what's today? mmm lets see 22 and when is the deadline? mmm is it 26? yep it is, that day or the day before i'll place my vote.

 

I find it quite odd that you haven't voted for CH since he's mafia as you claim.

 

Was i suppose to tell i was the doctor then?

 

No...but as I said before...you're claiming doc was to save your own skin and possibly force the real doc into counter-claiming.

 

go ahead and lynch me my friend, as i told you before, for more experience you may have within the mafia game, you'r wrong!

 

But your death (if townie) will ensure that mafia will be lynch the next day.

And if you're mafia...then kudos to me.

 

We will know the truth when the lynch happens.

Fact: One of you is lying (Kasa or CH).

Fact: CH correctly identified the winning % on the battlefield for townies (or close enough to avoid a mod-kill).

Fact: CH voted for Kasa

Fact: Kasa voted NO-LYNCH!!!!

 

Why on earth would a townie not vote for a known mafia?

 

 

Kasa mentioned that he dropped hints that he was medic before being asked to roleclaim. He was already getting 4 votes before he dropped the hints. Perhaps this was his way to save his own hide. I saw no hints in his previous posts on D1.

I think you're putting a little too much trust into that part. The winning % was more or less known to everybody after I explained why I picked p.3 for KevinH's hint.

 

@KevinH not necessarily. If we lynch Kasabian and he turns out to be scum, I'm sure they'll kill CH tonight and vice versa. The more interesting choice comes when we go for a no lynch. Then I believe they are still forced to take out our doc or risk our cop roaming free at nights. But they may decide that giving away which of CH/Kasa is the doc put them at a too great disadvantage and kill one of us/CD. I'm still inclined to force the scum to make the difficult decision for us.

But your death (if townie) will ensure that mafia will be lynch the next day.

And we'll have a dead cop by the morning. It's a rather important side effect.

• Molestargazer + Alasdair + Kasabian = 43
  
• Molestargazer + Nerau + Kasabian = 44
  
• Chaoshawk + Ccabal86 + Kasabian = 43
  
• Chaoshawk + Ccabal86 + Alasdair = 44
  
• Chaoshawk + Kaziocore + Nerau = 43
  

If Kasabian is scum (and Chaoshawk is townie by competing doc claim), then Molestargazer must be scum.

If Kasabian is townie, then Chaoshawk must be scum.

 

If we lynch Mole, the doc will definitely be alive.

If the mafia kills the doc, we would probably have certain knowledge of scum.

And we'll have a dead cop by the morning. It's a rather important side effect.

 

Are you saying that mafia knows who the cop is?

Are you saying that mafia knows who the cop is?

IF Kasabian is our doc, then I believe so yes.

@Everyone - What is your take on the situation?

I'm feeling oblivious.

 

I don't see how Kasabian being the doc reveals the cop.

 

Maybe Kasabian and Chaoshawk are both scum and they hope that the death of one puts implicit trust in the other.

I think you're putting a little too much trust into that part. The winning % was more or less known to everybody after I explained why I picked p.3 for KevinH's hint.

 

I'm inclined to agree with this statement and about people catching the 'hint' from the day before. Nonetheless Kasabian forced the situation of conflicting docs by claiming my role as we was being lynched. Also, Canucks the cop has been lying hints himself about his role for a while now so I wouldn't be surprised they would know.

 

I personally believe lynching molestar, at this point, does make sense and keeps the doctor alive for certain in the next day by the reasoning they wouldn't want to immediately out their own man between us two. However, a mafia roleblocker (as mentioned earlier) could simply block me from saving from then on now they that the real doc has been outted or kill me if they can not do that. A stalker would be just as bad and our cop would be even less safe.

 

I'd also like to hear opinions of people such as ccbal, Nerau and Alasadair who have been lingering and not adding to this for a while or when they do post they simply repeat what has been said or nothing worth knowing.

I'm feeling oblivious.

 

I don't see how Kasabian being the doc reveals the cop.

 

Maybe Kasabian and Chaoshawk are both scum and they hope that the death of one puts implicit trust in the other.

 

I reviewed the posts and could not see where a cop would be revealed as well.

It could be that I don't see what Martino sees.

No one else but Martino and you have advocated a no-lynch.

AND I extremely doubt that either of you are the cop.

 

Highly doubtful that both are scum and both are claiming doc.

Otherwise the real doc would know both are lying.

I'd also like to hear opinions of people such as ccbal, Nerau and Alasadair who have been lingering and not adding to this for a while or when they do post they simply repeat what has been said or nothing worth knowing.

 

That's because you guys are doing all the work for us, keep doing what you're doing :speak_cool: In reality, I'm very busy these days, don't have much time go give this a lot of thought.

 

I am quite confident at this point however that mole and Kasa are scum.

That won't matter if the doc never says a peep and ultimately is anti-town. It's an odd theoretical situation and does not seem to be the case.

IF Kasabian is our doc, then I believe so yes.

 

Will the answer be NO if Kasabian is not the doc?

That's because you guys are doing all the work for us, keep doing what you're doing :speak_cool: In reality, I'm very busy these days, don't have much time go give this a lot of thought.

 

I am quite confident at this point however that mole and Kasa are scum.

 

Not exactly a good habit to fall into (if you can help it) I understand.

Highly doubtful that both are scum and both are claiming doc.

Otherwise the real doc would know both are lying.

 

I doubt it, too, but it would be a really good play. Maybe there is no doc.

 

Attacks, counterattacks, feints, and flanking...none of it seems to work anymore.

 

Maybe there is more going on than I know. I'll role-claim that I am just a vanilla townie. Trust me on this.

I doubt it, too, but it would be a really good play. Maybe there is no doc.

 

Attacks, counterattacks, feints, and flanking...none of it seems to work anymore.

 

Maybe there is more going on than I know. I'll role-claim that I am just a vanilla townie. Trust me on this.

 

If it's D4 and you haven't been nightkilled.

You must be scum

 

Unless you're a clever mafia...then I would have assumed you were a vanilla townie anyways.

(Note: I only checked that the tally was correct and not the math)

(Note: I only checked that the tally was correct and not the math)

 

The proof is left as an exercise for the interested student.

this how i see it

 

like i said before someone is lying but information is gained no matter the outcome so the result will be the same

Will the answer be NO if Kasabian is not the doc?

I won't know if Kasabian is not the doc. The mafia has a little more information, so they may still know. Which is another part of the reason I for a moment suggested a cop roleclaim, to even out the information between us.

 

The thing is though, that it seems like I was the only one to read some comments a certain way. I would have to go back and reread the last few pages to see if my initial feeling is right, but I won't have enough time before Saturday.

I won't know if Kasabian is not the doc. The mafia has a little more information, so they may still know. Which is another part of the reason I for a moment suggested a cop roleclaim, to even out the information between us.

 

The thing is though, that it seems like I was the only one to read some comments a certain way. I would have to go back and reread the last few pages to see if my initial feeling is right, but I won't have enough time before Saturday.

 

 

I don't think you are the only one.

It seems that CH thinks the cop dropped some hints.

I had a look and I think I know who you all are talking about.

 

Regardless...I still think that lynching one of them (preferably Kasa) is the best course of action.

It will lead to 1 dead mafia and 1 dead doc (and a dead townie via nightkill if we mislynch).

Going on a little trip this weekend (Friday to Monday).

So I'll be back on Tuesday.

I'll try to log on at the hotel but I sincerely doubt I get th

Going on a little trip this weekend (Friday to Monday).

So I'll be back on Tuesday.

I'll try to log on at the hotel but I sincerely doubt I get th

 

Have fun! I'll be busy, too, but it's for work.

While I'm pretty sure that Kasa is scum...since I am gone and will have limited access....I don't know if I'll be able to respond to scummy posts on deadline.

Therefore I will unvote and hope the rest of the town can pick up the slack in my absence.

 

Unvote

Yeah we'll figure out how to get the ball rolling without two of the active townies

I'm sure I can get in a couple posts per day but it might be 12 hours between them. Reduced activity is all relative.