622 replies to this topic

[brewersalliance]

I think Rafay is most likely town. He's been scum in two games I've played and town in the rest and I've noticed a difference in how he plays as scum as town. Sure he does some very questionable stuff as town, but I've noticed as scum he would echo the posts of someone else in the game who was also scum. Now obviously people can intentionally change their game play styles but in this case I am gonna give Rafay then benefit of the doubt for now. So I don't think he should be the Target of the shot.

We still have until October 4th, so plenty of time to discuss things.

As for MK, he did backtrack quickly, which could be scum realizing he got outed for his plan, or it could be exactly what he said. This is a new game style we haven't played before so could have just interpreted it wrong. However at the moment I think he's our best suspect, but like I said let's not rush this. We still need to hear fro. SM and Velocity.

One thing I thought of was what kind of person should we shoot? In this game, targeting an inactive is a huge risk. If they are town, they become the gun bearer and if they continue to be inactive, they would die if they miss the deadline and scum gets to pick the next gun bearer. So shooting an inactive townie has the ability bro pretty much lose the game for us. So if there are four scum, I would not be shocked if one of them realized that and hid out as an inactive, like SM and Velocity have done so far. Pretty much until we shoot a scum, the inactive players have a bit of a shield around them...

[The Warrior]

One thing I thought of was what kind of person should we shoot? In this game, targeting an inactive is a huge risk. If they are town, they become the gun bearer and if they continue to be inactive, they would die if they miss the deadline and scum gets to pick the next gun bearer. So shooting an inactive townie has the ability bro pretty much lose the game for us. So if there are four scum, I would not be shocked if one of them realized that and hid out as an inactive, like SM and Velocity have done so far. Pretty much until we shoot a scum, the inactive players have a bit of a shield around them...

 

This point is an interesting one but the philosophy isn't that much different than a normal mafia game imo. You certainly don't want an inactive gunbearer (assuming that he/she is town since you could lose them to inactivity early on) but you also don't want to just shoot active players because if active town gunbearers get killed off it could leave us in a situation in a couple days where we need a kill but the gun falls to a more inactive gunbearer who then could somehow miss deadline at a crucial time and lose the game.  

 

Our best option is to have everyone actively contributing. It's harder for the mafia to hide when they are forced to talk regularly. This is even more important in this game since we know that there is no other way to get information. We need to give Kevin every opportunity to make the best decision possible for the town's first shot.

[brewersalliance]

This point is an interesting one but the philosophy isn't that much different than a normal mafia game imo. You certainly don't want an inactive gunbearer (assuming that he/she is town since you could lose them to inactivity early on) but you also don't want to just shoot active players because if active town gunbearers get killed off it could leave us in a situation in a couple days where we need a kill but the gun falls to a more inactive gunbearer who then could somehow miss deadline at a crucial time and lose the game.  

 

 

Yes but there is more danger with targeting an inactive this time around, as they will not die, and the active person who targets them would die in their place, and then they could miss the shot, and a 100% confirmed town would die the next day.  So basically choosing an inactive has the potential to kill two 100% confirmed by the mod townies, which would basically kill our chances at winning-especially cause the scum then get to pick the next gun bearer.  It makes hiding out there a bit safer, because in no way is it worth the risk to shoot one of them with kevin's first shot.  if he does and they are town, town could basically lose on d1.

[Lachiton]

You said it yourself that scum, knowing that there will be hesitancy in targeting inactive as the said inactive will wield the gun, can just hide in the shadows and let town kill of all active players one by one, basically losing the game. We cant afford anyone to be inactive in this game. Even though scum cant kill, it is very easy for them to hide as lynch wagons cant be formed and analyzed.

[Robert2424]

why  dose rafay have a gun?

[brewersalliance]

why  dose rafay have a gun?

he doesnt.  

[KevinH]

So much pressure ...
 
Post count:
9 brewersalliance
6 The Warrior
5 Lord MK
5 Robert2424
4 Lachiton
3 KevinH
3 SeaBeeGipson
3 Rafay
2 Wolfpacks
 
How to decide?

[SeaBeeGipson]

So much pressure ...
 
Post count:
9 brewersalliance
6 The Warrior
5 Lord MK
5 Robert2424
4 Lachiton
3 KevinH
3 SeaBeeGipson
3 Rafay
2 Wolfpacks
 
How to decide?

By alphabetical order. In all honestly I need to read up. I'm still curious why scum didnt pick an inactive inexperienced target. Where are Velocity and SM?

[The Warrior]

So much pressure ...
 
Post count:
9 brewersalliance
6 The Warrior
5 Lord MK
5 Robert2424
4 Lachiton
3 KevinH
3 SeaBeeGipson
3 Rafay
2 Wolfpacks
 
How to decide?

What are your thoughts at this point? What strategy do you think we should use in this game?

[KevinH]

Giving a gun and having that person miss is the way that the scum kills people.  I was their first target.

 

Everyone should write a 100-word essay on why I shouldn't shoot them.

[Lachiton]

I aint writing any essay   

My posts in the first page is indicative enough that I am town 

[brewersalliance]

I aint writing any essay   

 

 

Grammar: 0/10

See me after class

[Colonel Medved]

 

• You must remain active to be in this game. If you do not post within a 72 hour period you may be force-replaced.

 

I've added an Activity Rule to prevent the "inactive gunbearer" possibility. SM and Velocity have until the 30th to join the game, or they will be replaced.

[Colonel Medved]

Suspicion Count

 

"Well let me just quote the late-great Colonel Sanders, who said..."I'm too drunk to taste this chicken."

- Ricky Bobby

 

 

brewersalliance (0):

SeaBeeGipson (0): 

Robert2424 (0):

Lachiton (0): 

The Warrior (0): 

Wolfpacks (0): 

Lord MK (1): brewersalliance 

KevinH (0): 

Rafay (1): Wolfpacks 

Sister Midnight (0): 

Velocity (0): 

 

No Lynch: KevinH

 

Not Voting: SeaBeeGipson, Robert2424, Lachiton, The Warrior, Lord MK, KevinH, Rafay, Sister Midnight, Velocity

Deadline is October 4th, 9:00AM CN for Kevin to Shoot

[Robert2424]

Well, good to know. The choice is entirely up to Kevin. He could do whatever he pleases. He could shot the most active player or the least, the most popular, least popular, if he wants revenge on somebody he could choose that person as well. Till then, he can point the gun in any direction and there isn't a thing any of us can do to stop him. 

[Rafay]

Giving a gun and having that person miss is the way that the scum kills people.  I was their first target.

 

 

They wanted you out 1st day. A fine strategy indeed.

 

Any choices? Do you have an old grudge against someone?

 

Also no essay coming from me.

[Wolfpacks]

Kevin is probably right, on mafia scum it does say 4 scum, so i don't think MedVed would have chanced it up. That would be a big risk Ballance wise, so I think we need to assume Kevin is right. That means we can miss two shots at most. If we miss 3, then scum wins.

So I still think the best way to do this is a mock vote count as it will make it easier to keep track of things for kevin

FoS MK and Wolfpacks

I think shooting Rafay would be a huge risk. Sure he could be scum but odds are he is town, and if he is town, he could be a lose cannon with the gun, so if Kevin shoots him and Rafay makes the wrong choice, we would have two townies dead, and be down to our last shot before scum wins. So if you are scum, I think Rafay would be who you want to be shot/end up with the gun.

I only voted Rafay for using that word again, not really a killing offence lol

[brewersalliance]

Oh lol well then thats fair. I'll take my FoS off wolfpacks lol

[Robert2424]

Idk, Rafay is kind of the star scream of Mafia. He's crazy in general. Less cooperative, and less reasonable then most. He'd make probably an excellent SK though, witch is actually a harder role to win as, as for town and mafia, he definitely can use some work. No way do I consider him probably town. Probably will stay that way to the end of the game unless he's confirmed by MK. 

[Velocity]

Sorry, didn't notice. Rafay, definitely. Easy vote.