Alternate_Tree

Well, you people are talking a lot in this game. I've read through page 10, and am still forming opinions. Just wanted to give an update on my catching up and then I'll post actual thoughts when I get through the mountain of posts.

X

I'll join if there's still space

Hello everybody, I'm a replacement player. I haven't had a chance to catch up on what's happening, but I will definitely be able to over the weekend and give my opinion on stuff.

I enjoyed it, thanks for sharing

Powerful

I think I may also have to sit out, it's my spring break in a week and a half and I will be very busy until then, but after spring break I hope to mod my own mafia game

Yeah, we should have taken out the two confirmed roles, especially since we only had 3. It was a pretty fun game, and my first time as scum

Well since I am in the hotseat, and I know that lynching me will be a bad choice, I'm going to vote the only option open. Vote: Xarastier

Well since I'm probably going to be lynched tomorrow I'll say my piece. We've had this list of "scummy people" that includes myself because I have not been very active. My roleclaim isn't very powerful because I don't do anything. I'm Oin, a vanilla member of the company, and I didn't want to raise too much of a fuss because I could hope that the scum would think I have a power role and murder me instead of the people that have actual power roles. I would just like to raise the point that maybe LK and EM aren't both town but both scum. We only know they are together, but it may be that they are both scum and are pushing for my lynch because they can do it at deadline with maybe only 1 townie voting for my lynch. We also have the new pair of Rafay and d3mon being linked by the investigation. It is also entirely possible that they are covering for each other to survive an extra day and will let the lynch of another townie go down without raising suspicions of them. Xarastier is suspicious to me just in the way he plays, so I don't know if he's a scum if he's going for something else. I can't get a read on Noahband, if there were more people I would say lynch him because he is more inactive than I am. Karl claiming miller may just be a scum planning ahead. Imran is tough to get a read on, but he is usually a good voice of reason and we should definitely reconsider evidence before lynching today because lynching will bring us within a day of the scum winning if it is a mislynch.

I'll admit to not being active, I have been quite busy with school. As to not being helpful, I can say I have no information to add and my judgements are any different than most of what people have stated. I don't know who to vote for out of the suspicious parties.

Does anyone have any useful information from last night because we are one vote away from a lynch, and it's important we get the right person. D3mon hasn't provided a defense, but we should at least wait until everyone has said their piece.

Updated So I will start with this because I agree with most of it. EM and LK are almost certainly on a team because no one has raised objections, whether they are town or scum playing at town is the question. The more likely is town because it is a pretty risky move to say you're on a team as the scum and guarantee 2 deaths for the scum rather than one if they get found out. Next is CoD and Xara, I'm not really sure what to think. CoD raging could indicate he's a frustrated townie, or it could indicate he's frustrated as scum for having Xara on his team with his confusing methods. Xara is very confusing, if he keeps sliding by his role claim even with all of us asking for his results, he may have blatantly lied as a scum, or made a transparent lie as a townie to lynch a non-power role? Or maybe something involving getting killed? I didn't check the list at the beginning because I am not as familiar with all of the roles and I'm writing this while playing Dota 2 and need to pay attention. Next on the list is Kaz, not really sure. Seems pro town because he is actually engaging and promoting discussion. Nothing suspicious, so I'd say a townie. Everyone else, including myself, seems to be waiting for something to happen and aren't giving up much info. I don't have any reads other than people being careful

One thing I'm going to say is that people should stop personal attacks because this is first and foremost a game. Otherwise I'd like to know, as Kaz said, what Xarastier found out last night to get the ball rolling on narrowing down the list of scum.

i win

Replying to Kaz, yeah I guess I am lazy. This week is the first week of the new semester, and I just haven't been feeling like posting stuff. I never really feel like lynching the first day is a good idea because it usually doesn't give any information on the people because they can claim it made sense at the time versus whatever "proof" they're scum. The fast votes for Lorikz are suspicious to me, but I don't see a reason to change my vote

I haven't gone afk btw, I just don't have anything relevant to add to the conversation. I've said my piece and haven't seen anything worth changing my vote over

75

Wait, so Karl, have you read LotR and not the Hobbit? Because with most people it's the other way around since the hobbit is a lot shorter and meant for a younger audience. Anyways, it seems like there is at least some good night roles that can provide good information, I just say wait a day before lynching anyone. Vote: No lynch

46

Man, gotta be suspicious of Karl since he hasn't read the book, but anyway I would vote for some time to hear what people have to say before voting to lynch anyone just yet. I'm also slightly confused how there would be a gun for the gunsmith to detect, since gunpowder wasn't discovered yet in Middle Earth, but that's just me being a super nerd

Technology

Well I have to make another go after last game, count me in

DUT

Well I'll say something, even though I don't have anything of value to say. I'm slightly confused as to why after roleclaiming EM tells us to wait a couple days to reveal what he's going to say. If he can't get targeted by a death note, then it would be prudent to post earlier before the scum have a chance to kill a person. Waiting extra time only benefits the scum since it doesn't prove anything if he doesn't get lynched in the next couple days, just that he's stalling