341 replies to this topic

[brewersalliance]

I don't think Kevin was scum, he was trying to be helpful, but then that could have been a smoke screen. Missed a lot yesterday because of work so playing catch up.

He wasn't scum. We already know he wasn't. Kevin was a paranoid cop. Only town can have cop roles.
 

 

Well, the FOS is meh. but Kevin wouldn't of been my first choice if I was scum, or even second. The vote was left over and I didn't bother to take it off. If I was truely wanting to lynch him, I'd be more vocal about it. 
 
Sanity will probally be a issue. Did anybody get a guilty result last night?

 
I did, on brewers. Which is why i was wondering if anyone else investigated him so i could confirm it
 

Interesting. Is "Guilty" the actual way your result was returned to you?
 

 

 

Well, the FOS is meh. but Kevin wouldn't of been my first choice if I was scum, or even second. The vote was left over and I didn't bother to take it off. If I was truely wanting to lynch him, I'd be more vocal about it. 
 
Sanity will probally be a issue. Did anybody get a guilty result last night?
 

 
I did, on brewers. Which is why i was wondering if anyone else investigated him so i could confirm it

Alright so MedVed is either scum trying to get me lynched or he has a sanity that is impacting his result. If you guys start to trend to vote for me, I do have a way that can 100% confirm I am town
However I obviously don't want to have to do that unless I am dead in the water
 

It's far too early in the game for Medved to come out saying he got a guilty result on one person if he was lying. He would surely be lynched the next day for lying. That means that it is far more likely that one of the following two things is true:
 
1) You are scum.
2) Medved is not a sane cop.
 
Unless I am missing something the only ways that Medved could have received a "guilty" result of any kind on Brewers are the following:
1) Brewers is scum and Medved is a sane cop.
2) Brewers is scum and Medved is a role cop. Since all scum are goons I guess that means that the result returned to Medved would be "Goon" which obviously makes Brewers scum.
3) Brewers is not scum and Medved is an insane cop who received an incorrect negative result (guilty).
4) Brewers is/or isn't scum and Medved is a paranoid cop which always receives results indicative of non-town (guilty).
 
So again, unless I'm missing something, I see three possible ways that Brewers came up as "guilty" to Medved and two ways that the result could have been incorrect (unless Medved was just straight up lying).

Well since I know I'm town the options in my eyes are MedVed is either lying or MedVed has a sanity. I don't think it's very likely he is lying so I am betting he is either insane or paranoid

[Wolfpacks]

I don't think Kevin was scum, he was trying to be helpful, but then that could have been a smoke screen. Missed a lot yesterday because of work so playing catch up.

He wasn't scum. We already know he wasn't. Kevin was a paranoid cop. Only town can have cop roles.

5 games under my belt and still a novice

[Rafay]

Unless I am missing something the only ways that Medved could have received a "guilty" result of any kind on Brewers are the following: 1) Brewers is scum and Medved is a sane cop. 2) Brewers is scum and Medved is a role cop. Since all scum are goons I guess that means that the result returned to Medved would be "Goon" which obviously makes Brewers scum. 3) Brewers is not scum and Medved is an insane cop who received an incorrect negative result (guilty). 4) Brewers is/or isn't scum and Medved is a paranoid cop which always receives results indicative of non-town (guilty).

 

My head hurts. 

[Mandarijn]

 

 

Well, the FOS is meh. but Kevin wouldn't of been my first choice if I was scum, or even second. The vote was left over and I didn't bother to take it off. If I was truely wanting to lynch him, I'd be more vocal about it. 
 
Sanity will probally be a issue. Did anybody get a guilty result last night?
 

 
I did, on brewers. Which is why i was wondering if anyone else investigated him so i could confirm it

Alright so MedVed is either scum trying to get me lynched or he has a sanity that is impacting his result. If you guys start to trend to vote for me, I do have a way that can 100% confirm I am town
However I obviously don't want to have to do that unless I am dead in the water

 

Now you've made me really curious...

[Robert2424]

Should we make a list. Who's got investigated and result? There could be someone from last night who wasn't investigated at all. Or several people investigated say brewers.

[Colonel Medved]

Interesting. Is "Guilty" the actual way your result was returned to you?

 

 

Yes, the message said Guilty

 

I was hoping someone else investigated him also, so we could confirm if he is really scum or if i'm not sane.

[Lachiton]

Multiple investigations on brewers can confirm his alignment. At this moment its too early to speculate who is scum and we cant go by one cop result alone because of the sanities involved.

[Lord MK]

How does one know for sure that they are town?
Other than their role pm. They don't have any other proof.
Brewers, what kind of proof are you talking about?

[brewersalliance]

I'm not sharing it until I absolutely have to

[SeaBeeGipson]

We have multiple cops I assume, so everyone flooding Brewers is probably not the best option as we lose sight of other people in the game.

I got a guilty on Robert2424.

Not sure my sanity yet. Do we have multiple sanities? I.E more than 1 paranoid cop, etc?

[Colonel Medved]

We have multiple cops I assume, so everyone flooding Brewers is probably not the best option as we lose sight of other people in the game.

I got a guilty on Robert2424.

Not sure my sanity yet. Do we have multiple sanities? I.E more than 1 paranoid cop, etc?

I know in the rules, isoc said that it was possible that every cop could be the same. So who knows

[The Warrior]

I'm not sharing it until I absolutely have to

I'm not asking you to share it yet but I am curious about what proof you could have that would clear you unequivocally.

 

We have multiple cops I assume, so everyone flooding Brewers is probably not the best option as we lose sight of other people in the game.

I got a guilty on Robert2424.

Not sure my sanity yet. Do we have multiple sanities? I.E more than 1 paranoid cop, etc?

All town players are cops of some sort. iSoc said that it was completely random which cop roles were assigned to us. It is possible that we are all the same type of cop or that there could be 8 different cop roles in the game.

[iSocialism]

Vote count: Day Twice
1. Lord MK (0);
2. Colonel MedVed (0);
3. Brewersalliance (0); The Warrior
4. Robert2424 (0); SeaBeaGipson
5. The Warrior (0);
6. SeaBeaGipson (0);
7. KevinH killed night one
8. Lachiton (0);
9. Rafay (0);
10. Canik (0);
11. Mandarijn (0); Brewersalliance
12. KitKat16 (0);
13. Wolfpack (0);

14. No Lynch (0);


Not voting: Lachiton, Canik, KitKat16, Wolfpack, Mandarjin, Rafay, Colonel Medved, Lord MK, Robert2424

 

With 12 alive, it takes 7 to lynch, or 4 at deadline.
Deadline is Saturday, June 30, 2018 at 10:00 CN Time

[brewersalliance]

i suppose I should take my troll/lulz vote off mandy now lol

 

unvote

 

vote:  no lynch

 

we have enough cops that we dont need to really lynch someone yet until we have something more concrete to go on, and all scum are goons, so they have no power roles

I'm not asking you to share it yet but I am curious about what proof you could have that would clear you unequivocally.

 

 

i guess it wouldnt 100% clear me, but with this format for the game it is probably as close to 100% clearing someone as possible

[Lord MK]

I'm not sold on your point.

[The Warrior]

By the way, I just noticed this:

 

With 12 alive, it takes 7 to lynch, or 4 at deadline.
Deadline is Saturday, June 30, 2018 at 10:00 CN Time

Deadline is tomorrow at 10:00. There has not been much discussion today and only three people have voted so far.

 

Does anyone else have any thoughts to share at this point?

[brewersalliance]

yeah this game has been kind of dead.  though nothing juicy has really happened yet.  hopefully it picks up.  it seems like a lot of people have been quiet and not talking.  Maybe isoc needs to consider a minimum post count and use mod kills to get some of u folks talking/active

[Colonel Medved]

yeah this game has been kind of dead.  though nothing juicy has really happened yet.  hopefully it picks up.  it seems like a lot of people have been quiet and not talking.  Maybe isoc needs to consider a minimum post count and use mod kills to get some of u folks talking/active

 

I'm guessing its going to take some time before things really get moving, because we don't even know to trust our intel until someone else happens to confirm it. Even then both people could be not sane

[brewersalliance]

very true.  tho we have 12 people and it feels like some of them have not even posted once on D2

Member name Posts brewersalliance 22 Robert2424 12 The Warrior 10 KevinH 10 Mandarijn 10 iSocialism 9 Rafay 9 Wolfpacks 9 Colonel Medved 8 Lord MK 7 SeaBeeGipson 5 Lachiton 3 Canik 3 Kitkat16 2

 

 

I dont think we have heard from either of them today.  Lach was in the hospital so he gets a pass in my eyes

[Lord MK]

Guys, start voting.

Vote: brewersalliance

Nothing in this game clears one absolutely