910 replies to this topic

[Lord MK]

Vote Count:

 

Canik(3): vgmmaster, FrigidInferno, GoldIron

SeaBeeGipson (1): Canik

Lachiton (1): brewersalliance

KitKat16 (1): lachiton

legoboyvdlp (1): SeaBeeGipson

Robert2424 (1): legoboyvdlp

GoldIron (1): The Warrior

The Warrior (1): Rafay

Brewersalliance (0):

KevinH (0): 

Vgmmaster (0): 

Rafay (0): 

iSocialism (0): 

FrigidInferno (0):

 

No Lynch (1): KevinH

 

Not Voting: KitKat16, Robert2424, iSocialism

 

With 14 alive, it takes 8 to lynch or 4 at deadline.

Deadline is Wednesday, 27th December at 11 AM, CN Time.

[legoboyvdlp]

 

Wtf?
Hmm... ok...?
Well... only one way to find out and that is
 

Why would you vote Robert when KitKat was the one who said it?
If KitKat said it, hoping you'd lynch him as he mentioned two townies, so we'd follow suit and lynch them both, why would we start with Robert?
Why would recommend leaving KitKat to Day 2? Are you insinuating the cop should investigate KitKat? That requires 1 - no one to block the cops ability or no roles to alter KitKat's results, and 2) us to have a cop.

Unvote
Vote Lego

I fail to see your logic here

 

 

I chose Robert randomly from between The Warrior and Robert. I believed it was best to leave Kitkat alone to see a) what information he is alluding to on day 2 and if he is lying or not, depending on what investigative roles there are in the game. It will be clear if his information regarding Robert proves to be false. On the other hand, an investigative role could also investigate the named people tonight, but that also depends on exactly those points which you mentioned. 

Just so you know, those sunglasses were meant to be b ), but turns out to be short for the sunglasses emoticon. I can't edit it to fix it. 

[FrigidInferno]

It would really suck if we didnt have a cop though, re-reading through the roles it sounds semi powerful compared to others such as 1-night vig or Neighborizer(which, btw, sounds a lot like a role-blocker to me). Hopefully someone chose it so we can have a little more umphh.

Canik sounds too much like trump(who btw was/is possibly facing impeachment charges, cant remember if their still going on) so I still say we need to be rid of him

 

Wtf?
Hmm... ok...?
Well... only one way to find out and that is
 

Why would you vote Robert when KitKat was the one who said it?
If KitKat said it, hoping you'd lynch him as he mentioned two townies, so we'd follow suit and lynch them both, why would we start with Robert?
Why would recommend leaving KitKat to Day 2? Are you insinuating the cop should investigate KitKat? That requires 1 - no one to block the cops ability or no roles to alter KitKat's results, and 2) us to have a cop.
Unvote
Vote Lego
I fail to see your logic here
 

 
I chose Robert randomly from between The Warrior and Robert. I believed it was best to leave Kitkat alone to see a) what information he is alluding to on day 2 and if he is lying or not, depending on what investigative roles there are in the game. It will be clear if his information regarding Robert proves to be false. On the other hand, an investigative role could also investigate the named people tonight, but that also depends on exactly those points which you mentioned. Just so you know, those sunglasses were meant to be b ), but turns out to be short for the sunglasses emoticon. I can't edit it to fix it. 

I also believe that kitkat should be investigated night 2, considering the fact that if kit IS mafia, kit might be making a bluff to get rid of two non-mafia. So if someone investigates the others and finds them inno, we can move on to other sus rather than lynching them. Not sure if what I said makes sense but imo the warrior and robert are now the last on my sus list.
I'll try to sum it up: Kit comes out as mafia, it turns out kit IS actually mafia, so now we are desperate to lynch/kill tw and robert, who, for all we know, could be the more powerful townies or at the other end of the spectrucm, a fruit vendor and a neighborizer.

Then theres the other side where tw and robert ARE mafia, but we think kit is bluffing so we do nothing at all.
Im just putting this out here

[Kitkat16]

oh lol you actually took my joke seriously

 

guys i can assure you this is going absolutely nowhere i selected two random people and thought you'd see the joke

[legoboyvdlp]

It would really suck if we didnt have a cop though, re-reading through the roles it sounds semi powerful compared to others such as 1-night vig or Neighborizer(which, btw, sounds a lot like a role-blocker to me). Hopefully someone chose it so we can have a little more umphh.

 

 

/ begin OOC

 

There is a 50/50 cop / role blocker chance, btw, and 25% chance (in perfect circumstances) to have a town cop. Although, tbf a mafia cop doesn't make much sense, though a mafia roleblocker definitely does. Cop is indeed the most powerful role in many circumstanced but arguably others like Doctor can be just as good.

 

/ end OOC

Based on Kitkat's words, I'll unvote and wait and see if we have any investigation results tomorrow from anyone

 

Unvote

[Robert2424]

It would really suck if we didnt have a cop though, re-reading through the roles it sounds semi powerful compared to others such as 1-night vig or Neighborizer(which, btw, sounds a lot like a role-blocker to me). Hopefully someone chose it so we can have a little more umphh.

Canik sounds too much like trump(who btw was/is possibly facing impeachment charges, cant remember if their still going on) so I still say we need to be rid of him

 

 

Wtf?
Hmm... ok...?
Well... only one way to find out and that is
 

Why would you vote Robert when KitKat was the one who said it?
If KitKat said it, hoping you'd lynch him as he mentioned two townies, so we'd follow suit and lynch them both, why would we start with Robert?
Why would recommend leaving KitKat to Day 2? Are you insinuating the cop should investigate KitKat? That requires 1 - no one to block the cops ability or no roles to alter KitKat's results, and 2) us to have a cop.
Unvote
Vote Lego
I fail to see your logic here
 
 

 
I chose Robert randomly from between The Warrior and Robert. I believed it was best to leave Kitkat alone to see a) what information he is alluding to on day 2 and if he is lying or not, depending on what investigative roles there are in the game. It will be clear if his information regarding Robert proves to be false. On the other hand, an investigative role could also investigate the named people tonight, but that also depends on exactly those points which you mentioned. Just so you know, those sunglasses were meant to be b ), but turns out to be short for the sunglasses emoticon. I can't edit it to fix it. 

I also believe that kitkat should be investigated night 2, considering the fact that if kit IS mafia, kit might be making a bluff to get rid of two non-mafia. So if someone investigates the others and finds them inno, we can move on to other sus rather than lynching them. Not sure if what I said makes sense but imo the warrior and robert are now the last on my sus list.
I'll try to sum it up: Kit comes out as mafia, it turns out kit IS actually mafia, so now we are desperate to lynch/kill tw and robert, who, for all we know, could be the more powerful townies or at the other end of the spectrucm, a fruit vendor and a neighborizer.

Then theres the other side where tw and robert ARE mafia, but we think kit is bluffing so we do nothing at all.
Im just putting this out here

 

If me and The Warrior were on a team together, it be entirely unfair to the town. I'm  going to put  that out there. 

 

I'm not certain where this conversation  has merit, how  would scum bid for Town roles, don't they already have there own roles.  Plus,  lets say they did. They wouldn't  get "Cop", They  get "Role Cop", where they be able to instigate somebody and  figure  out there exact role. Thats what I'd do. but still  something suspicious to note down. 

 

Vote SLMK   (Since he didn't see it before)

 

I would respond to lego, but he's done enough to draw attention to himself. 

[Lord MK]

So a few rules which need to be taught to the new players.

Scum members are banned from telling on their fellow scum partners under any circumstances.
This has been one of the cardinal rules of mafia from its beginning.

So don't take jokes seriously.
KitKat, stop making jokes.  

Robert, i noticed your vote.
But i can assure you that if you do that one more time, i will reveal your role to everyone.

[Kitkat16]

So a few rules which need to be taught to the new players.

Scum members are banned from telling on their fellow scum partners under any circumstances.
This has been one of the cardinal rules of mafia from its beginning.

So don't take jokes seriously.
KitKat, stop making jokes.  

Robert, i noticed your vote.
But i can assure you that if you do that one more time, i will reveal your role to everyone.

 

stop making jokes!? do you know whom it is you're talking to? my dear boy, taking the piss is as essential to my being as breathing, i just can't stop

 

i had something else to say, but i've decided to retract it for now, we'll see how things unfold

[legoboyvdlp]

Scum members are banned from telling on their fellow scum partners under any circumstances.
This has been one of the cardinal rules of mafia from its beginning.

Well, I really took that a bit too seriously... lel.

[Canik]

Also I didn't really found Ninok. That's just something I roam the streets saying when I'm drunk.

Kind of interesting how a wagon started over that tho.  I'm sure at least 1 or 2 were townies joking around b/c day 1 and stuff but maybe one was an over-eager Mafia. If I had to guess I'd say GoldIron since his placed the 3rd vote. You see a wagon starting, think not much harm in trying to build the momentum of it at that point. I'm on to you, GoldIron!

[brewersalliance]

alright, im back.  before you say im scum for being away for a while and just appearing now, I have been marathoning star wars, and saw the new one a bunch of times over the past two days... priorities

 

with that being said, I havent really seen anything that screams someone is scum or town at the moment.  KevinH did point out that mafia would never vote off their own D1, which makes me think of he changes his vote to someone, and that person ends up being scum, KevinH would end up prob being scum.  I also wouldnt be shocked if someone from scum has placed an early lulz vote on another scum to give them cover in the future.

 

with that being said, im curios to see where this goes.  maybe we will get lucky and hit pay dirt with a scum lynch D1.  its not likely but hey anythings possible.

 

I also think if scum had high draft pics, the probably wouldnt pick cop, as yeah it would take it away from town, but even if scum didnt get cop, there is still only a 50% chance town would end up with cop, so I feel it would be a waste.  I could see scum going for role cop, doctor.  Question:  if the scum got a killing power role, like for example 1 shot vigi, does that mean the night they use that, the scum can have 2 kills or does using that power replace their regular kill?

[legoboyvdlp]

tbf the two on the wagon are first time players, though Inferno or whatever he calls himself is an experienced Town of Salem player apparently. But a wagon forming 2/3 days into day 1 is rather interesting.

[brewersalliance]

tbf the two on the wagon are first time players, though Inferno or whatever he calls himself is an experienced Town of Salem player apparently. But a wagon forming 2/3 days into day 1 is rather interesting.

Yeah if Canik is lynched and ends up being town, then whoever hammered that vote in would be pretty suspicious to me

[Lord MK]

Question:  if the scum got a killing power role, like for example 1 shot vigi, does that mean the night they use that, the scum can have 2 kills or does using that power replace their regular kill?

 

The abilities granted by a person's role and their faction's kill is independent of each other. 

 

 

So a few rules which need to be taught to the new players.

Scum members are banned from telling on their fellow scum partners under any circumstances.
This has been one of the cardinal rules of mafia from its beginning.

So don't take jokes seriously.
KitKat, stop making jokes.  

Robert, i noticed your vote.
But i can assure you that if you do that one more time, i will reveal your role to everyone.

 

stop making jokes!? do you know whom it is you're talking to? my dear boy, taking the piss is as essential to my being as breathing, i just can't stop

 

i had something else to say, but i've decided to retract it for now, we'll see how things unfold

 

 

i didn't mean to be rude, but there are kids here and they don't get our jokes. so i just warned you to be careful.

 

Vote Count:

 

Canik(3): vgmmaster, FrigidInferno, GoldIron

SeaBeeGipson (1): Canik

Lachiton (1): brewersalliance

KitKat16 (1): lachiton

legoboyvdlp (1): SeaBeeGipson

GoldIron (1): The Warrior

The Warrior (1): Rafay

Robert2424 (0): 

Brewersalliance (0):

KevinH (0): 

Vgmmaster (0): 

Rafay (0): 

iSocialism (0): 

FrigidInferno (0):

 

No Lynch (1): KevinH

 

Not Voting: KitKat16, Robert2424, iSocialism, legoboyvdlp

 

With 14 alive, it takes 8 to lynch or 4 at deadline.

Deadline is Wednesday, 27th December at 11 AM, CN Time.

[brewersalliance]

brewersalliance, on 16 Dec 2017 - 09:20, said: Question:  if the scum got a killing power role, like for example 1 shot vigi, does that mean the night they use that, the scum can have 2 kills or does using that power replace their regular kill?   The abilities granted by a person's role and their faction's kill is independent of each other.   

 

 

thats what I thought just wanted to make sure.  if they got a high draft pick, it wouldnt shock me if they went for killing roles, since they could get double kills then 

[legoboyvdlp]

I would respond to lego, but he's done enough to draw attention to himself. 

 

This in itself makes me a bit suspicious of you, completely apart from what KitKat posted, which I now realize was indeed a joke. In my opinion, your message would appear to be a statement that while appearing the opposite is trying to portray me as mafia by drawing attention to my posts, and possibly an attempt to subtly manipulate town against me, (as if I haven't done enough of that myself...). But I'll leave this as a FOS: I'm not going to commit to voting on you just yet until I've had a look at your other posts, which may cause me to remove my FOS. 

 

FOS Robert2424

I'd appreciate any thoughts on what I just posted about Robert.

[brewersalliance]

 

 

I would respond to lego, but he's done enough to draw attention to himself. 

 

This in itself makes me a bit suspicious of you, completely apart from what KitKat posted, which I now realize was indeed a joke. In my opinion, your message would appear to be a statement that while appearing the opposite is trying to portray me as mafia by drawing attention to my posts, and possibly an attempt to subtly manipulate town against me, (as if I haven't done enough of that myself...). But I'll leave this as a FOS: I'm not going to commit to voting on you just yet until I've had a look at your other posts, which may cause me to remove my FOS. 

 

FOS Robert2424

I'd appreciate any thoughts on what I just posted about Robert.

 

I would agree with you.  I find it suspicious he does not give any reason for his suspicions of you, trying to make it seem like its obvious that everyone should suspect you.  its probably nothing but hey you never know

also

Unvote:  Lachiton

 

Vote: GoldIron

 

for only making one post this entire game and the post was GoldIron voting to join the wagon on Canik, with legit no reason at all

[iSocialism]

I want to be suspicious. Dibs on the hammer

[Canik]

You're always suspicious, iSoc

As is Robert

[Lachiton]

So Kitkat makes a joke and as a result 2 people came under suspicion immediately. Well done dude!
Yeah my vote and FOS still remains firmly on you. You do tend to do some serious business with your jokes