Whoa, wait a minute. You SAW Chaos stab someone and DIDN'T blow the whistle?

 

Now this is awfully suspicious...

 

i agree.

 

even so i think it is in our best interest to "lynch" one of them tonight. the question is which one and how exactly to go about it.

 

(also yeah nice catch on ChaosHawk EM...i totally missed that)

Whoa, wait a minute. You SAW Chaos stab someone and DIDN'T blow the whistle?

 

Now this is awfully suspicious...

Well i didnt do it at first because I didnt want the mafia to attack me because last time i blew the whistle in the game like this I died straightaway, but if ya saw in my earlier posts i kept on saying keep your eyes on choas without directly saying it, plus at the time i thought we werent suppose to quote or say anything from our pms directly or something. Tis why I was confused but then martino cleared it up. Once again I apologize. But I can most assure you that I saw him and urged people to get him, as it seems one person listened to me since a mage attacked him.

Well i didnt do it at first because I didnt want the mafia to attack me because last time i blew the whistle in the game like this I died straightaway, but if ya saw in my earlier posts i kept on saying keep your eyes on choas without directly saying it, plus at the time i thought we werent suppose to quote or say anything from our pms directly or something. Tis why I was confused but then martino cleared it up. Once again I apologize. But I can most assure you that I saw him and urged people to get him, as it seems one person listened to me since a mage attacked him.

 

except for the fact that mafia have essentially no way to kill you immediately. unless they all got in the same room with you and had some sort of super weapons or something i cant really think of a way for them to do 10 damage to you in a single night.

 

and even then we'd know they were with you in the room which would greatly narrow down who it is.

Ok, then.

 

I'm in favor of "lynching" Either Chaoshawk or 19thSpecOps tonight. So, the question is how do we do it then? Multiple attacks during the night could work, but it might be dangerous to group together like that.

heh figures. well I suggest not to lynch me because you be wasting your time plus killing a friendly here. Clearly in the first night i posted only one action to watch people, choas never posted. at that time there was only three people in the room, now before the entire healing thing i saw that someone had hit per. aka EM and it was choas because he ran to stab per. as for the second night i watched choas because i wanted to make sure it was him the second time around and not an innocent bystander but someone hit choas which was a mage plus the report of EM saying he was stabbed once again. the second time i only saw the mage attack chaos and not him stabbing per. but then again there goes that chance thing that gets thrown into the mix. Either way I did nothing through the night cept watch people. So I have to say that you would seriously be wasting your time lynching me. Thats what the mafia would want.

Ok, then.

 

I'm in favor of "lynching" Either Chaoshawk or 19thSpecOps tonight. So, the question is how do we do it then? Multiple attacks during the night could work, but it might be dangerous to group together like that.

 

what i was thinking was grouping together 5 or 6 people in a room with him and have them all attack him. whether that takes one night or two or whatever would depend on item usage i believe.

 

although that may be a bit high...we could go lower(like 3) but then it'd take longer.

I believe SpecOps story over Chaoshawk and am sticking with my original assumption that Chaoshawk is mafia.

 

I propose either:

 

1. Tthe two of us who were attacked and the two who healed us should be the ones to do the "lynching", with chaoshawk being the 5th person in the room. This way we could have a clear 4 vs 1 townie advantage without risking putting all of our eggs in one basket, as Martino warned us not to do. The only problem is that we may not be able to inflict all of the damage necessary to finish him off. I'm guessing without a weapon we will inflict 1 damage per person. It may take 2 nights to do it.

 

OR

 

2. Alternatively we could keep everyone in the same rooms so that the mage could attack him again doing 3 damage and the rest of us could attack him as well, all but guaranteeing a night kill. We had a big group together last night and nothing bad happened so we would probably be safe again tonight.

 

God, I missed playing mafia

I believe SpecOps story over Chaoshawk and am sticking with my original assumption that Chaoshawk is mafia.

 

I propose either:

 

1. Tthe two of us who were attacked and the two who healed us should be the ones to do the "lynching", with chaoshawk being the 5th person in the room. This way we could have a clear 4 vs 1 townie advantage without risking putting all of our eggs in one basket, as Martino warned us not to do. The only problem is that we may not be able to inflict all of the damage necessary to finish him off. I'm guessing without a weapon we will inflict 1 damage per person. It may take 2 nights to do it.

 

OR

 

2. Alternatively we could keep everyone in the same rooms so that the mage could attack him again doing 3 damage and the rest of us could attack him as well, all but guaranteeing a night kill. We had a big group together last night and nothing bad happened so we would probably be safe again tonight.

 

God, I missed playing mafia

It makes sense that we can keep the same people in the room, so as to not cause any more confusion of who is gonna get who if ya follow me here, because other scum could enter. It probably would be safer to stay together in the lobby and go after chaos tonight along with the mage, I was going to attack chaos whether anyone believed me or not. but thank you em for believing hopefully this would go right.

Well, I am willing to give 19thSpecOps the benefit of doubt this time and go for Chaoshawk first.

Follow Chaoshawk

Its lynching time folks D:

Move: Main Lobby

Follow Chaoshawk

The case against chaoshawk is very strong. I totally smell a rat here. To quote a TV series called "Yes, Minister," we need to call in the health inspector to deal with the rats in the office, LOL.

 

Follow Chaoshawk

Follow Chaoshawk ... gotta eliminate the threat to us townies!

Well that works perfectly for the mafia. Now they get the opportunity to attack one of my assailants without worry of being watched at all. I'm not sure how to make you believe me nor do I know who attacked me last night but no one seems to care about that and be damned who did so. Mango you did a great job of narrowing it down but sadly you're charging for the wrong guy in this case. I hope this mistake does not cost you all much.

Chaos, if you're a townie and we do kill you, I promise to dump some of my 40 ounce beer on the ground in your honor. Plus, if the town wins, you still win even though you're dead.

 

I hope you keep coming back to play with us game after game, it's a lot of fun, especially when we get to play with new people.

Chaos, if you're a townie and we do kill you, I promise to dump some of my 40 ounce beer on the ground in your honor. Plus, if the town wins, you still win even though you're dead.

 

I hope you keep coming back to play with us game after game, it's a lot of fun, especially when we get to play with new people.

 

i dont think you need to worry about him not coming back. this is his third game with us i believe.

There is something to note however: Chaos was given a mafia role in the past 2 games if I recall correctly. What are the odds of him being given such a role for the thrid time in a row?

There is something to note however: Chaos was given a mafia role in the past 2 games if I recall correctly. What are the odds of him being given such a role for the thrid time in a row?

 

that my friend is known as the Gambler's Fallacy. the idea that since something has or hasn't happened several times in a row means it's due to not happen or happen.

 

so yeah the odds are the same as anyone getting a mafia role this game.

Hm, I see it's bandwagon time and all, but ...

 

Firstly as I'm a little late with my post on this day. I used the night to search the room in which I was located but due to lights out, came up short and found nothing.

 

Secondly ... Is it possible Chao found an item or had it from the start as a townie and made a random attempt on his first night? I mean I agree the preponderance of the evidence is against him, but he also makes a good point. We seem to be rushing here just a bit too much.

Certainly hope he's not a townie...but im pretty sure he's mob material in this game....ya just don't go randomly attacking people at will...just hope were not doing wrong here..I know im playing a double edge sword here but im gonna have to go wit my gut and go after choas on this one..

 

Nothing personal its just business. Follow choas

Hopefully I don't sprain my ankles falling off the bandwagon here....!

Hm, I see it's bandwagon time and all, but ...

 

Firstly as I'm a little late with my post on this day. I used the night to search the room in which I was located but due to lights out, came up short and found nothing.

 

Secondly ... Is it possible Chao found an item or had it from the start as a townie and made a random attempt on his first night? I mean I agree the preponderance of the evidence is against him, but he also makes a good point. We seem to be rushing here just a bit too much.

 

 

Theo,

 

I was attacked day 1. There were only 2 people who could have done it. If it wasn't Chaos then it was SpecOps. We know this for sure so it's not too early at all for the town to take action. Why wait for the mafia to keep picking us off. Like I said, the worst we can do is kill one mafia and one townie, those seem like great odds to me. It's also funny that you are the only one against the lynch as you are also one of the other two people who are under suspicion from the other room.

 

Coincidence? Time will tell my friend.

I like it at the front. When necessary we can quote it into thread.

 

I find it easier to know I can find it at the beginning rather than have to scroll back to find it.

 

MOD: Can the positions of each player be shown before D1 and D2 end and for subsequent days?

I read EM's posts and find CH suspicious.

His reason for saying the word "stab" is funny.

You can bleed from lots of things but it's too convenient that he thought about stabbing.

 

So what's the plan in lynching CH?

How many should follow him?