Only  3 people left alive who did not vote to lynch scum yesterday and Rafay has been cleared by our cop as being a townie.  That leaves just Imran Ehsan and Noahband.  

 

Vote:  Imran Ehsan

 

Vote count:
Alternate_Tree (4): Lorikz Kain, Electric Mango, Xx Karl xX, Xarastier
Xarastier (4): Rafay, Imran Ehsan, D3mon, Alternate_Tree

No-Lynch (0):

Not voting (1): Noahband
 

noahband and imran are the most likely scum based on the facts. Of the  4 who didnt vote to lynch the scum d3mon was killed, rafay was cleared by the cop and that leaves just imran and the inactive noah.

 

plus if you read alternates post before he was lynched he praises Imran calling him a voice of reason.

Followiing EM's lead:

Vote Imran Ehsan  

"Sorry! I don't want any adventures, thank you. Not Today. Good morning! But please come to tea -any time you like! Why not tomorrow? Good bye!”

― J.R.R. Tolkien, The Hobbit

 

Vote count:

Imran Ehsan (3): Lorikz Kain, Electric Mango, Xarastier

Noahband (1): Rafay

 

No-Lynch (0):

 

Not voting (3): Noahband, Xx Karl xX, Imran Ehsan

 

It is Day 4. Deadline is Friday, March 8 at 0600.

 

With 7 alive, it takes 4 to lynch, or 2 at deadline.

Well since every1 has made up their minds. Sorry Imran...

 

 

Unvote: Noahband

 

Vote: Imran Ehsan.

Tarry Lorikz. I think it's still too quick too jump on Imran or any1 else lets just re read the facts and instead of a playing member let's lynch some1 non-contributing like

 

Vote: noahband

 Rafay, change your vote to Imran Ehsan so we can win and get on with it    

Aright then, lets hope we finally pinned the nail on this scummy coffin.

 

Vote: Imran

"Surely you don’t disbelieve the prophecies, because you had a hand in bringing them about yourself? You don’t really suppose, do you, that all your adventures and escapes were managed by mere luck, just for your sole benefit? You are a very fine person, Mr. Baggins, and I am very fond of you; but you are only quite a little fellow in a wide world after all!”
― J.R.R. Tolkien, The Hobbit

Vote count:
Imran Ehsan (4): Lorikz Kain, Electric Mango, Xarastier, Rafay

No-Lynch (0):

Not voting (3): Noahband, Xx Karl xX, Imran Ehsan
 
Imran Ehsan (Azog, the Goblin Doctor) has been lynched.

It is now Night 4. Deadline is Monday, March 4 at 1700.

"'Why O why did I ever leave my hobbit-hole?' said poor Mr. Baggins, bumping up and down on Bombur's back."
― J.R.R. Tolkien, The Hobbit

The Company lost another member.
Electric Mango (Fili, the Mason and member of the Company) was killed in the night.

It is now Day 5. Deadline is Saturday, March 9 at 1200.

With 5 alive, it takes 3 to lynch, or 2 at deadline.

Vote: Noahband

vote: Noahband

vote: noahband

Vote count:
 

Noahband (3): Rafay , Lorikz Kain, Xx Karl xX

Not voting (2): Noahband, Xarastier


"The King beneath the mountains,
The King of carven stone,
The lord of silver fountains
Shall come into his own!

His crown shall be upholden,
His harp shall be restrung,
His halls shall echo golden
To songs of yore re-sung.

The woods shall wave on mountains.
And grass beneath the sun;
His wealth shall flow in fountains
And the rivers golden run.

The streams shall run in gladness,
The lakes shall shine and burn,
And sorrow fail and sadness
At the Mountain-king’s return!"
― J.R.R. Tolkien, The Hobbit

Noahband (Bolg, Goblin Odd-Night Tracker) has been lynched.

The Company wins!

 

Rafay: You are Gandalf, the Cop.

Each night you may investigate a player to see if they are a Goblin. You win when the Company controls the game.

 

 

 

 

Kaziocore: You are Bilbo Baggins, the Compulsive Hider.

Each night you must name a player and will be treated like that player for all other roles' purposes. If you hide with a Goblin, you will die. You win when the Company controls the game.

 

 

 

 

D3mon: You are Thorin Oakenshield, the Role Cop.

Each night you may investigate a player and be told their role. Note that any role could be Goblin-aligned. You win when the Company controls the game.

 

 

 

 

Killgor: You are Balin, the Even-Night Tracker.

On even-numbered nights, you may name a player and be told if they perform an action on another player. You win when the Company controls the game.

 

 

 

 

Electric Mango: You are Fili, the Mason.

At night you may talk with Kili, the other Mason. You win when the Company controls the game.

 

 

 

 

Lorikz Kain: You are Kili, the Mason.

At night you may talk with Fili, the other Mason. You win when the Company controls the game.

 

 

 

 

Xx Karl xX: You are Dori, the One-shot Bulletproof Miller.

The first time the Goblins try to kill you, you will live. If investigated by the cop, you will show as a Goblin. You win when the Company controls the game.

 

 

 

 

Xarastier: You are Nori, the Odd-Night Watcher.

On odd-numbered nights, you may name a player and be told of any other players that perform actions on the the player you named. You win when the Company controls the game.

 

 

 

 

Chaplain of Death: You are Ori, the Non-Consecutive Night Jailer.

You may target a player at night and that player will be protected from kills and also be roleblocked. You may not use your ability two nights in a row. You win when the Company controls the game.

 

 

 

 

Alternate_Tree: You are Great Goblin, the Goblin Godfather.

You are scum along with Bolg and Azog. If investigated, you will appear as a Vanilla Dwarf and part of the Company. You are the final arbiter of whom the Goblins kill and which of you makes the kill. You may safely claim to be Oin. You win when the Goblins control the game.

 

 

 

 

Noahband: You are Bolg, the Goblin Odd-Night Tracker.

You are scum along with Great Goblin and Azog. A cop will investigate you as a Goblin; a role cop will investigate you as an Odd-Night Tracker. If the Godfather does not make you deliver a kill, on odd-numbered nights you may target a player and see if they perform an action on another player. You may safely claim to be Dwalin. You win when the Goblins control the game.

 

 

 

 

Imran Ehsan: You are Azog, the Goblin Doctor.

You are scum along with Great Goblin and Bolg. A cop will investigate you as a Goblin; a role cop will investigate you as a Doctor. If the Godfather does not make you deliver a kill, you may target a player at night and protect them. There is not a vigilante in the game. You may safely claim to be Gloin. You win when the Goblins control the game.

Edited March 5, 201313 yr by KevinH

Day 1

• No Lynch

Night 1

• Rafay investigated Electric Mango
• Kaziocore hid with Rafay
• D3mon role investigated Kaziocore (failed on Hider)
• Xarastier watched Kaziocore (failed on Hider)
• Noahband tracked Kaziocore (failed on Hider)
• Chaplain of Death jailed Electric Mango
• Imran Ehsan killed Killgor

Day 2

• Kaziocore was lynched

Night 2

• Rafay investigated Chaplain of Death
• D3mon role investigated Rafay
• Imran Ehsan protected Electric Mango
• Noahband killed Chaplain of Death

Day 3

• Alternate_Tree was lynched

Night 3

• Rafay investigated Xarastier
• Xarastier watched Electric Mango
• D3mon role investigated Xx Karl xX
• Imran Ehsan killed D3mon

Day 4

• Imran Ehsan was lynched

Night 4

• Rafay investigated Noahband
• Noahband killed Electric Mango

Day 5

• Noahband was lynched

(Townies win)

Moderator comments:

This didn't play out like I thought, but it seemed balanced nonetheless.
The town had numerous investigative roles but the scum had roles that would confuse the investigators.

• The cop could have investigated the godfather and found him town or investigated the miller and thought him scum.
• The role cop could have found a doctor or a tracker that were really scum.
• The townie watchers and trackers could have seen scum perform actions that didn't kill and thus seem town.
• None of this happened

Some surprises:

• Kaziocore didn't role claim and clear Rafay before he was lynched.
• The masons were allowed to live after role-claiming.
• On Day 3 D3mon had 3 townie votes on him and could have been lynched with 2 of the 3 scum piling on.
• D3mon claimed "cop" vs "role cop" and Rafay (also cop) didn't challenge it at all.
• Later Day 3, Noahband didn't vote when Xarastier could have been lynched.

 

"A safe fairyland is untrue to all worlds."
― J.R.R. TolkienThe Hobbit

Really interesting game Kevin.  I liked reading your surprises and some of the twists that you had possible in the game that never happened.  I was wondering why Imran would protect me since I'm town and he was mafia, but it makes sense that he would do it so the watcher could witness him targetting me without me being night killed.  I also thought the game was well balanced and fun to play.  It was close until the end when we voted for Alternative_Tree.  Then it was pretty obvious who the other two were based on voting patterns and d3mons clearing of Rafay as a townie.

Yeah, we should have taken out the two confirmed roles, especially since we only had 3.  It was a pretty fun game, and my first time as scum

Ya until that one positive lynch it was anyone's game. I lol'd at how everyone looked into kazio that first night

 

I think it was mostly activity levels that factored into the outcome. At certain times if people were more active it could have potentially changed the way the lynch votes swung.

Oh also   for being correct on my very first guess and post for that matter on noahband being scum.

I lol'd when I saw how 3 people targetted Kazio when he hid and all failed. probably what led to the (misguided) lynch vote being hammered in on him.

1. lol I didn't roleclaim because I was busy

so I was surprised that I was voted

 

2. you guys should learn how to react better when you are attacked

most people here will immediately react badly (especially Rafay)

isn't it that most of the time if you suspect the ones who suspect you,

you're wrong and they're most likely town?

 

3. sorry Xx Karl xX for suspecting you

you reacted too defensively

if i wasn't lynched at that day

i would definitely try to lynch Imran

Nice game Kev. The twists on the roles were marvellous. The scum could've easily taken the advantage and they did for the earlier game. Thank God, I didn't screw up and target wrong ppl when I was investigating. I gotta say, I'm disappointed with my performance. I only found 1 goblin, could've been better but at least I survived and won. That's what counts.

 

We should have more flavour games with ots and lots of power roles, like a justice league game.

We let the masons live on because we were trying to kill the cop. If we killed the actual cop and only the role cop remained it would have been very hard to id us as scum. It was a gamble and it failed. But I liked the setup. Good game.

Good game, however, I do not think I will be coming back for another one. I don't exactly understand the mechanics, and am as of late not as active (school).