I have changed my mind.

 

Assuming CanucksDynasty, KevinH, and Martino are townie, which of the following gives the best information?

 

Molestargazer

Killed and townie -> Chaoshawk is scum

Killed and scum -> Kasabian is scum; Chaoshawk, Ccabal86, Kaziocore are townies

 

Chaoshawk

Killed and townie -> Molestargazer and Kasabian are scum

Killed and scum -> Molestargazer is townie

 

Ccabal86

Killed and townie -> nothing certain gained

Killed and scum -> Chaoshawk is scum; Kaziocore and Nerau are townie

 

Kaziocore

Killed and townie -> nothing certain is gained

Killed and scum -> Chaoshawk and Nerau are scum; Molestargazer, Ccabal86, Alasdair, and Kasabian are townie

 

Nerau

Killed and townie -> nothing certain is gained

Killed and scum -> Chaoshawl and Kaziocore are scum; Molestargazer, Ccabal86, Alasdair, and Kasabian are townie

 

Alasdair

Killed and townie -> nothing certain is gained

Killed and scum -> nothing certain is gained

 

Kasabian

Killed and townie -> Molestargazer is townie

Killed and scum -> Kaziocore is townie

 

Hint: Only one identifies a scum in both conditions.

 

Great you change your mind, you did it well, you wont regret for that change, believe me.

 

I don't know if the question above was for all, but im stepping in and say, i would go again for the options of kaziocore, CH or Nerau, i would go with lynching either Kazio or CH (botw higher post count from the 3 of them)

 

I also suggest an update before the deadline, what will be gained with that? easy more information that will lead to the real scums ,therefore, there won't be any townie dead.

Well I prefer the three choices without

nothing certain is gained

 

That would be Kasabian, Mole and CH

My vote is already on mole, so obviously I agree with KevinH. On top of this, both mole and Kasabian are the two most likely scum suspects at this time. Therefore, the option where lynching one as scum confirms the other as scum is highly attractive. And as KevinH noted, even if we turn out to be wrong about mole, it would still lead us to a scum. So it really is a win/win scenario as I would sacrifice a townie to find a scum any time (except Lylo obviously).

Kasabian, I don't want to put you at L-1 and risk a quicklynch. However, you are currently at L-2.

 

I'd like a roleclaim, please.

I still feel that making it to Day 4 is a priority.

However

Day 1 (7-3) no-lynch

Night 1 (7-3) failed night-kill

Day 2 (7-3) lynch based on current analysis -- worst case, we lynch a townie

Night 2 (6-3) townie night-killed

Day 3 (5-3) lynch based on more analysis -- virtually assured of lynching 1 scum

Night 3 (5-2) townie night-killed

Day 4 (4-2) lynch or lose but now there are three battlefield shifts to use

 

Unvote.

Vote: Molestargazer

 

The good of the many outweighs the good of the one.

I also suggest an update before the deadline, what will be gained with that? easy more information that will lead to the real scums ,therefore, there won't be any townie dead.

 

You do know that the update option was removed ages ago, right? If not, you really are out of the loop...That may well mean you're not lurking on purpouse.

Kasabian, I don't want to put you at L-1 and risk a quicklynch. However, you are currently at L-2.

 

I'd like a roleclaim, please.

 

Is this a hint from one scum to another?

Is this a hint from one scum to another?

 

If it was, would you really expect me to admit it? :facepalm:

 

No, of course it isn't. I want a roleclaim.

It was a rhetorical question.

 

I wouldn't expect you to admit it.

 

Is it just because Kasabian is in line to be lynched?

He might say he's the doc or a cop -- is that worth more than him saying he's a townie?

Kasabian, I don't want to put you at L-1 and risk a quicklynch. However, you are currently at L-2.

 

I'd like a roleclaim, please.

 

It's okay, if i get lynched, the scums will be cornered as they have voted for me already so they will be an easy target.

 

You and your men are one of the best groups of medics there is...

i agree that right now it seems to be between kasabian and mole with kasabain being the stronger choice

 

i also agree with how kevinH has laid stuff out

 

You and your men are one of the best groups of medics there is...

 

are you trying to hint that you are doc maybe?

 

also a quick lynch gets us less than letting the disscussion to continue to drag out so i am holding my vote

 

are you trying to hint that you are doc maybe?

 

your guys can't patch themselves up if they are under attack...

your guys can't patch themselves up if they are under attack...

 

Good god. :facepalm:

I sincerely hope you did not quote your pm role...as you will most likely be mod-killed.

 

Since you strongly hinted that you are doc...would you mind telling us whom you protected?

My friend how many times you want me to say it, im a townie, i've always been playing pro-town. If i get lynched you'll see im saying the true. I know im in a few combinations but CH is too, im in 3 combinations, he is in 3, mole is in just two, so you might consider my option that the scums are the combination of CH, nerau and kaziocore.

 

 

Dude...if you were mafia...you'd be claiming you are townie...just like you are doing right now.

Would you really say...I'm mafia so don't vote for me?

 

Reasons for voting for you...

1. You clearly haven't been following the game.

2. I strongly suspect mole as mafia and your 5th vote ensured he would not get lynched.

3. You are really defensive...a trait I normally see with mafia players.

4. You guessed the wrong page of the hint I saw...(maybe you're just a townie that guessed wrong?)

Good god. :facepalm:

I sincerely hope you did not quote your pm role...as you will most likely be mod-killed.

 

Since you strongly hinted that you are doc...would you mind telling us whom you protected?

 

I was careful at it.

 

I protected the same guy that didn't thank me for saving him.

 

Dude...if you were mafia...you'd be claiming you are townie...just like you are doing right now.

Would you really say...I'm mafia so don't vote for me?

 

Reasons for voting for you...

1. You clearly haven't been following the game.

2. I strongly suspect mole as mafia and your 5th vote ensured he would not get lynched.

3. You are really defensive...a trait I normally see with mafia players.

4. You guessed the wrong page of the hint I saw...(maybe you're just a townie that guessed wrong?)

 

the reason number 1 is going for you too, i have been leaving hints over my last post and you haven't figured out.

for the 2)i was voting true my bb , i didn't even read the other post, or read who was the guy that was going to get lynched, i just voted no-lynch because i didn't had proof againts anyone else.

for the 3) Im a bit defensive all the time, that doesn't indicate that im a mafia, that's how i play.

for the 4) Im just a townie that guessed wrong thats all

 

See you guys then tonight, will be going for work and i won't be able to post from there.

OK, Kasabian's town. Damn.

Kasabian, if that was a direct quote

not only were you not reading some of the posts, you were also not reading the rules :facepalm:

 

Unvote

 

I protected the same guy that didn't thank me for saving him.

 

I see but it doesn't mean that Mole may be scum since you protected somebody else.

Alasdair seems to be MIA :​|

Alasdair seems to be MIA :​|

 

yeah seems so. i'll give him until i get home tonight to show up and contribute or he'll get replaced...

 

as for Kasabian's claim: he asked me beforehand if what he posted was ok and i said yes.

 

Edit: not saying he actually is the doc though.

Edited September 20, 201016 yr by Narsis

Since no one counter claims Kasabian's role...

 

I'm going back to my D1 suspect.

 

Unvote

Vote: Molestargazer.

Since no one counter claims Kasabian's role...

 

I'm going back to my D1 suspect.

 

Unvote

Vote: Molestargazer.

For a moment assuming that Kasabian is lying, I would hope our doc has more sense than to counterclaim. Should the real doc die somewhere in the process, we can then proceed to lynch Kasabian. No reason to sacrifice himself tonight.

 

Anyway, assuming the scum didn't set up this claim pretty brilliantly, I'm going to believe him. There is a doc, so the claim is far too dangerous otherwise.

unvote.

 

So back to scum hunting. There are/were some interesting things going on, so I'm not going to meddle too much at this point. But I will bring forth a new lynch target.

vote Nerau

 

He was not trying to hint he was the doc, that was a clear claim. Anyway, I especially didn't like the tentative choice you made. Sure you agreed with what the town was about to do (lynch our doc) but you were not willing to commit. Sounds a little convenient too me. Especially considering Kasabian just claimed doc and you still thought him the better choice for a lynch target.

I like the Molestargazer/Chaoshawk pair. One is scum, the other is not.

KevinH list...

 

• Molestargazer + Alasdair + Kasabian = 43
  
• Molestargazer + Nerau + Kasabian = 44
  
• Chaoshawk + Ccabal86 + Kasabian = 43
  
• Chaoshawk + Ccabal86 + Alasdair = 44
  
• Chaoshawk + Kaziocore + Nerau = 43
  

 

Well since Kasa roleclaimed doc...the math no longer supports that mole is mafia (provided that the post counts are correct/valid).

So if Kasa and mole are townie...then I would focus on this group.

 

Chaoshawk + Ccabal86 + Alasdair = 44

 

When the mid-day update was still an option...both Chaoshawk and Ccabal86 ramped up their post counts.

Both then wanted the update after they posted some more.

 

My first post count on pg 3 and I mentioned about requesting an update ASAP a few posts later...

 

1. molestargazer - 2+4+

2. Chaoshawk - 2+1+

3. CanucksDynasty - 7+1+2

4. Nerau - 0+2+

5. ccabal86 - 0+2+

6. KevinH - 2+4+2

7. Kasabian - 0+2+

8. Alasdair - 0+0+

9. Martino - 0+0+1

10. Kaziocore - 0+1+1

 

Now let's take a look at the recent post per page...

 

1. molestargazer - 2+4+2+0+3+0

2. Chaoshawk - 2+1+1+1+3+1

3. CanucksDynasty - 7+1+7+4+2+1

4. Nerau - 0+2+0+1+2+0

5. ccabal86 - 0+2+2+2+0+2

6. KevinH - 2+4+2+2+4+2

7. Kasabian - 0+2+0+2+1+0

8. Alasdair - 0+0+2+1+0+0

9. Martino - 0+0+1+1+2+0

10. Kaziocore - 0+1+1+3+2+0

 

 

Difference of...

1. molestargazer +5

2. Chaoshawk +6

3. CanucksDynasty +12

4. Nerau +3

5. ccabal86 +6

6. KevinH +8

7. Kasabian +3

8. Alasdair +3

9. Martino +3

10. Kaziocore +5

 

 

Not to mention that they both bandwagoned voted Kasa (with the 3rd and 4th vote).

Perhaps this time they needed/wanted a lynch?

Perhaps instead of Alasdair...I would possibly go with this combo (if some posts were not included, etc)...

 

Chaoshawk + Ccabal86 + Nerau = 45

yeah seems so. i'll give him until i get home tonight to show up and contribute or he'll get replaced...

 

as for Kasabian's claim: he asked me beforehand if what he posted was ok and i said yes.

 

Edit: not saying he actually is the doc though.

 

Sorry guys, RL got in the way. Lots of drama with work and trying to find a new job.

 

What'd I miss? :P