450 replies to this topic

[Chaplain of death]

=D that makes a lot more sense now. I was curious how i killed Rhizo. I was just hoping against hope that he'd vig kill a townie but i thought i was screwed since he was obviously suspicious of me at that point.

I did point out the possibility of someone having targeted WP but being scum i couldn't exactly stick my head on the chopping block with him by arguing with the entire town.

Im also surprised i wasnt lynched on the last day. I misplayed hard trying to turn on SM. The fact that SBG voted me early and all of us posted with no hammer from the scum makes it clear that he or I was the scum. I realized this far too late when i couldn't possibly reverse direction on my gamble on SM. (In the future it is most definetly not in the towns interest to throw out votes early like that on the last day when scum can just hammer and end, because if you are wrong the scum win. Hold your vote until discussion can take place unless you have clear evidence.)

[Rhizoctonia]

=D that makes a lot more sense now. I was curious how i killed Rhizo. I was just hoping against hope that he'd vig kill a townie but i thought i was screwed since he was obviously suspicious of me at that point.

I did point out the possibility of someone having targeted WP but being scum i couldn't exactly stick my head on the chopping block with him by arguing with the entire town.

Im also surprised i wasnt lynched on the last day. I misplayed hard trying to turn on SM. The fact that SBG voted me early and all of us posted with no hammer from the scum makes it clear that he or I was the scum. I realized this far too late when i couldn't possibly reverse direction on my gamble on SM. (In the future it is most definetly not in the towns interest to throw out votes early like that on the last day when scum can just hammer and end, because if you are wrong the scum win. Hold your vote until discussion can take place unless you have clear evidence.)

 

 

Yea, after the night you killed me I pondered how the hell it happened.  I was pretty certain you were the last scum, but I wasn't sold yet on SBG.  So I went through every scenario I could think of on how if you were scum, why my RB didn't work.   Was I roleblocked?  Were you immune?  What confused me the most was I RB'd you, yet it didn't go through, so then my thought was maybe he's has a RB (would be odd since you had a JOAT with a RB), but if that was the case, then you would of shown up with motion when Robert used his ability on you, so it couldn't of been that.  Only explanation was you were a Ninja, but couldn't understand how you would still be able to kill me.  So I was pretty much lost, either I was missing something, or it was SBG.  Seems it was your unknown role, which I didn't even think about, which makes sense because I had one that I didn't know of.  Should of thought of that, since I had a unknown one.

I was pretty certain it was you, was thinking about Vig killing you, but SBG was on my mind as a possibility.  Figured RB was safer, if I RB you and wasn't killed I would start next day knowing it was you.  Didn't want to Vig kill you and be wrong and hurt town chances.  Wouldn't of mattered I guess what action I used, wouldn't of worked. 

 

But well played, good win.  TW certainly made me think about a lot, even after dead with his setup.  

[SeaBeeGipson]

Good game.

[Imran Ehsan]

I knew COD was scum. 

 

was wrong about yehom though.

[Chaplain of death]

 

=D that makes a lot more sense now. I was curious how i killed Rhizo. I was just hoping against hope that he'd vig kill a townie but i thought i was screwed since he was obviously suspicious of me at that point.

I did point out the possibility of someone having targeted WP but being scum i couldn't exactly stick my head on the chopping block with him by arguing with the entire town.

Im also surprised i wasnt lynched on the last day. I misplayed hard trying to turn on SM. The fact that SBG voted me early and all of us posted with no hammer from the scum makes it clear that he or I was the scum. I realized this far too late when i couldn't possibly reverse direction on my gamble on SM. (In the future it is most definetly not in the towns interest to throw out votes early like that on the last day when scum can just hammer and end, because if you are wrong the scum win. Hold your vote until discussion can take place unless you have clear evidence.)

 

 

Yea, after the night you killed me I pondered how the hell it happened.  I was pretty certain you were the last scum, but I wasn't sold yet on SBG.  So I went through every scenario I could think of on how if you were scum, why my RB didn't work.   Was I roleblocked?  Were you immune?  What confused me the most was I RB'd you, yet it didn't go through, so then my thought was maybe he's has a RB (would be odd since you had a JOAT with a RB), but if that was the case, then you would of shown up with motion when Robert used his ability on you, so it couldn't of been that.  Only explanation was you were a Ninja, but couldn't understand how you would still be able to kill me.  So I was pretty much lost, either I was missing something, or it was SBG.  Seems it was your unknown role, which I didn't even think about, which makes sense because I had one that I didn't know of.  Should of thought of that, since I had a unknown one.

I was pretty certain it was you, was thinking about Vig killing you, but SBG was on my mind as a possibility.  Figured RB was safer, if I RB you and wasn't killed I would start next day knowing it was you.  Didn't want to Vig kill you and be wrong and hurt town chances.  Wouldn't of mattered I guess what action I used, wouldn't of worked. 

 

But well played, good win.  TW certainly made me think about a lot, even after dead with his setup.  

 

 

Your Vig kill would have gone through. The extra ability stopped all non kill abilities.

[The Warrior]

 

 

=D that makes a lot more sense now. I was curious how i killed Rhizo. I was just hoping against hope that he'd vig kill a townie but i thought i was screwed since he was obviously suspicious of me at that point.

I did point out the possibility of someone having targeted WP but being scum i couldn't exactly stick my head on the chopping block with him by arguing with the entire town.

Im also surprised i wasnt lynched on the last day. I misplayed hard trying to turn on SM. The fact that SBG voted me early and all of us posted with no hammer from the scum makes it clear that he or I was the scum. I realized this far too late when i couldn't possibly reverse direction on my gamble on SM. (In the future it is most definetly not in the towns interest to throw out votes early like that on the last day when scum can just hammer and end, because if you are wrong the scum win. Hold your vote until discussion can take place unless you have clear evidence.)

 

 

Yea, after the night you killed me I pondered how the hell it happened.  I was pretty certain you were the last scum, but I wasn't sold yet on SBG.  So I went through every scenario I could think of on how if you were scum, why my RB didn't work.   Was I roleblocked?  Were you immune?  What confused me the most was I RB'd you, yet it didn't go through, so then my thought was maybe he's has a RB (would be odd since you had a JOAT with a RB), but if that was the case, then you would of shown up with motion when Robert used his ability on you, so it couldn't of been that.  Only explanation was you were a Ninja, but couldn't understand how you would still be able to kill me.  So I was pretty much lost, either I was missing something, or it was SBG.  Seems it was your unknown role, which I didn't even think about, which makes sense because I had one that I didn't know of.  Should of thought of that, since I had a unknown one.

I was pretty certain it was you, was thinking about Vig killing you, but SBG was on my mind as a possibility.  Figured RB was safer, if I RB you and wasn't killed I would start next day knowing it was you.  Didn't want to Vig kill you and be wrong and hurt town chances.  Wouldn't of mattered I guess what action I used, wouldn't of worked. 

 

But well played, good win.  TW certainly made me think about a lot, even after dead with his setup.  

 

 

Your Vig kill would have gone through. The extra ability stopped all non kill abilities.

 

This is correct.

[SeaBeeGipson]

Do we already have the link to scum chat?

[Chaplain of death]

I don't think he posted it so here goes Scum chat

[Lord MK]

TW when is the next game?

[The Warrior]

I'll probably put out a signup thread in the next few days (maybe today).

[Lord MK]

Good, waiting for that.