622 replies to this topic

[Robert2424]

I'm not grumpy. I'm mainly bored. this mafia game is odd at best. Boring at worst.

Mk posts are wierd. Putting stock that he's trying to kill a townie has only so much merit. I'd imagine he'd avoid mentioning his scum parners unless pacifficly asked.

[brewersalliance]

 

Townies don't know anything, so "suspicions" are worthless.
But I do have some quotes from a now-known scum trying to influence me.

My top suspicion is Robert
Alluding to him knowing that Kevin has a gun.

 

2.75, huh.
Then the 0.75 is rafay.
Vote: Rafay.

 

Exactly why i am town.

I would have selected Rafay,if I am scum.
Then TW would be the next gunbearer. Admit it, Rafay has a thing for TW.
TW would be useless without information to aid him. He can't do his calculations.

The scum this time is probably a drunk SBG. Or Robert2424 (all those numbers must mean something, what gives? Probably his victim count)

 

I'm going to give townie points to anyone that Lord MK mentioned.

+1 Townie points

• Rafay
• Robert2424
• SeaBeeGipson
• The Warrior

Remaining candidates

• brewersalliance
• Lachiton
• Sister Midnight
• Velocity
• Wolfpacks

 

 

 

Why is lachiton on the list of remaining candidates?  medved legit posted confirming he sent Lachtion the town role PM.  He is for all intensive purposes confirmed town

[Robert2424]

 

 

Townies don't know anything, so "suspicions" are worthless.
But I do have some quotes from a now-known scum trying to influence me.

My top suspicion is Robert
Alluding to him knowing that Kevin has a gun.

 

2.75, huh.
Then the 0.75 is rafay.
Vote: Rafay.

 

Exactly why i am town.

I would have selected Rafay,if I am scum.
Then TW would be the next gunbearer. Admit it, Rafay has a thing for TW.
TW would be useless without information to aid him. He can't do his calculations.

The scum this time is probably a drunk SBG. Or Robert2424 (all those numbers must mean something, what gives? Probably his victim count)

 

I'm going to give townie points to anyone that Lord MK mentioned.

+1 Townie points

• Rafay
• Robert2424
• SeaBeeGipson
• The Warrior

Remaining candidates

• brewersalliance
• Lachiton
• Sister Midnight
• Velocity
• Wolfpacks

 

 

 

Why is lachiton on the list of remaining candidates?  medved legit posted confirming he sent Lachtion the town role PM.  He is for all intensive purposes confirmed town

 

where was this post?

[The Warrior]

I assume that he's referring to this one:

 

 

I guess we can vote but the person wont be lynched. My role PM says my weapon is my vote, not sure what's going on with that.

 

That's a mistake on my part, that was used in the setup on the wiki page. Didn't double check it haha

 

Voting does not count in this game, but i could keep track if you want to show who everyone thinks is suspicious 

While Medved doesn't outright say it, he does sort of imply it.

 

I think it's likely that Lachiton is town but the wording of a VT message is plainly listed on the popcorn mafia wiki page for anyone to read/recite so that doesn't 100% clear him..

[brewersalliance]

I assume that he's referring to this one:

 

 

I guess we can vote but the person wont be lynched. My role PM says my weapon is my vote, not sure what's going on with that.

 

That's a mistake on my part, that was used in the setup on the wiki page. Didn't double check it haha

 

Voting does not count in this game, but i could keep track if you want to show who everyone thinks is suspicious 

While Medved doesn't outright say it, he does sort of imply it.

 

I think it's likely that Lachiton is town but the wording of a VT message is plainly listed on the popcorn mafia wiki page for anyone to read/recite so that doesn't 100% clear him..

yes but just because its on the wiki doesnt mean thats the PM that the mod would send.  That would be one hell of a risk to fabricate that, because if medved sent something different, the entire town would have been able to call lachiton out for BS and he would have been shot right away.  would be a terrible risk as his very first post.  I think hes town

[Lachiton]

 

I assume that he's referring to this one:

 

 

I guess we can vote but the person wont be lynched. My role PM says my weapon is my vote, not sure what's going on with that.

 

That's a mistake on my part, that was used in the setup on the wiki page. Didn't double check it haha

 

Voting does not count in this game, but i could keep track if you want to show who everyone thinks is suspicious 

While Medved doesn't outright say it, he does sort of imply it.

 

I think it's likely that Lachiton is town but the wording of a VT message is plainly listed on the popcorn mafia wiki page for anyone to read/recite so that doesn't 100% clear him..

yes but just because its on the wiki doesnt mean thats the PM that the mod would send.  That would be one hell of a risk to fabricate that, because if medved sent something different, the entire town would have been able to call lachiton out for BS and he would have been shot right away.  would be a terrible risk as his very first post.  I think hes town

 

This guy gets it SBG was the other one to get it. 

 

I am disappointed that Kevin still has left me in his suspects list. TW too, but he will not have the best interest of town if he is scum.

[Wolfpacks]

Why am i a candidate,

[Velocity]

I suppose I am because there's nothing that would confirm me as innocent, but at the same time there is nothing to sway me towards scum

[KevinH]

Alright, Lachiton gets a townie point for creatively posting his role PM.
Brewers gets a half-point for pointing it out.
 
That leaves the 3 remaining scum as

• Sister Midnight
• Velocity
• Wolfpacks

So I guess I just have to shoot them and we win.

[Velocity]

Wow man that's so rude, theres no reason to just shoot me, like I've done nothing wrong. So I mean shooting me isn't the best idea man

[The Warrior]

 

I assume that he's referring to this one:
 

 

I guess we can vote but the person wont be lynched. My role PM says my weapon is my vote, not sure what's going on with that.

 
That's a mistake on my part, that was used in the setup on the wiki page. Didn't double check it haha
 
Voting does not count in this game, but i could keep track if you want to show who everyone thinks is suspicious 

While Medved doesn't outright say it, he does sort of imply it.
 
I think it's likely that Lachiton is town but the wording of a VT message is plainly listed on the popcorn mafia wiki page for anyone to read/recite so that doesn't 100% clear him..

yes but just because its on the wiki doesnt mean thats the PM that the mod would send.  That would be one hell of a risk to fabricate that, because if medved sent something different, the entire town would have been able to call lachiton out for BS and he would have been shot right away.  would be a terrible risk as his very first post.  I think hes town
 

This guy gets it SBG was the other one to get it. 
 
I am disappointed that Kevin still has left me in his suspects list. TW too, but he will not have the best interest of town if he is scum.

I didn’t say that I believed you to be a suspect. In fact I explicitly stated the opposite. I was only saying that the role pm’s were clearly spelled out on the wiki and that we shouldn’t take that as a reason to 100% clear anyone. Having said that I do believe you are likely town as I mentioned previously.

[Robert2424]

Sister midnight is scum? How could you be evil sister midnight?

[KevinH]

Was Lord MK clever enough to mention his fellow scum as suggestions for targets?

[Lachiton]

Possible. Then it is worth noting when and why MK took those names. 

I didn’t say that I believed you to be a suspect. In fact I explicitly stated the opposite. I was only saying that the role pm’s were clearly spelled out on the wiki and that we shouldn’t take that as a reason to 100% clear anyone. Having said that I do believe you are likely town as I mentioned previously.

Fair enough. Also as brewers pointed out, it will be a huge risk for scum to fake that from the wiki if Medved had changed up the role PMs, especially in this game when there's less pressure on scum to do so.  

[brewersalliance]

Was Lord MK clever enough to mention his fellow scum as suggestions for targets?

That's definitely possible, Rafay is always a common Target and of MK was the first to lead a crusade against him and Rafay flipped scum it would look good for MK. Did Rafay accuse MK of being scum after MK placed his "vote" on him? Rafay typically calls out anyone who votes him by saying things like "I found scum" and then OMGUS votes for them

[brewersalliance]

I'm not saying Rafay is scum, but I can't think of a single time when he's been town and hasn't OMGUS voted someone who suspected him the second they suggested it and I don't recall him doing that with MK when MK suggested Rafay should be the Target. So why would Rafay completely change his playstyle? Now granted he did claim Robert was scum the second Robert accused him, and perhaps that's why he didn't point out MK, but we do need to consider that he didn't call out MK right away because they are partners and MK was trying to bus from Rafay right away, since Rafay is a typical target.

Rafay might still be town as there is no way to actually investigate, and like I previously said, I still don't think he's worth the risk for Kevin to shoot as Kevin is much more valuable to the town, but if we go a day or two without hitting a scum and start to lose townies, I think he should be considered for a shot. Just not at this point as I'd have more faith in a random stock closing price picking a scum than Rafay lol

[Rafay]

I'm not saying Rafay is scum, but I can't think of a single time when he's been town and hasn't OMGUS voted someone who suspected him the second they suggested it and I don't recall him doing that with MK when MK suggested Rafay should be the Target. So why would Rafay completely change his playstyle? Now granted he did claim Robert was scum the second Robert accused him, and perhaps that's why he didn't point out MK, but we do need to consider that he didn't call out MK right away because they are partners and MK was trying to bus from Rafay right away, since Rafay is a typical target. Rafay might still be town as there is no way to actually investigate, and like I previously said, I still don't think he's worth the risk for Kevin to shoot as Kevin is much more valuable to the town, but if we go a day or two without hitting a scum and start to lose townies, I think he should be considered for a shot. Just not at this point as I'd have more faith in a random stock closing price picking a scum than Rafay lol

 

I didn't vote back cuz votes have no value in this game. 

[brewersalliance]

I didn't vote back cuz votes have no value in this game. 

 

 

thats actually a valid reason, im willing to give you the benefit of the doubt for now

[Wolfpacks]

Alright, Lachiton gets a townie point for creatively posting his role PM.
Brewers gets a half-point for pointing it out.

That leaves the 3 remaining scum as

• Sister Midnight
• Velocity
• Wolfpacks

So I guess I just have to shoot them and we win.

Give a dog/wolf a bad name and you get shot, got to keep the wolf from the door I suppose

[Velocity]

Yeah and what my name represents has to do with guns and speed so I assume I'm dangerous now