622 replies to this topic

[Lachiton]

 

Well, on the bright side gun is in the hands of an active townie. Though we have one more town dead, the chances of hitting scum has gone up. 
 
I did start the wagon on Robert but the reasons I voted for him are the same with which I had spat with him early on.
 
 
Anyways I agree with the assessment that we have at least 1 scum on the wagon. Amongst the 4 of us, my top suspect for scum on Robert's wagon is SM.

As for suspects outside the wagon, WP is the one to stand out. SBG does seem slightly town to me as he was the first to point out my subtle reveal of my role PM as that of a town.

 

Why am I at the top of your wagon list?

 

I am going by the possibility that if there was a scum on Robert's wagon, then it might likely be you. I know I am town, TW questioned Robert twice before voting, brewers cast the proverbial hammer and have taken considerable amount of time analyzing and asking questions around which is a townie thing to do. So that leaves you unfortunately.

Not saying there is certain scum on the wagon but if it were, to me it would be probably you.

[brewersalliance]

Looking back on it, WP hasnt really contributed much this game, other than following my vote on SBG almost instantly, without providing any reason why he did so.  Maybe it was an attempt to quickly form a wagon.  

 

While his inactivity does not scream scum, it certainly does not help his case for being town.  I know ive stated my suspicions multiple times, but before I place a vote I would like to hear from wolfpacks, but if he doesnt show up and actually contribute, I think I may be joining Lachiton with voting for him 

[Robert2424]

Wolfpacks activity in mafia has always been a problem. 

[Colonel Medved]

Suspicion Count

 

 

“I am your father’s brother’s nephew’s cousin’s former roommate.”

- Lord Dark Helmet

 

 

brewersalliance (0):

SeaBeeGipson (0):

Robert2424 (0): 

Lachiton (0):

The Warrior (0): 

Wolfpacks (1): Lachiton

Rafay (0):

Sister Midnight (0): 

 

 

Not Voting: brewersalliance, SeaBeeGipson, Robert2424, The Warrior, Wolfpacks, Rafay, Sister Midnight

 

Deadline is October 22nd, 9:00AM CN for Robert2424 to Shoot

[Robert2424]

I'm not trying to sell Kevin short at all. or to try to say he isn't a good player. I however think its more likely a wagon and lynch to form on a kevin in a given game, then TW. 

[Lord MK]

I'm not trying to sell Kevin short at all. or to try to say he isn't a good player. I however think its more likely a wagon and lynch to form on a kevin in a given game, then TW.

Isn't ol' Kevin dead?

[brewersalliance]

 

I'm not trying to sell Kevin short at all. or to try to say he isn't a good player. I however think its more likely a wagon and lynch to form on a kevin in a given game, then TW.

Isn't ol' Kevin dead?

 

yes and so are you lol 

[Sister Midnight]

 

 

I'm not trying to sell Kevin short at all. or to try to say he isn't a good player. I however think its more likely a wagon and lynch to form on a kevin in a given game, then TW.

Isn't ol' Kevin dead?

 

yes and so are you lol 

 

Brewsky, why are you talking to a ghost who isn't supposed to be posting?  No offense to anyone dead of alive.

[brewersalliance]

 

 

 

I'm not trying to sell Kevin short at all. or to try to say he isn't a good player. I however think its more likely a wagon and lynch to form on a kevin in a given game, then TW.

Isn't ol' Kevin dead?

 

yes and so are you lol 

 

Brewsky, why are you talking to a ghost who isn't supposed to be posting?  No offense to anyone dead of alive.

 

that was my passive aggressive way of saying "youre dead no talking"

[Rafay]

I'm suspecting The Warrior, brewsers, SM and Wolfpacks.

 

SM & WP for reasons already mentioned and brewsers and The Warrior for being overly active and mis-voting on Robert.  

[Robert2424]

 

 

 

 

I'm not trying to sell Kevin short at all. or to try to say he isn't a good player. I however think its more likely a wagon and lynch to form on a kevin in a given game, then TW.

Isn't ol' Kevin dead?

 

yes and so are you lol 

 

Brewsky, why are you talking to a ghost who isn't supposed to be posting?  No offense to anyone dead of alive.

 

that was my passive aggressive way of saying "youre dead no talking"

 

At least I'm not the one who said it. 

[Wolfpacks]

Sorry busy at work, correct me if I'm wrong but wasn't Kevin's list made up from some monetary thing, not any proven evidence. By killing me your only giving me the gun to kill with

[Sister Midnight]

Sorry busy at work, correct me if I'm wrong but wasn't Kevin's list made up from some monetary thing, not any proven evidence. By killing me your only giving me the gun to kill with

I had the same thought about the fact that Kevin made his choices randomly. I find it curious that some people are trying to turn his remarks about individuals into some kind of oracle.

[brewersalliance]

Sorry busy at work, correct me if I'm wrong but wasn't Kevin's list made up from some monetary thing, not any proven evidence. By killing me your only giving me the gun to kill with

 

 

 

Sorry busy at work, correct me if I'm wrong but wasn't Kevin's list made up from some monetary thing, not any proven evidence. By killing me your only giving me the gun to kill with

I had the same thought about the fact that Kevin made his choices randomly. I find it curious that some people are trying to turn his remarks about individuals into some kind of oracle.

 

his list of three wasnt done randomly tho, those were just three people he thought might be scum.  im not saying we should go off his list, i was just telling robert who was on it. 

 

we still have a couple days until deadlime, but it would be nice to hear from SBG, and hear more than just "im busy/will post later" from Wolfpacks... 

 

come on guys what are your thoughts?  

[Wolfpacks]

I drive for a living so time at home is limited, I post what I can inbetween breaks, and what I can when im home, I don't really have the time to a real in-depth post but I will see what I can come up with.

[Robert2424]

The weekend is fast approaching, and I'm still not sure who to shoot. I have till Monday morning, but I'd rather decide by Sunday. As my schedule is changing at work, activity might drop between now and Sunday also.

[Sister Midnight]

Who are you leaning towards?

[brewersalliance]

Right now, for me its between Wolfpacks, SM, and SBG.  I feel fairly confident that at least two, if not all three of our remaining scum are in that group.

 

Vote:  Sister Midnight

 

something just feels off with her.  every time someone has talked about her being potentially scum, she has gotten very defensive.  Plus the whole "sbg is scum" thing that she did over and over again, then claiming it was a joke just feels off.  I get if you are saying it once it might be a joke, but when you say it multiple times throughout the game, it feels like a bit more than a joke and more of an attempt to get it to stick. So i am not buying her reasoning that it was just a joke.  I think it could be very convenient cover.  It would not shock me one bit if both SM and SBG are scum partners and she has been trying to bus from him this entire game.  

[The Warrior]

Sorry busy at work, correct me if I'm wrong but wasn't Kevin's list made up from some monetary thing, not any proven evidence. By killing me your only giving me the gun to kill with

Kevin's "list" wasn't based off of his stock market thing, only his final decision to shoot was. The list he put together was people he thought could be scum. Yes it was all speculation but that's all any of us have in this game.

 

I'm still torn on what I think at this point. Not much has changed for me since this post:

 

I don't have any real strong suspicion yet but I want to hear more from SM, SBG, Wolfpacks, and Rafay. I think that at least two of our remaining scum are in this grouping but I wouldn't be surprised if all three ended up here.

 

SM has continued to try to walk back the SBG comments and could have been scum on Robert's wagon. SBG is still not active enough in my opinion and needs to post more. Neither Wolfpacks nor Rafay are particularly active and neither voted for anyone to shoot yesterday.

[Sister Midnight]

Sigh. I don’t think you can categorize most of what I’ve said as very defensive. But I notice that Brewers voted for very quickly when I pondered him and TW giving a lot of weight to Kev’s remarks when he randomly executed players. Am I touching a nerve, Brewsky?