likely is. Unknown: COD Dontavian Velocity Wolfpacks Assuming the top 4 are all town, and given that this game probably features 3 scum total, with 2 scum remaining that means we basically have a 50/50 chance of lynching scum today if we lynch someone in the unknown category.

Why don’t you actually think about what I’ve claimed to be and how I’ve played the game up to this point instead of voting based off of your flawed investigation result? I am a Miller. That is the only reason why I investigated as guilty to you. That’s what a Miller does. Regarding Torres: I helped confirm him as a Friendly Neighbor and a member of the town. Regarding Kevin: I didn’t end up voting for him yesterday but I listed him as one of my top suspects and called him out early in the game as well when he was critical of me being a Miller. If Wolfpacks didn’t play the way he did yesterday I would have voted for Kevin when no one else was.

Well, crap. We now have an alleged cop claim and Vig claim. If we have a protective role, please think long and hard (that’s what she said) about who you protect tonight.

And you're still wrong. I don't quite understand this. Not the fact that you're taking me at my word (because I'm telling the truth), but the vote for Rafay. Rafay's horrendously wrong in voting for me but why are you voting for someone who has claimed Cop and has not been countered? Let me be clear about this: I don't think Rafay is scum. It is likely that he is a Cop and is just voting for me for some retarded reason. Vote: Tony Not necessarily because it's me your voting for, but because you've hardly contributed at all this game, and basically admitting that you're just placing a side vote to avoid getting lynched instead of committing to an actual vote feels really scummy to me. I have to kind of agree with this. If you're only voting for LWW to register a vote just because instead of voting on someone who might actually get lynched today that does look kind of bad. Overall I'm still most critical of the 3 people who have challenged my role claim. I don't fault you because you should but I also have the benefit of knowing that I'm telling the truth and therefore it looks scummy to me that Kevin, COD, and Wolfpacks have done so. Of the three of them, Kevin has been the most vocal in repeatedly calling it into question. Wolfpacks however has done so and then voted for Rafay who claimed Cop for some reason.. So for now.. Vote: Wolfpacks Can you explain the vote on Rafay?

I almost always vote on the last day or two. It shouldn’t be surprising. Here is where I’m at right now: - I know that I’m a Miller (Town). - I know that Torres is a Friendly Neighbor (Town). - I know that Rafay claimed to be a Cop to give us information that I already gave (most likely Town). So as far as I’m concerned I personally know of three “confirmed” townies. That leaves at least three scum somewhere in this list: Captain Lww Kevin Dontavian Velocity Lord MK COD Tony Wolfpacks Since I know that I’m town, by default that means that I think anyone who is attempting to cast doubt on my role is potentially scum. The people who have been the most critical of me (other than Rafay who is most likely town) imo so far have been: Kevin COD Wolfpacks I’m not saying they’re all scum because they probably aren’t but if I had to guess right now I’d say that at least one of them is.

Come on guys, at least FOS someone or something. The day is more than halfway over.If we trust TW: TW cleared, Torres cleared, captain most suspicious but nobody overly soIt we don’t trust TW: TW suspicious, Torres 50/50, captain not as suspicious If we think TW is scum: TW highly suspicious, Torres pretty cleared, captain a bit suspicious If we think Rafay makes a lot of sense: We don’t I’m willing to give TW the benefit of the doubt at least for today, but his experience does make it possible this could be a power play by him, in my mind. Personally, I don’t think captain is super suspicious, but I can see how the current things we know could point that way, since nobody else is really suspicious much at all. I don’t know about captain but other than that option 1 is correct.

I agree that they could. I’m trying to be as transparent as possible so the town knows that I am what I’ve claimed.

I will vote for Torres again today as well but it's still too early to end the day. I know that MK is keeping track of night actions but is anyone keeping track of claimed/suspected roles as well?

Well, you’re in luck (unless you’re actually scum) because that’s not what I’m doing.

This is how I feel as well. When big game events occur that are potentially controversial (i.e. a Miller role claiming and the subsequent debate about it) scum usually enjoys watching the fallout and letting town go after town. A scum might participate in that debate to help steer the narrative a bit but it's not uncommon for most scum to sit back and watch it play out and avoid being put on the spot in such situations.

I got that note last night that said Torres is a member of the town. I don’t know how else that would have happened unless he’s a Friendly Neighbor.