You and your friends have decided to go to the rumored "haunted woods" for a Halloween camping trip. You set up camp and are just sitting down for some s'mores. You begin telling stories about past groups who have gone camping and have never been seen again. You wonder if you'll make it through the night...
 
 
Players:

• Nick the Great
• Imran
• Electric Mango
• Preston
• Montosh
• iSocialism
• Rafay
• Robert2424
• KevinH
• Dman3726 Commander Shepard
• Lyner
• Kaziocore

Still Alive (3/12)
 

Nick the Great

Montosh
Lyner
Kaziocore

 
Dead (9/12)

 

 

Rafay, 1-Shot town doctor was lynched on day 1.

Electric Mango Town Cop was night killed.

Imran Mafia Roleblocker was night killed.

Commander Shepard Vanilla townie was lynched on day 2.

Preston Vanilla townie was night killed.

Robert2424 Vanilla townie was night killed.

KevinH Vanilla townie was lynched.

Lyner, 1-shot town Roleblocker was night killed.

iSocialism Vanilla townie was night killed.

 

 

Vote: Nick the Great

he has no townie points in my book, and has happen to hop on the wagon.

Nick the Great is as good a candidate as any.

Any discussion before I place my vote?

I'm a vanilla townie, I'll say it up front.  iSocialism said that I don't have any town points, but I don't believe I have any scum points either.  I also don't really believe you have done anything that makes you seem like a townie either.  I mean, I didn't vote at the end of the day, but I had placed and removed votes throughout the game.  I haven't talked a whole lot because I am still in my first game, and want to learn how to play more.  I'd be willing to answer anything you guys wanted to ask.  Also, why am I being blamed by Rob, not Montosh or iSoc, who also didn't vote or do anything special that I didn't.

Also, I see that preston was night killed after heavily questioning and examining Kevin.  I think maybe the scum noticed that Preston had figured them out, so they killed him while they had a chance.  I suspect Kevin especially, and also Lyner and Kazio

Bah, Damn complicated day schedule and damn people liking to NK me. 

 

 

BAH BAH BAH BAH BAH BAH BAH. 

I are the deads. Bah!

I'll start with my previous list:

 

• Commander Shepard most inactive and won't be there to help town when needed
• Preston lynched Rafay and is trying hard to lynch an active claimed vanilla townie
• Lyner lynched Rafay and is sticking with Preston
• Kaziocore lynched Rafay
• iSocialism lynched Rafay
• Nick the Great nothing suspicious
• Montosh nothing suspicious
• Robert2424 nothing suspicious

 

  

FOS: Nick the Great, Montosh, iSocialism

My FOS was based on the "not voting", but there's more to it.
Let's analyze the votes at the end of the day.
 

It doesn't seem right. Kevin always acts exactly like this. I'm not saying there's nothing to the lynch, but Kevin is here and actively contributing.

I was on the chopping block at the time, and Montosh gives me some moral support but doesn't put his vote anywhere.
 
 

OK, I do seem to look really bad there to be honest.  I am new, and I agree with Kaz.  I kinda forgot about my vote on you earlier, since I got semi inactive for a few days.  Kevin just caught my eye when I saw some of the things he posted.  To be honest, I am not so what I am doing yet, since this is my first game, but Now that you pointed it out, my behavior was pretty dumb.
 Unvote

Nick the Great unvoted, which was ultimately helpful, but at the time left me with 3 votes and still on the chopping block.
 
Preston switched from me to Commander Shepard, which secured Commander Shepard's lynch.
 

Vote: Shepard

iSocialism's vote was 5 minutes late, but it might have counted. Commander Shepard's lynch was already secured before this.
 

 
So here's my revised list:

• Montosh verbally defended me, but didn't vote
• Lyner lynched Rafay, could have lynched me
• Kaziocore lynched Rafay, could have lynched me
• iSocialism lynched Rafay, put a late moot vote on Commander Shepard
• Nick the Great unvoted from me, but didn't revote

Vote: Montosh

 

You have to look at my analysis from the perspective of believing that I'm a townie.  But if you take that perspective, I believe Montosh's actions are the most scummy.

Interesting

 

And it's looking pretty bad for the town

 

Will post some thoughts tomorrow

 

 

 

 

Also why the sudden hastiness, iSoc?

Because I believe KevinH to be town. I saw that he was the lynch leader and tried to switch power over to Shepard who was inactive.

Dear scum,

Please kill each other.

Sincerely,

KevinH

I've been away for a few days. Anyway, I read your analysis Kevin, and just because I didn't vote your way doesn't make me scum.

 

Anyway, my internet is god awful atm, i'll be back when that clears up.

Just to be clear, I didn't agree with either the Kevin or Shepard lynch. If we're lynching based on general unhelpfulness, then we should lynch everyone but isocialism.

If we are lynching because someone isn't helping, then everyone loses.  Kevins line of look at the perspective that I'm a townie or whatever he said, makes it suspicious.  He is seeming like he doesn't even see that perspective.  I am actually really suspicious of Kevin right now.  

VOTE: KevinH

What other perspective could I have?

Nick the Great (1) - iSocialism

Montosh (1) - KevinH

iSocialism (0)

KevinH (1) - Nick the Great

Lyner (0)

Kaziocore (0)

No Lynch (0)

 

Not Voting (3) - Montosh,  Lyner, Kaziocore

 

With 6 alive, it takes 4 to reach majority and 2 to reach half majority.

Nick the Great is the current wagon leader at L-3.

Deadline is December, 24 2014 1:00 AM EST.

 

 

Kevin, it seems as you are looking thru the perspective that you are not town, and then when you say look at it as if I am town, it sounds like you are being hypothetical.

You have to look at my analysis from the perspective of believing that I'm a townie.  But if you take that perspective ...

 

Kevin, it seems as you are looking thru the perspective that you are not town, and then when you say look at it as if I am town, it sounds like you are being hypothetical.

 

The article you (above) refers to the remaining players in the game. I was addressing the remaining players in the game and suggesting the perspective that they should take.

 

How would you (Nick The Great) word it differently?

 

I see where you are coming from.  I would just generally think that is something that you don't have to say tho, and that people should assume you're town without telling to act as such.

Let's take a look at first day's votes:

 

 

Nick the Great (0)
Imran (0)

Electric Mango (1) - Rafay
Preston (0)
Montosh (1) - Commander Shepard
iSocialism (0)
Rafay (6) - Kaziocore, Lyner, Imran, Preston, iSocialism, Electric Mango
Robert2424 (0)
KevinH (0)

Commander Shepard (0)
Lyner (1) - Montosh
Kaziocore (0)
No Lynch (1) -   Nick the Great, KevinH

Not Voting (1) - Robert2424

 

In a 12 player game there is usually 3 scum, we confirmed a third party(probably SK) so it should be 2 mafia and 1 SK

The mafias, not sure that there is an SK would try to split into the wagon and off-wagon.

The SK lynched one guy from the wagon, therefore chance is he should not be in the wagon.

One of the mafia is in the wagon, so chance is the other is not in the wagon

 

Now let's look at last night's kill

 

Nick the Great (0)

Preston (0)

Montosh (0)

iSocialism (0)

Robert2424 (0)
KevinH (2) - Lyner, Kaziocore

Commander Shepard (3) - KevinH, Robert2424, Preston

Lyner (0)
Kaziocore (0)

No Lynch (0)
Not Voting (4) - Nick the Great, Montosh, Commander Shepard, iSocialism

With 9 alive, it takes 5 to reach majority and 3 to reach half majority.

Commander Shepard is the current wagon leader at L-2.

Deadline is December, 13 2014 12:00 AM EST.

 

Preston, Vanilla Townie has been night killed.
Robert2424, Vanilla Townie has been night killed.

 

Both scum parties knows Preston is town, and if I were them I'd surely lynch him ASAP for sparking activities and leading town.

But if one of the scum targets Preston, it means risking having the other party targeted Preston, too. The safer choice is for both scums to target other people, since there are still a lot of towns remaining. Preston has been suspecting Kevin strongly, so it should be safe to kill Preston the next day if one of the scum isn't Kevin.

Yet one of the scum still take the risk and lynched Preston anyway.  Is the scum Kevin? or is the scum framing Kevin?

 

The Robert kill is also an interesting one, he hasn't been posting much, if scum were trying to kill a townie then Kaz should be a better choice IMO(not to mention Kaz's the only one Preston believe is a town). Robert has suspicion about Kevin.

 

Much assumptions I know

 

 

 

 

 

That's that,

After all those mumbo jumbos, I'm feeling that our scum is Kevin and Nick, with iSoc as a runner up. Montosh hasn't posted much for me to get a good vibe, interesting fact tho, Montosh hasn't voted even once since RVS. We're screwed if Kaz is scum.

Let's take a look at first day's votes:

 

 

Nick the Great (0)

Imran (0)

Electric Mango (1) - Rafay

Preston (0)

Montosh (1) - Commander Shepard

iSocialism (0)

Rafay (6) - Kaziocore, Lyner, Imran, Preston, iSocialism, Electric Mango

Robert2424 (0)

KevinH (0)

Commander Shepard (0)

Lyner (1) - Montosh

Kaziocore (0)

No Lynch (1) -   Nick the Great, KevinH

 

Not Voting (1) - Robert2424

 

In a 12 player game there is usually 3 scum, we confirmed a third party(probably SK) so it should be 2 mafia and 1 SK

The mafias, not sure that there is an SK would try to split into the wagon and off-wagon.

The SK lynched one guy from the wagon, therefore chance is he should not be in the wagon.

One of the mafia is in the wagon, so chance is the other is not in the wagon

 

Now let's look at last night's kill

 

Nick the Great (0)

Preston (0)

Montosh (0)

iSocialism (0)

Robert2424 (0)

KevinH (2) - Lyner, Kaziocore

Commander Shepard (3) - KevinH, Robert2424, Preston

Lyner (0)

Kaziocore (0)

No Lynch (0)

Not Voting (4) - Nick the Great, Montosh, Commander Shepard, iSocialism

 

With 9 alive, it takes 5 to reach majority and 3 to reach half majority.

 

Commander Shepard is the current wagon leader at L-2.

Deadline is December, 13 2014 12:00 AM EST.

 

Preston, Vanilla Townie has been night killed.

Robert2424, Vanilla Townie has been night killed.

 

Both scum parties knows Preston is town, and if I were them I'd surely lynch him ASAP for sparking activities and leading town.

But if one of the scum targets Preston, it means risking having the other party targeted Preston, too. The safer choice is for both scums to target other people, since there are still a lot of towns remaining. Preston has been suspecting Kevin strongly, so it should be safe to kill Preston the next day if one of the scum isn't Kevin.

Yet one of the scum still take the risk and lynched Preston anyway.  Is the scum Kevin? or is the scum framing Kevin?

 

The Robert kill is also an interesting one, he hasn't been posting much, if scum were trying to kill a townie then Kaz should be a better choice IMO(not to mention Kaz's the only one Preston believe is a town). Robert has suspicion about Kevin.

 

Much assumptions I know

 

 

 

 

 

That's that,

After all those mumbo jumbos, I'm feeling that our scum is Kevin and Nick, with iSoc as a runner up. Montosh hasn't posted much for me to get a good vibe, interesting fact tho, Montosh hasn't voted even once since RVS. We're screwed if Kaz is scum.

So you are saying, that me and kevin are both scum, however we are voting for eachother?  How does that work?

 

Let's take a look at first day's votes:

 

 

Nick the Great (0)

Imran (0)

Electric Mango (1) - Rafay

Preston (0)

Montosh (1) - Commander Shepard

iSocialism (0)

Rafay (6) - Kaziocore, Lyner, Imran, Preston, iSocialism, Electric Mango

Robert2424 (0)

KevinH (0)

Commander Shepard (0)

Lyner (1) - Montosh

Kaziocore (0)

No Lynch (1) -   Nick the Great, KevinH

 

Not Voting (1) - Robert2424

 

In a 12 player game there is usually 3 scum, we confirmed a third party(probably SK) so it should be 2 mafia and 1 SK

The mafias, not sure that there is an SK would try to split into the wagon and off-wagon.

The SK lynched one guy from the wagon, therefore chance is he should not be in the wagon.

One of the mafia is in the wagon, so chance is the other is not in the wagon

 

Now let's look at last night's kill

 

Nick the Great (0)

Preston (0)

Montosh (0)

iSocialism (0)

Robert2424 (0)

KevinH (2) - Lyner, Kaziocore

Commander Shepard (3) - KevinH, Robert2424, Preston

Lyner (0)

Kaziocore (0)

No Lynch (0)

Not Voting (4) - Nick the Great, Montosh, Commander Shepard, iSocialism

 

With 9 alive, it takes 5 to reach majority and 3 to reach half majority.

 

Commander Shepard is the current wagon leader at L-2.

Deadline is December, 13 2014 12:00 AM EST.

 

Preston, Vanilla Townie has been night killed.

Robert2424, Vanilla Townie has been night killed.

 

Both scum parties knows Preston is town, and if I were them I'd surely lynch him ASAP for sparking activities and leading town.

But if one of the scum targets Preston, it means risking having the other party targeted Preston, too. The safer choice is for both scums to target other people, since there are still a lot of towns remaining. Preston has been suspecting Kevin strongly, so it should be safe to kill Preston the next day if one of the scum isn't Kevin.

Yet one of the scum still take the risk and lynched Preston anyway.  Is the scum Kevin? or is the scum framing Kevin?

 

The Robert kill is also an interesting one, he hasn't been posting much, if scum were trying to kill a townie then Kaz should be a better choice IMO(not to mention Kaz's the only one Preston believe is a town). Robert has suspicion about Kevin.

 

Much assumptions I know

 

 

 

 

 

That's that,

After all those mumbo jumbos, I'm feeling that our scum is Kevin and Nick, with iSoc as a runner up. Montosh hasn't posted much for me to get a good vibe, interesting fact tho, Montosh hasn't voted even once since RVS. We're screwed if Kaz is scum.

So you are saying, that me and kevin are both scum, however we are voting for eachother?  How does that work?

 

He said he believes there are 2 scums and a sk for this game. One scum was already killed, leaving us one scum and SK

It's easy for scum to vote for each other.  When one is revealed, the other looks really townie.

I'll post later after work.

Three and a half days left.
Two votes at deadline to lynch.

Vote: Nick The Great

Getting two votes on somebody is best for the town.
 

Three and a half days left.

Two votes at deadline to lynch.

 

Vote: Nick The Great

 

Getting two votes on somebody is best for the town.

 

 

 

Not if you get 2 votes on another townie