funniest death ever;

now does anyone have any guess on the reason Aenir was chosen?

One would normally put suspicion on those that voted to lynch the townie. By killing off one of those voters, the scum has increased the chances that they would be targeted for a lynch.

 

Unless ... maybe none of the scum voted for the townie and they aren't worried about getting lynched because of voting for a townie.

 

Or maybe it's a big "Wine In Front Of Me" situation where they just want us to think that they didn't vote for a townie.

 

So basically, we don't know nothin'.

 

Vote: No-lynch

funniest death ever;

now does anyone have any guess on the reason Aenir was chosen?

 

From what I read from the death note wiki it seems that Aenir had some kinda investigative role, so it seems that the scum are going after any people with investigative abilities or it might be that they put all names in a hat, picked one up and decided to get rid of it.

 

Now, I think it would be a safe assumption that there are 3 scum but if there are 4 of them then we are getting pretty close to LYLO.

 

... maybe none of the scum voted for the townie and they aren't worried about getting lynched because of voting for a townie.

 

 

 

 

FoS:

KevinH (2): Fernando Garcia, Xarastier

No Lynch (2): d3mon, Alternate_Tree

 

Not Voting (2): cam177, Electric Mango

FoS:

Electric Mango

 

 

He is almost always in favor of lynching, but when he saw us lynching Xarastier he chose to vote No lynch. The only way I can see this reversal in voting pattern/play style is that he knew that Xarastier was not scum, and therefore chose to abstain from voting to lynch him to appear townie. Also, having a townie who wants to lynch at random would benefit the scum immensly as it would throw us into confusion. Out of everything I've been able to peace together through the information I have available, this is my best guess at who the scum is.

 

I will however withhold my vote until an explanation is given.

i also want to place a FOS on athermonuke for the last 2 posts. they kind'a look like gloating to me...

So did they have any power roles? Seems like MOD is only posting their names and not what roles they had. Unless both xarastier and aenir were just vanilla townies.

I am not gloating. I am very much confused. I try to piece together puzzles and thought I was starting to see patterns but this pretty much throws a wrench in all that.

I put more suspicion on the lurkers.

 

I totally understand that game play will be altered because of holidays, but it would be an easy way for scum to hide.

So i noticec that there is a significant amount of discussion between all of us except Cam177 and Alternate_Tree. They are pretty much unknowns at this point and i find it interesting that those two have been very quiet while two death notes have been picking us off.

btw, i keep a tab open on all the IRON threads I frequent so I don't forget to go to them =S. So if you see me reading this topic between 0900 -1800 CN time, I'm probably not on.

Sorry again for not talking much, I got the stomach flu on Friday and am just recovering, so I haven't had my mind on this game, but I don't have any insights I can offer, I am very confused as to who could have the death notes, but it is seeming we have to get a lynch that isn't just the time running out because the scum are gaining a large advantage.

Unvote.

 

FoS:

KevinH (2): Fernando Garcia, Xarastier

No Lynch (2): d3mon, Alternate_Tree

Not Voting (2): cam177, Electric Mango

 

Day 2 posts:

5 Athermonuke

5 KevinH

2 killgor

2 d3mon

1 Fernando Garcia

1 Chaplain of death

1 Alternate_Tree

1 Imran Ehsan

0 Electric Mango

0 Xx Karl xX

0 cam177

 

Vote: cam177

i'm still waiting to see who bites the dust today.

Oh man, I'm not liking that list you put up Kevin, kinda paints me in a bad light haha. But honestly I don't have any info to share as my townie role is more reactive i guess since it only takes effect once something is done to me. But I guess in the interest of getting inactives to post more, vote: electric mango

It makes for a boring game if nobody has anything to say.

 

I'll start.

 

I was invited into into yet another thread (I'm so popular).

 

While I have no additional information regarding whether anyone is scum or not, I tend to trust those with whom I've had night contact.

meh... nobody wans to take me out... fos you all...

I am with KevinH. He seems to be in the best position to know who is scum and who is not. To add to that, Cam177 has consistently stayed in the dark and has not given any way of seeing who he is via conversation or debate. Alternate_Tree at least has good reasons as to why he has not been big in discussing. vote: Cam177

Sorry for the inactivity, I've had a lot of relatives come back in town for the holidays and my evenings have been filled up doing family activities. Anyways.... I tend to think that more scum did NOT vote to lynch our townie than did. I agree with Kevin in regards that scum did not need to vote for him because so many other people were hopping on the bandwagon.

 

Kevin's FOS list is the same one that I am starting out with. I'm going to read through all of our posts from Day 1 before making a vote.

Merry Christmas and Happy Holidays!!!!

i hate christmas....

oh...sorry to hear that =(

I love Christmas!

 

(although you have to wonder when I wake up and check the mafia thread first ...)

gotta say, hating christmas sounds like scum... Anyways, Merry Christmas to all

Merry Christmas everyone!