~21 hours until the deadline. We need to make some decisions.

Vote: ccabal

You've got something jammed in here real good

 
Vote Count

ccabal86 (2): Imran Ehsan, The Warrior,
Shahenshah (1): iSocialism,
The Warrior (0): 
Electric Mango (0): 
Yehom (0):
iSocialism (0):
Imran Ehsan (0):
Lyner (0):
Finster Baby (0):

No Lynch (0):

Not voting: Electric Mango, ccabal86, Shahenshah, Lyner, Yehom, Finster Baby,  

 
With 9 alive, it takes 5 to lynch or 3 at deadline.
Deadline is Thursday, March 17 at 17:00 EDT.
 

Kevin, you missed Lyner's vote. There are three votes for ccabal currently.

As I have all ready stated I feel ccabal is in a 1a/1b situation on my potential scum list:

 

VOTE: ccabal86

Yeah target the guy who isn't talking. That has shown so much results with the last lynches. Must be the liking of picking a target that won't fight back. I'll bet that Ccabal will show up as luke skywalker - watcher/town. My only question is why so eager to vote for him? anyways

 

Vote Imran

 

if you are not scum then they will hop all over this making sure to get someone of your role out of the pool, but we'll see.

Yeah target the guy who isn't talking. That has shown so much results with the last lynches. Must be the liking of picking a target that won't fight back. I'll bet that Ccabal will show up as luke skywalker - watcher/town. My only question is why so eager to vote for him? anyways

 

Vote Imran

 

if you are not scum then they will hop all over this making sure to get someone of your role out of the pool, but we'll see.

My only problem with your theory is he is active everywhere else.

 

Vote:ccabal.

The First Order is ruthless.
 
Vote Count

ccabal86 (5): Imran Ehsan, The Warrior, Lyner, Finster Baby, Shahenshah, 
Imran Ehsan (1): iSocialism,

 
ccabal86, Luke Skywalker, Non-Consecutive Night Watcher, has been lynched.

It is now Night 5.
Please actions to me by Saturday, March 19, at 11:00 EDT.

Day 6 begins.

Yehom, Ello Asty, Bodyguard, was killed in the night.

The Warrior announces that this has all been an episode of Undercover Boss: Starkiller Base and he is really Kylo Ren.

The Mafia team is revealed:

Shahenshah, Supreme Leader Snoke, Mafia Encryptor Godfather
Imran Ehsan, Captain Phasma, Mafia Encryptor Jack-of-all-trades
The Warrior, Kylo Ren, Mafia Encryptor Ninja
Electric Mango, General Hux, Mafia Encryptor 1-shot Strongman

 

Three remaining townies don't have the ability to achieve a majority

iSocialism, Lor San Tekka, 1-Shot Bulletproof Neapolitan
Lyner, C-3PO, Doctor
Finster Baby, PZ-4CO, Even Night Follower

 

Mafia wins!

 

Somewhere deep down I had a feeling that TW and Imran were scum after reading back, but they played it too well. Good game guys

I knew I should have stayed with TW and Shah. *sigh*

 

Well played gents. Well played.

The dark force awakens .

 

We figured there was bulletproof either on iSoc or Lyner.

Would be nice to see the night actions. Make it happen kevin.

 

This was really fun for us...so good game. I was running out of theories (lies) to post towards the end there. iSocialism, you were on to us but just not close enough. Perez was onto us as well before everyone else I think, but it was too easy to get him lynched as well

I just wanted to believe that the town had one cop left but something told me it was too good to be true. Also all actions of ccabal and Finster pointed to them telling the truth, which meant that the alternative was either one TW/Sha/Imran was scum. Too much faith in Imran, sorry guys

iSocialism

You are Lor San Tekka, 1-Shot Bulletproof Neapolitan. 
Abilities:
Each night phase, you may query whether any player is a vanilla townie or not. The first shot you take will not kill you.
Win condition:
You win when all threats to the town have been eliminated and there is at least one town player alive.

Rafay 

You are R2-D2, 3-shot (ascetic-proof) Rolestopper 
Abilities:
Three times during the night phase, you may target a player to stop all other Night actions from affecting them in any way
Win condition:
You win when all threats to the town have been eliminated and there is at least one town player alive.

Fox Fire

You are Poe Dameron , Ascetic Sane Cop 
Abilities:
Each night you may investigate players to discern their alignment. You are immune to all actions at Night except kills.
Win condition:
You win when all threats to the town have been eliminated and there is at least one town player alive.

Lyner

You are C-3PO, Doctor 
Abilities:
Each night you may target a player to protect that player from a single kill made during that Night
Win condition:
You win when all threats to the town have been eliminated and there is at least one town player alive.

Commander Shepard / Finster Baby

You are PZ-4CO, Even Night Follower 
Abilities:
On even numbered nights you may target a player to learn what form of action they took that Night but not who they targeted.
Win condition:
You win when all threats to the town have been eliminated and there is at least one town player alive.

Mandarijn

You are Admiral Ackbar, Macho Flavor Cop 
Abilities:
Each night you may investigate players to discern their Star Wars character name. You may not be protected from kills.
Win condition:
You win when all threats to the town have been eliminated and there is at least one town player alive.

Rusken

You are Leia Organa, Motion Detector 
Abilities:
Each night you may target a player and learn if any actions were performed by or on that player, but not what the actions were or who else they involved.
Win condition:
You win when all threats to the town have been eliminated and there is at least one town player alive.

Road2Victory / Ccabal86

You are Luke Skywalker, Non-Consecutive Night Watcher 
Abilities:
On non-consecutive nights you may can target a player and learn who, if anybody, targeted that player the same Night (but not what actions were performed on that player).
Win condition:
You win when all threats to the town have been eliminated and there is at least one town player alive.

Robert2424

You are BB-8, Odd Night Tracker 
Abilities:
On odd-numbered nights you may can target a player and learn who, if anybody, that player targeted the same night (but not the action the player performed).
Win condition:
You win when all threats to the town have been eliminated and there is at least one town player alive.

Samus

You are Chewbacca, Vanilla Townie Universal Backup 
Abilities:
You are a vanilla townie until the first town power role dies. Then you will inherit that role.
Win condition:
You win when all threats to the town have been eliminated and there is at least one town player alive.

Perez

You are Maz Kanata, Voyeur 
Abilities:
Each night you can target a player at night and learn what was done to them that night (protection, investigation, etc), but not who did it.
Win condition:
You win when all threats to the town have been eliminated and there is at least one town player alive.

Yehom

You are Ello Asty, Bodyguard 
Abilities:
Each night you can target a player to protect them. However, if the protected player is supposed to be killed, you will be killed instead ("taking the bullet" for them, as it were).
Win condition:
You win when all threats to the town have been eliminated and there is at least one town player alive.

Kaziocore / Shahenshah

You are Supreme Leader Snoke, Mafia Encryptor Godfather (safe-claim as Han Solo) 
Imran Ehsan, The Warrior, and Electric Mango are Mafia with you.
Abilities:
If investigated by a cop, you will be shown as innocent. If investigated by a flavor cop, you will show as Han Solo. As a group, you get a nightly factional kill. You may talk with your fellow scum at this link http://www.quicktopic.com/52/H/8gQgKxD6E6N
Win condition:
You win when all other factions have been eliminated or nothing can prevent it.

Imran Ehsan

You are Captain Phasma, Mafia Encryptor Jack-of-all-trades (safe-claim as Rey) 
Kaziocore, The Warrior, and Electric Mango are Mafia with you.
Abilities:
You have 1 shot each of cop, doctor, gunsmith, neapolitan, role cop, roleblocker, rolestopper, and vigilante (after night 2).
As a group, you get a nightly factional kill. You may talk with your fellow scum at this link http://www.quicktopic.com/52/H/8gQgKxD6E6N
Win condition:
You win when all other factions have been eliminated or nothing can prevent it.

The Warrior

You are Kylo Ren, Mafia Encryptor Ninja (safe-claim as Finn/FN-2187) 
Kaziocore, Imran Ehsan, and Electric Mango are Mafia with you.
Abilities:
As a group, you get a nightly factional kill. If you deliver this kill, you will not be seen.
You may talk with your fellow scum at this link http://www.quicktopic.com/52/H/8gQgKxD6E6N
Win condition:
You win when all other factions have been eliminated or nothing can prevent it.

Electric Mango

You are General Hux, Mafia Encryptor 1-shot Strongman (safe-claim as Captain Ithano)
Kaziocore, Imran Ehsan, and The Warrior are Mafia with you.
Abilities:
As a group, you get a nightly factional kill. If you deliver this kill, you can choose to use the strongman ability once .
You may talk with your fellow scum at this link http://www.quicktopic.com/52/H/8gQgKxD6E6N
Win condition:
You win when all other factions have been eliminated or nothing can prevent it.

Summary


Day 1:

• Fox Fire, Ascetic Sane Cop was lynched.
• Samus, Vanilla Townie Universal Backup, becomes Ascetic Sane Cop

Night 1:

• Rafay, 3-shot Rolestopper, rolestops on Samus. 
• The Warrior, Mafia Encryptor Ninja, attempts to kill Samus but fails.
• Mandarijn, Macho Flavor Cop, flavor investigates The Warrior and learns his character name is Kylo Ren.
• Imran Ehsan, Mafia Encryptor Jack-of-all-trades uses rolecop ability on Rafay.
• Perez, Voyeur, targets The Warrior.
• iSocialism, 1-Shot Bulletproof Neapolitan, targets Rusken.
• Rusken, Motion Detector, targets Road2Victory.
• Road2Victory (later Ccabal86), Non-Consecutive Night Watcher, targets Robert2424.
• Robert2424, Odd Night Tracker, targets Yehom.
• Samus, Ascetic Sane Cop, investigates Lyner.
• Lyner, Doctor, protects Electric Mango.
• Yehom, Bodyguard, takes no action.

Day 2:

• Rusken, Motion Detector, was lynched.

Night 2:

• Rafay, 3-shot Rolestopper, rolestops on Samus.
• Lyner, Doctor, protects Samus but is blocked.
• Mandarijn, Macho Flavor Cop, flavor investigates Samus but is blocked.
• Perez, Voyeur, targets Samus but is blocked.
• Yehom, Bodyguard, targets Samus but is blocked.
• Electric Mango, Mafia Encryptor 1-shot Strongman, strongman kills Samus.
• Samus, Ascetic Sane Cop, tries to investigates Road2Victory but is killed instead.
• iSocialism, 1-Shot Bulletproof Neapolitan, targets Imran Ehsan.
• Imran Ehsan, Mafia Encryptor Jack-of-all-trades uses roleblock ability on Road2Victory.
• Finster Baby, Even Night Follower, follows The Warrior.

Day 3:

• Rafay, 3-shot (ascetic-proof) Rolestopper was lynched.

Night 3:

• The Warrior, Mafia Encryptor Ninja, kills Robert2424.
• Imran Ehsan, Mafia Encryptor Jack-of-all-trades uses vigilante kill on Mandarijn.
• Mandarijn, Macho Flavor Cop, flavor investigates Perez but is killed.
• Robert2424, Odd Night Tracker, targets Mandarijn but is killed.
• iSocialism, 1-Shot Bulletproof Neapolitan, targets Electric Mango.
• Lyner, Doctor, targets Imran Ehsan,
• Yehom, Bodyguard, targets Imran Ehsan.
• Ccabal86, Non-Consecutive Night Watcher targets Imran Ehsan.
• Perez, Voyeur, targets Imran Ehsan.

Day 4:

• Perez, Voyeur, was lynched.

Night 4:

• The Warrior, Mafia Encryptor Ninja, attempts to kill iSocialism but is stopped by bulletproof.
• iSocialism, 1-Shot Bulletproof Neapolitan, targets Lyner.
• Yehom, Bodyguard, targets Lyner.
• Lyner, Doctor, targets Imran Ehsan.
• Imran Ehsan, Mafia Encryptor Jack-of-all-trades uses rolestop on Shahenshah.
• Finster Baby, Even Night Follower, follows Electric Mango.

Day 5:

• Ccabal86, Non-Consecutive Night Watcher, was lynched.

Night 5:

• Yehom, Bodyguard, targets Lyner.
• The Warrior, Mafia Encryptor Ninja, attempts to kill Lyner but kills bodyguard Yehom instead.
• Imran Ehsan, Mafia Encryptor Jack-of-all-trades uses doctor on The Warrior.
• iSocialism, 1-Shot Bulletproof Neapolitan, targets Lyner.

Mafia win with 4-3 advantage.


The Mafia Talk thread is at http://www.quicktopic.com/52/H/8gQgKxD6E6N
The highlight is a post by Electric Mango:
"Your role as scum is try not to stick out but act like your not trying to blend in while at the same time trying not to act like you are trying to not act like you are not acting to try to blending in of the blending. Confused? Don't be. Day 1 Strategies: Throw random accusations and act like a noob."


Mod notes

Overall, the game played out differently than expected. The town had a lot of investigative roles. I gave the scum both Ninja and Godfather abilities to counteract that but it turns out that those abiliities never came into play. The town had several protective abilities and was only able to prevent one kill, plus a bulletproof was used.

Day 2: Rusken voting for Samus would not be a real scum tell. There was no way that a claimed cop would get lynched and the scum would not try to advocate it.

Fox Fire was revealed as Ascetic Sane Cop. Samus took the role as backup so if the town believed his claim, they should have understood that ascetic means the role can't be protected by the doctor or bodyguard.

Day 4: Mandarijn the flavor cop gets killed in the night and had been after The Warrior all game; I was expecting a lynch within a few hours, but the scum team talked their way out of it.

Day 4: Lyner, Yehom, Ccabal86, and Perez all visited Imran Ehsan the night before (bedroom party) and that might have self-confirmed their roles with some degree of certainty but nobody really mentioned it.

Night 4: The scum somehow thought that Lyner the doctor might be bulletproof so instead targeted iSocialism who had bulletproof. How ironic.

I give the scum a lot of credit for talking their way out of some bad situations. Well-played!

Somehow I managed to follow 2 scum. Not sure if that was luck or not. lol

That was a lot of fun guys and it will certainly be a very memorable first game of mafia for me. I'm looking forward to playing in many upcoming games.

 

Catching on to some aspects of the game early on was difficult since it was my first game, but I give a lot of credit to my teammates (especially Imran) for helping devise a great strategy that we executed pretty flawlessly in my opinion. I will say that for the duration of the game, this thread was my favorite thread and discussion to participate in on the entire forums. Given te current state of foreign affairs in CN though, it's probably a good thing that this game is finally over. We have a little bit of work to do.

IMO the big risk we took was going after Mand, we knew it was a matter of time before he stops buying into Imrans stories and push for tW. We knew the reaction would be tW getting lynched so we played that around as a knee jerk reaction theory.

 

We also knew Lyner as a confirmed townie could carry.some.townie votes so we played into winning him and amplify his doubts.

Mod notes

 

Overall, the game played out differently than expected. The town had a lot of investigative roles. I gave the scum both Ninja and Godfather abilities to counteract that but it turns out that those abiliities never came into play. The town had several protective abilities and was only able to prevent one kill, plus a bulletproof was used.

 

Day 2: Rusken voting for Samus would not be a real scum tell. There was no way that a claimed cop would get lynched and the scum would not try to advocate it.

 

Fox Fire was revealed as Ascetic Sane Cop. Samus took the role as backup so if the town believed his claim, they should have understood that ascetic means the role can't be protected by the doctor or bodyguard.

 

Day 4: Mandarijn the flavor cop gets killed in the night and had been after The Warrior all game; I was expecting a lynch within a few hours, but the scum team talked their way out of it.

 

Day 4: Lyner, Yehom, Ccabal86, and Perez all visited Imran Ehsan the night before (bedroom party) and that might have self-confirmed their roles with some degree of certainty but nobody really mentioned it.

 

Night 4: The scum somehow thought that Lyner the doctor might be bulletproof so instead targeted iSocialism who had bulletproof. How ironic.

 

I give the scum a lot of credit for talking their way out of some bad situations. Well-played!

 

Nice summary. To add a few points of my own. I thought Samus missed a trick there revealing his role early without confirming at least one of us as scum. We had EM's strong man ability which cut though all protections that he attracted. He probably saved Lyner from the D2 lynch though but in hindsight that didnt help the town win the game as none of our targets were saved by him.

 

Mand also missed a trick by not revealing why he thought TW was scum. He pretty much confirmed him as scum N1 but still went on to vote others for lynch instead of revealing that he knew by his actions that TW was scum. Also Kevin is right that town really should have picked up that Mand knew TW is scum after Perez revealed that Mand had visited TW on N2 coupled with his role. We really talked out of that by getting Perez lynched instead of letting others believe him.

 

We were really worried that Lyner may be BP so we did not target him on N4 or the game would have been over early,

 

Perez's reveal was really damaging for us. He confirmed ccabal, Lyner and Yehom's role as well as his own which also revealing Mand had visited TW on N2. We started a lot of discussions in different tangents and a lot of fluff to make sure townies dont analyze his results too closely. iSoc did analyze them later but he did not have enough support and couldnt make good arguments to sway the townies to his side as well.

 

Townies were held back by the inactives specially of ccabal and Rafay who did not defend themselves when we pushed for their lynches.

 

The mafia encryptor ability was awesome. Me, TW and Shah strategised a lot during the game and probably posted more in our mafia thread then in this thread to get our strategies right to win the game. By the way we discussed a lot on how to confuse you guys a lot and how to make sure you dont all gang up on us by targetting one or the other as lynch targets while supporting others.

 

So Yehom/Finster..dont feel too bad. We strategised a lot to confuse you guys...

@Kevin - I'm curious to know who you felt would be the "MVP" of the game. Also, is there a specific game event that you believed was the turning point that altered the course of the rest of the game?

That was a lot of fun guys and it will certainly be a very memorable first game of mafia for me. I'm looking forward to playing in many upcoming games.

 

Catching on to some aspects of the game early on was difficult since it was my first game, but I give a lot of credit to my teammates (especially Imran) for helping devise a great strategy that we executed pretty flawlessly in my opinion. I will say that for the duration of the game, this thread was my favorite thread and discussion to participate in on the entire forums. Given te current state of foreign affairs in CN though, it's probably a good thing that this game is finally over. We have a little bit of work to do.

good first game here bro.

 

I highly suspected you as scum because of your rookiness in the early day(s), some of your posts just screamed 'NOOB SCUM RIGHT HERE' but you managed to avoid my attention when other townies were behaving more scummier :/.

 

Seems you've learnt alot now, and will be good to see if you still post like a noob or not in the next game

 

And now we need to get more people to get in on all this fun they've been missing out on! War shouldn't be a distraction, takes max 30mins/day

MVPs never come from the losing side but I think Perez had things analyzed correctly before he got lynched on Day 4 and I think that was the turning point of the game.

 

I'll give the honor to Imran because the doc was still protecting him on the last night!

Electric Mango, Mafia Encryptor 1-shot Strongman, strongman kills Samus.

 

Electric Tango.

 

This is confirmation that you will never live this one down.

 

Ever.