169 replies to this topic

[Kaziocore]

We're not even sure if there's a cop...

[Martino]

Yeah...I understood what you meant.

KevinH did that last game too (he turned out to be townie).
So I'm not quite sure what to make of it.

Good, maybe we've finally convinced him . Anyway, we are getting close to deadline so its time to get rid of my random vote.

unvote

A no lynch is not an option, so I'm voting for the one who I feel has contributed the least:

vote AKCPLUTO

His only contribution was a POS with no explanation.

[KevinH]

Vote: AKCPLUTO

He's as good a choice as any.
Besides, he pointed his pinky at me.

[AKCPLUTO]

I put my pinky out in light of Kevin changing his strategy, and going for a lynch this time around. It's only a pinky - nothing serious. In other words, I'm agreeing with Martino.

When is the deadline, again?

[Theophilos]

We're not even sure if there's a cop...

I would think there is a cop ... t'would be kinda unbalanced if there wasn't one.

[Narsis]

The "There is a Mod Here " VC:

AKCPluto: 3 - (Kaziocore, Martino, KevinH)
Martino: 2 - (Theophilos, Electric Mango)
Electric Mango: 1 - (CanucksDynasty)

Not Voting: 1 - (AKCPluto)


Also as a reminder the deadline will be whenever i get around to it Saturday morning(i.e. the morning of the 12th).

[AKCPLUTO]

Vote: Martino for overreacting to a pinky of suspicion.

[Electric Mango]

Vote: Martino for overreacting to a pinky of suspicion.

.....and not because it puts both of you at 3 votes?

[AKCPLUTO]

Well, that's extra.

[CanucksDynasty]

Unvote

I guess my vote is the tie-breaker.
Between the two I would have to....

Vote: AKCPLUTO

Little reasoning for his suspicions is a bit scummy for my taste.

[KevinH]

8. After someone has been lynched, discussion may continue until the end of the week. However no lynch may be undone during this period.

That's a lynch. Any discussion?

[Kaziocore]

AKCPluto: 4 - (Kaziocore, Martino, KevinH, Canucksdynasty)

So that means AKCPluto will be lynched.

Anyway between AKCPluto and Martino, I would really choose AKCPluto instead given the lack of information
because Martino is more experienced, I think, than him.

[Electric Mango]

Never thought I would see CD dropping the hammer vote. AKCPluto would have been lynched anyway since he was the first to reach 3 votes. I like CD's call, it gets the game moving quickly and it looks good for CD in my eyes. Why drop the hammer when he could have just sat back in the shadows. Well played good sir.

[Narsis]

The "Day 1 is Almost Done" VC:

AKCPluto: 4 - (Kaziocore, Martino, KevinH, CanucksDynasty)
Martino: 3 - (Theophilos, Electric Mango, AKCPluto)

Not Voting: 0


so AKC will die come tomorrow morning. this gives you approx. 24 hours to talk things over a bit more.

[AKCPLUTO]

Frankly, I point a pinky of suspicion at everyone, mentally, when the game starts. As I understand it, this game is a case of guilty until proven innocent.

I don't understand why CD voted for me, though...

[CanucksDynasty]

Frankly, I point a pinky of suspicion at everyone, mentally, when the game starts. As I understand it, this game is a case of guilty until proven innocent.

I don't understand why CD voted for me, though...

Nothing against you.
But between the 2...Martino seemed more townie.

[CanucksDynasty]

Never thought I would see CD dropping the hammer vote. AKCPluto would have been lynched anyway since he was the first to reach 3 votes. I like CD's call, it gets the game moving quickly and it looks good for CD in my eyes. Why drop the hammer when he could have just sat back in the shadows. Well played good sir.

You should know by now...I always pick a side (whether right or wrong).
I don't think it helps the town any by sitting on the sidelines.

[KevinH]

If AKCPluto is found to be scum, that will put a whole lot of suspicion on Theophilos and Electric Mango.

If he is found to be townie, then it's tougher to analyze.

[Theophilos]

If AKCPluto is found to be scum, that will put a whole lot of suspicion on Theophilos and Electric Mango.

Not really I think we both pointed to problematic nature of the pinky pointing ... I'd rather consider the 4th vote on AKC Pluto since it was "overkill", is CD doing more than just picking sides? Perhaps hiding the fact he's mafia?

[Martino]

If AKCPluto is found to be scum, that will put a whole lot of suspicion on Theophilos and Electric Mango.

If he is found to be townie, then it's tougher to analyze.

To be fair, considering the ease with which the bandwagon moved towards AKCPluto I'm not really optimistic about AKCPluto being scum. On the other hand, I wonder why he didn't just say he voted for me in order to try and save his own skin. If voting for him partly for his FOS was overreacting, then putting the third vote on him must have been even worse overreacting. So his vote shouldn't have gone to me. Of course, it makes sense that he votes me to save himself, but why not just be honest.

Anyway, if he is scum, I'd say it is between EM and Kazio. Theophilos was the first to question AKCPluto about his FOS, so that makes him a less likely scum budy. Kazio could have been distancing and the voting could have been too fast for him to unvote. I also wouldn't clear CD just yet. After all, AKCPluto would have been lynched even without his vote. On the other hand, if AKCPluto turns out to be a townie, I'd say that CD is a townie as well. I don't see why he would hammer as scum when the lynch was between two townies.