Lachiton

TBF it is the first day of scum hunting and town has nothing else to base their suspicions on, except each player's vote for town roles. I got heat for my choice of Doctor too. Roleblocker is a powerful role, and more of an active one than Doctor, but again suffers the same fate if Strongman is the mafia choice. So unless Strongman is killed off, roleblocker will be useless too. So there are some questions on your choice, especially MK, who actually voted first for role blocker and only voted cop after it was already the most popular choice. Rafay and KC didn't post any thoughts regarding their choice, so I will wait till I hear their side of the story.

Dos

Not sure where you're going with this, but I have posted only after Kevin confirmed town can start voting since mafia chose their role, so my "pushing" for doctor cannot have any bearing on the role already decided. I know Doctor is a very common role, most traditional mafia games have a combination of detective/cop and a doctor setup usually. As vgnmaster rightly pointed out, mafia must have considered cop to the be the numero uno choice of town, so godfather is the most likely role to have been chosen. So in that likelihood, doctor can actually save the cop who is the town's biggest asset. Strongman could have been chosen as well, but with doctor/roleblocker not a sure shot lock, ultimately the role would become useless. And though ninja seems to be the least likely chosen role, I have a feeling it might be the 2nd choice of the mafia. Mafia must have also thought that town will consider doctor/roleblocker somewhat of a risk given strongman on the cards, so generally we will go with the safer bet of tracker/watcher. So in that scenario with ninja, he can be the one doing the killing, hoping to eliminate cop and making tracker useless. With godfather, he would likely take a step back and and let the other mafia do the kills so as to not alert the tracker. Basically above sums up my reasoning for doctor. Also it must be noted when I made that post, none of the voters expressed their thoughts on the choices they're making, except MK, so I just wanted to know hear other's thoughts on my choice.

I thought Mafia gets only one role and they have already voted on it pre-game

No takers for doctor yet, eh? I am still sticking to both Cop and Doctor. Getting to save a townie sounds to me a much more valuable asset than Tracker, especially when a save or two can salvage the game for the town. Yes they are useless against strongman but so is tracker against ninja. Also the roles are unlimited, more so reason to me to stick with doctor. Roleblocker is good too, can help town from scum kills but kind of double edged sword as he might invariably block town cop from investigating. Also mafia has already made their choice and they will try to confuse us to vote for the roles of their choice, so we should look out for that too Your role PMs should mention the number of votes you receive if you're a townie. Maybe they don't know how many votes they get cause they're not towniesLol, you just ended the game.

We get to vote on two roles right? If so, my vote goes for both Cop and Doctor. Reasoning - Cop is obvious choice, Doctor will help save a possible townie or can reveal the role of scum to him if his save doesn't work. He can put more effort in cross questioning his suspect(s) and convince the Cop to direct his investigation on the suspect, getting a sure shot success. If I get only one vote, I am more inclined on Doctor then. But as Kitkat mentioned above, if Doctor have very limited shots of protection, then probably not worth it. So my vote depends on the clarification about the no of opportunities they get.

I never played Mafia before, lol. Can I join too?

You finally did it. Congrats!!

IX

I

XI

Banned for agreeing with brewer

Granted but you lose the ticket. I wish I can make people laugh.

CC - 2017 Argus - 672 LS - 604 murphpk - 163 Rhizo - 155 King Cankles - 147 ​Theophilos - 140 RR - 138 ​​Hertt - 113 dagonslayer51 - 111 AngelCruzdelaSant - 87 brewersalliance- 85 Fermion - 77 welder - 48 George Jarvis - 46 MK - 46 Lachiton - 21 Mazuurek - 19 Jarcine1221 - 18 Balacenia - 16 captainjf - 16 spike2 - 14 myrrdin Emrys - 13 MorganFreeman - 13 Yamuna - 13 theWanderer - 11 legoboyvdlp - 9 JayMillz - 6 Leche06 - 6 Rolento - 4 Atliis - 4 Sithon - 3 Kaziocore - 3 Mandarijn - 3 sukmaindra9 - 3 1ceCream - 3 Whitebeard - 2 SaveStation - 2 Robert2424 - 1 Ferastical - 1

CC - 2017 Argus - 672 LS - 604 murphpk - 163 Rhizo - 155 King Cankles - 146 ​Theophilos - 140 RR - 138 ​​Hertt - 113 dagonslayer51 - 111 AngelCruzdelaSant - 87 brewersalliance- 84 Fermion - 77 welder - 48 George Jarvis - 46 MK - 46 Lachiton - 20 Mazuurek - 19 Jarcine1221 - 18 Balacenia - 16 captainjf - 16 spike2 - 14 myrrdin Emrys - 13 MorganFreeman - 13 Yamuna - 13 theWanderer - 11 legoboyvdlp - 9 JayMillz - 6 Leche06 - 6 Rolento - 4 Atliis - 4 Sithon - 3 Kaziocore - 3 Mandarijn - 3 sukmaindra9 - 3 1ceCream - 3 Whitebeard - 2 SaveStation - 2 Robert2424 - 1 Ferastical - 1

CC - 2017 Argus - 669 LS - 604 murphpk - 163 Rhizo - 155 King Cankles - 143 ​Theophilos - 140 RR - 138 ​​Hertt - 113 dagonslayer51 - 111 AngelCruzdelaSant - 87 brewersalliance- 81 Fermion - 77 welder - 48 George Jarvis - 46 MK - 46 Mazuurek - 19 Lachiton - 19 Jarcine1221 - 18 Balacenia - 16 captainjf - 16 spike2 - 14 myrrdin Emrys - 13 MorganFreeman - 13 Yamuna - 13 theWanderer - 11 legoboyvdlp - 9 JayMillz - 6 Leche06 - 6 Rolento - 4 Atliis - 4 Sithon - 3 Kaziocore - 3 Mandarijn - 3 sukmaindra9 - 3 1ceCream - 3 Whitebeard - 2 SaveStation - 2 Robert2424 - 1 Ferastical - 1

reached the finishing line.

Winners stay real. Dreams are for losers.

CC - 2017 Argus - 668 LS - 604 murphpk - 163 Rhizo - 155 King Cankles - 138 RR - 138 ​Theophilos - 137 ​​Hertt - 113 dagonslayer51 - 111 AngelCruzdelaSant - 87 Fermion - 77 brewersalliance- 75 welder - 48 George Jarvis - 46 MK - 46 Mazuurek - 19 Jarcine1221 - 18 Lachiton - 18 Balacenia - 16 captainjf - 16 spike2 - 14 myrrdin Emrys - 13 MorganFreeman - 13 Yamuna - 13 theWanderer - 11 legoboyvdlp - 9 JayMillz - 6 Leche06 - 6 Rolento - 4 Atliis - 4 Sithon - 3 Kaziocore - 3 Mandarijn - 3 sukmaindra9 - 3 1ceCream - 3 Whitebeard - 2 SaveStation - 2 Robert2424 - 1 Ferastical - 1

Hmmm, I will have a go at it. Your wish is granted. You have a magical wand that makes your every wish come true. You wish for 100 million dollars and a bag full of money materializes out of thin air. Your joy know no bounds. You can make yourself happy and your enemies tremble. But with euphoria comes paranoia. The wand grants it's wielder any wish, so if somehow you lose the wand or it is stolen you will also lose the power. You realize the power is in the wand not in you. You need to correct that. So you gear up for your wish - "I wish to have all the powers of the wand to myself. From now on I will be the one who makes wishes come true, not this wand.". POOF!!! Your wish is granted, but you forgot one little thing. The magical wand had that power because only a magical wand can wield such power. So here you are, transformed into a wand, lying neglected on the ground, waiting for someone to pick you up and making their wish come true My wish - I can see future and change it to my suiting.

CC - 2017 Argus - 664 LS - 604 murphpk - 163 Rhizo - 155 RR - 138 ​Theophilos - 137 King Cankles - 130 ​​Hertt - 113 dagonslayer51 - 111 AngelCruzdelaSant - 87 Fermion - 77 brewersalliance- 69 welder - 48 George Jarvis - 46 MK - 46 Mazuurek - 19 Jarcine1221 - 18 Lachiton - 17 Balacenia - 16 captainjf - 16 spike2 - 14 myrrdin Emrys - 13 MorganFreeman - 13 Yamuna - 13 theWanderer - 11 legoboyvdlp - 9 JayMillz - 6 Leche06 - 6 Rolento - 4 Atliis - 4 Sithon - 3 Kaziocore - 3 Mandarijn - 3 sukmaindra9 - 3 1ceCream - 3 Whitebeard - 2 SaveStation - 2 Robert2424 - 1 Ferastical - 1

CC - 2017 Argus - 663 LS - 604 murphpk - 163 Rhizo - 155 RR - 138 ​Theophilos - 137 King Cankles - 129 ​​Hertt - 113 dagonslayer51 - 111 AngelCruzdelaSant - 87 Fermion - 77 brewersalliance- 69 welder - 48 George Jarvis - 46 MK - 46 Mazuurek - 19 Jarcine1221 - 18 Balacenia - 16 captainjf - 16 Lachiton - 16 spike2 - 14 myrrdin Emrys - 13 MorganFreeman - 13 Yamuna - 13 theWanderer - 11 legoboyvdlp - 9 Leche06 - 6 JayMillz - 5 Rolento - 4 Atliis - 4 Sithon - 3 Kaziocore - 3 Mandarijn - 3 sukmaindra9 - 3 1ceCream - 3 Whitebeard - 2 SaveStation - 2 Robert2424 - 1 Ferastical - 1

CC - 2017 Argus - 663 LS - 604 murphpk - 163 Rhizo - 155 RR - 138 ​Theophilos - 137 King Cankles - 128 ​​Hertt - 113 dagonslayer51 - 111 AngelCruzdelaSant - 87 Fermion - 77 brewersalliance- 69 welder - 48 George Jarvis - 46 MK - 46 Mazuurek - 19 Jarcine1221 - 18 Balacenia - 16 captainjf - 16 Lachiton - 15 spike2 - 14 myrrdin Emrys - 13 MorganFreeman - 13 Yamuna - 13 theWanderer - 11 legoboyvdlp - 9 Leche06 - 6 JayMillz - 5 Rolento - 4 Atliis - 4 Sithon - 3 Kaziocore - 3 Mandarijn - 3 sukmaindra9 - 3 1ceCream - 3 Whitebeard - 2 SaveStation - 2 Robert2424 - 1 Ferastical - 1

Happy Independence Day to our American brothers and sisters.

CC - 2017 Argus - 660 LS - 604 murphpk - 163 Rhizo - 155 RR - 138 ​Theophilos - 137 King Cankles - 123 ​​Hertt - 113 dagonslayer51 - 111 AngelCruzdelaSant - 87 Fermion - 77 brewersalliance- 68 welder - 48 George Jarvis - 46 MK - 46 Mazuurek - 19 Jarcine1221 - 18 Balacenia - 16 captainjf - 16 spike2 - 14 Lachiton - 14 myrrdin Emrys - 13 MorganFreeman - 13 Yamuna - 13 theWanderer - 11 legoboyvdlp - 9 Leche06 - 6 JayMillz - 5 Rolento - 4 Atliis - 4 Sithon - 3 Kaziocore - 3 Mandarijn - 3 sukmaindra9 - 3 1ceCream - 3 Whitebeard - 2 SaveStation - 2 Robert2424 - 1 Ferastical - 1