[OP-06] Kill Everyone Mafia

Players (7/7)

• Lyner
• KevinH
• Road2Victory
• Electric Mango
• Rafay
• Nenos the Great
• iSocialism

Still Alive (1/7)

 

• KevinH

 

Already Dead

Lyner, Town Vigilante, was night killed on Night 1
Electric Mango, Mafia Goon, was night killed on Night 1
Nenos the Great, Town Vigilante, was night killed on Night 1
iSocialism, Mafia Goon, was night killed on Night 1

Road2Victory, Town Vigilante, was night killed on Day 2

Rafay, Town Vigilante, was endgamed on Day 2

 

Links to Important Stuff
Replacement Thread
Rules and Role PMs
 
1.00, 1.01, 1.02, 1.03, 1.04

2.00, 2.01 (END)
 

veeeeeery good job Kevin

town was too lazy

picked KevinH's plan even though it could mean instant Mafia win if two scum players are in a row

I love the plan Kevin.

I was against it from the get go. The town was filled w/ idiots and inactive noobs.

So who'll be modding the next game?

I had an idea for one game

I wonder what if Rafay was online and read that last message from Kevinh and changed his vote. 

Wow Rafay shame on you.Filled with idiots? I knew Kevin was mafia all along. 

I try to play the same whether I'm townie or scum.

 

The plan was sound as the best option for the town except for one point.

 

I got to pick the time at which the stocks were ordered.

 

When Nenos didn't shoot, it blew my plan (from the scum perspective) but we got lucky with the final lynch.

http://i.imgur.com/lcGtFIJ.jpg

I wonder what if Rafay was online and read that last message from Kevinh and changed his vote. 

Votes are locked when it's L-0

I got to pick the time at which the stocks were ordered.

 

Yeah that was good, should've noticed that last ordering post

 

 

Wow Rafay shame on you.Filled with idiots? I knew Kevin was mafia all along. 

 

So did I. But why the others accepted the plan is beyond me.  

 

Wow Rafay shame on you.Filled with idiots? I knew Kevin was mafia all along. 

 

So did I. But why the others accepted the plan is beyond me.  

 

So you wanted to punish the town?

 

 

So you wanted to punish the town?

 

No I was confused at the end tbh. 

If I played this game again as a townie, I'd advocate the exact same plan.

 

So you wanted to punish the town?

 

No I was confused at the end tbh. 

 

That explains why you don't like to be the person with the last vote or make the final decision.....

I guess its a good thing you are not a judge then....

You think you could have done better????

If I was more active I would have persuaded Rafay that Kevin was mafia. 

whatever r2v, you brought it. Kevin is a very good player. This team was very experienced

You're wrong iSocialism, not just about r2v since he knew Kevinh was scum and voted for him.

Nothing about being good or experienced, the mafia is lucky that Rafay was confused because otherwise you would have lost. And that is more of Rafay's fault than the scum playing good. 

Nobody could "know" that I was scum.

Starting with 4 vigilantes and 3 scum made for an interesting setup but not conducive to typical play where a player is lynched and suspicion goes towards those that voted to lynch a townie.

Random vigilante shots without a plan and a guaranteed scum kill every night would have made it difficult for the town to win.

Nenos should have made his shot and the game should never reached the point where Rafay had to make a judgement between 2 players.

 

The flaw in the town's play was that my "random" assignment was not challenged.  I got to pick the time when when the stock prices were quoted.  If the arrangement at that time did not favor the scum, I would simply have picked another time.

I meant most probable, hence voting you and not Rafay.

The flaw in the town's play was that they were too inactive to care to challenge it seems and not caring about the way things were being done and the implications.

 

If they looked at the data (there's probably more scummy things to reflect on that you did);

1) You deciding who to kill based on supposedly random data

2) Your first plan being ordered weirdly and not based off the order of players from in-game list (default)

3) I wouldn't say the way the events unfolded points to you being scum but you would be the most suspicious so yeah

 

Whichever way you look at it's the town fault for the mafia winning in your scenario and how it actually happened. That same inactivity that allowed you to control the game also undermined your plan so it's a moot point. Assuming it was town inactivity according to some players. 

Actually no I can't forgive you Rafay.

Never has so much evidence pointed to Kevinh being the scum, you really can't blame other players of being inactive when you don't even look back at previous posts.

Lyner figured out you're scum KevinH :V

Well said Commander Shephard couldn't have said it any better myself. 

1) You deciding who to kill based on supposedly random data

 

If it was random, that would be best for the town. 

 

2) Your first plan being ordered weirdly and not based off the order of players from in-game list (default)

 

Alphabetical is weird? (Which happened to put the 3 scum in a row!)